Costco Car Insurance Review

Independent insurance review

Costco Car Insurance Review

If you already pay for a warehouse membership, it makes sense to ask whether Costco car insurance can cut your premium too. The program is real; it is backed by American Family Insurance, and more than 500,000 Costco members have switched to it, according to the program’s own site. But it is not cheaper for everyone, and the best perks are reserved for Executive members.

This review sorts out what the top-ranking reviews get wrong or leave out. It explains who actually insures you after the December 2025 name change, where the program is sold, what it costs for clean-record drivers, teens, seniors, and drivers with a ticket or DUI, and how much a member can realistically save. It also covers every coverage type, all published discounts, ratings from AM Best and J.D. Power, and the pros and cons.

Costco car insurance monthly rates compared with national averages for clean records, tickets, accidents, DUI, teens and seniors.
Costco car insurance vs. national averages. Source: 2026 real-quote analysis. Averages, not quotes.

What is Costco car insurance?

Costco car insurance is a member benefit, not a Costco product. Costco Insurance Agency, Inc. is the licensed agent, and the policies are written by American Family Insurance companies. The program site states plainly that it is operated by a third party, that Costco does not underwrite policies or pay claims, and that Costco Insurance Agency may be paid for sales.

Auto policies are underwritten by one of three Wisconsin companies: American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company, American Family Connect Insurance Company, or Midvale Indemnity Company. Home and condo policies sold through the same program are underwritten by Homesite companies, and some Texas property coverage may come from Ranchers and Farmers Mutual.

From Ameriprise to CONNECT to American Family

Many older reviews still call the insurer CONNECT, and some still say Ameriprise. Both names are out of date. The company traces back to IDS Property Casualty, which sold for years as Ameriprise Auto and Home. American Family bought that business on October 1, 2019, for gross proceeds of about $1.135 billion, and the Costco partnership continued.

Costco Wholesale store with a blue SUV parked outside, illustrating a Costco car insurance review.
Who has insured Costco members
DateWhat happenedWhat it means for you
2005IDS Property Casualty begins selling as Ameriprise Auto and HomeThe original Costco auto partner
Oct. 1, 2019American Family completes its purchase of the businessA larger parent company
Aug. 4, 2020Rebranded as CONNECT, powered by American Family InsuranceCostco named a primary partner
Dec. 2025CONNECT changes its name to American Family InsuranceA name change only; policies continue
Oct. 2026AM Best affirms an A (Excellent) rating for the underwritersStrong ability to pay claims

Ameriprise Financial (October 1, 2019); Business Wire (August 4, 2020); costco.amfam.com FAQ; AM Best (October 22, 2026).

The December 2025 change matters if you are a current customer. The program’s FAQ calls it a name change only and says coverage, billing, premiums, service, and claims were not affected. The legal underwriting companies still carry “Connect” in their names, so you may see both names on your documents.

Where you can buy Costco car insurance

Availability is one of the most confusing parts of this program, because review sites disagree. Some say 42 states, others say every state but Michigan, and older articles list states that have since been added. The safest answer comes from the program’s own fine print and an up-to-date state list, and the final word is always a ZIP code quote.

Costco car insurance availability and state limits
State or ruleWhat appliesSource
MichiganNot listed among available statesDecember 2025 state list
New YorkCostco Insurance Agency is not licensed thereProgram FAQ
MassachusettsMember auto discount for Executive members onlyProgram fine print
FloridaCostco pricing on car insurance only; some Midvale policies excludedProgram fine print
TennesseeNo member discount on home or some Midvale auto policiesProgram fine print
California, Maryland, MichiganNo lifetime renewability benefitProgram fine print
Most other statesSold, but check your ZIP codeProgram site

costco.amfam.com benefits page and FAQ (accessed October 28, 2026); a state list updated December 19, 2025. Availability can change.

How much does Costco car insurance cost?

No official page publishes average prices, so independent studies are the best guide. They use different drivers and areas, so compare each study only with itself. Study A is a national real-quote analysis updated October 27, 2026, reporting averages for liability-only coverage from Costco’s insurer. Study B is an Illinois rate study updated September 30, 2026, using a 45-year-old married man with a clean record and a 2015 Honda Civic.

Costco car insurance monthly liability-only rates vs. national averages for clean records, speeding tickets, accidents, DUI, teens, and seniors.
Costco’s insurer vs. national average monthly liability-only rates. Study A; averages, not quotes.

Study A: national real-quote analysis updated October 27, 2026; liability-only averages. Averages, not quotes.

In Study A, Costco’s insurer came in below the national average for every driver type. The gap was $16 a month for a clean-record driver and widest for DUI drivers, at $33 a month. The same study shows how much prices swing by state, from $43 a month in Wisconsin to $258 in Nevada.

Costco’s insurer by state, Study A (liability only, monthly)
StateCostco’s insurerState averageDifference
Wisconsin$43$57$14 less
Ohio$50$65$15 less
Arizona$118$91$27 more
Nevada$258$164$94 more

Study A: national real-quote analysis updated October 27, 2026. Differences are our calculation.

The state table is the most important chart in this review. In Wisconsin and Ohio, Costco’s insurer beat the state average. In Arizona and Nevada, it cost more. Your state, not the Costco name, decides whether the program saves you money.

Costco vs. GEICO, Progressive, and State Farm

Study B is far less flattering. For its Illinois driver, Costco was the most expensive of the six insurers it compared, for both minimum and full coverage.

Illinois car insurance monthly rate comparison for Costco, GEICO, Progressive, and State Farm, showing minimum and full coverage costs.
Study B: Illinois rate study updated September 30, 2026; 45-year-old married man, clean record, 2015 Honda Civic EX.

In Study B, Costco’s full coverage cost $96 a month more than Progressive’s, or $1,152 a year (our calculation). Its minimum coverage cost $30 a month more than GEICO’s or Progressive’s. Study B’s editors rated the program 2 out of 5 and said it is not a good option for most people.

The two studies do not contradict each other as much as it seems. Study A averages real quotes from many drivers in many states, while Study B tests one profile in one state. Together, they say Costco can be a good deal, but not automatically.

How much can Costco members save?

Neither Costco nor American Family publishes an official average savings figure. Third-party reviews quote numbers from about $580 to $600 a year, but those come from older marketing and are not verified on the current program site. So we calculated savings from Study A’s current averages.

Chart showing estimated yearly Costco car insurance savings versus national averages, from $192 for clean-record drivers to $396 for DUI drivers.
Our calculation: (national average − Costco’s insurer) × 12, using Study A liability-only averages updated October 27, 2026. Not a quote.

A clean-record driver who matches the averages would save about $192 a year on liability-only coverage. A senior would save about $300, and a driver with a DUI about $396. Those are averages, and your own quote could be higher or lower.

Does the membership pay for itself?

Costco membership costs $65 a year for Gold Star or Business and $130 for Executive, after the fee increase of September 1, 2024. The Executive 2% reward, now capped at $1,250 a year, does not apply to insurance, so the insurance savings have to stand on their own.

Membership math, using Study A averages (our calculation)
DriverYearly savingsAfter a $65 Gold Star feeAfter a $130 Executive fee
Clean record$192$127$62
Speeding ticket$204$139$74
At-fault accident$216$151$86
Senior$300$235$170
Teen$324$259$194
DUI$396$331$266

Our calculation is based on Study A liability-only averages. Most members join for groceries and gas, so the fee is often already paid; this table shows the case where insurance is the only reason.

Even in the strict case where insurance is the only reason to join, the average savings in Study A cover the Gold Star fee for every driver type. Full coverage, discounts, and your state can change the result a lot, so treat this as a starting point.

A hypothetical: stacking the DriveMyWay discount

American Family’s DriveMyWay app, a form of usage-based car insurance, gives a 15% discount just for enrolling, and the program says most customers end up with savings of 10% to 35%. Unsafe driving can raise your rate. Here is what those percentages would mean on Study A’s $83 clean-record average.

Hypothetical Costco DriveMyWay monthly premiums: $83 without telematics, $71 with enrollment discount, and $54–$75 with final savings.
Hypothetical; our calculation using Study A’s $83 average and DriveMyWay percentages from costco.amfam.com (accessed October 28, 2026). Rounded to the nearest dollar.
(accessed October 28, 2026). Rounded to the nearest dollar.

Costco car insurance for teens and seniors

Teen drivers are expensive with every insurer, and Costco’s is no exception. In Study A, teens averaged $159 a month for liability-only coverage, against a $186 national average. Seniors averaged just $61, the lowest figure in the study and $25 below the national average.

Costco car insurance liability-only monthly rates for teens ($159) and seniors ($61), compared with national averages of $186 and $86.
Study A: national real-quote analysis updated October 27, 2026. Averages, not quotes.

Families with a teen can trim the bill further. Our college student car insurance comparison offers more context for young drivers. The program offers a good student discount for students with good grades and a student away discount for students who attend school more than 100 miles from home without a car. Adding a teen to a parent’s policy is usually cheaper than a separate policy.

Seniors get the most out of the program in Study A. A defensive driver course discount is available, and the Executive membership’s lifetime renewability benefit may appeal to older drivers who worry about being dropped, though it is not a contract guarantee.

Teen and senior options
DriverAverage (Study A)Discounts to ask about
Teen$159 a monthGood student, student away (100+ miles), multi-vehicle, DriveMyWay
Senior$61 a monthDefensive driver course, Premier Safety, multi-product, DriveMyWay

Study A; costco.amfam.com benefits and discounts page (accessed October 28, 2026).

Drivers with tickets, accidents, or a DUI

Costco’s insurer was not a high-risk specialist in the past, but Study A suggests it prices drivers with violations competitively. It averaged $110 a month after a speeding ticket, $115 after an at-fault accident, and $109 after a DUI, each below the national average.

The DUI number stands out. At $109, it was nearly the same as the $110 ticket figure and $33 below the $142 national average for DUI drivers. If you need an SR-22 filing, confirm with an agent that the insurer will file it in your state before you buy.

Chart showing how traffic violations increase Costco car insurance monthly premiums: $27 for speeding, $32 for an at-fault accident, and $26 for DUI.
Our calculation: Study A violation average minus Study A clean-record average ($83). Liability only, updated October 27, 2026.

Types of coverage you can buy

The program offers the standard coverage types discussed in our car insurance basics guide. Its official car page lists the following coverages, plus windshield repair, 24/7 claims reporting, and online account management.

Auto coverage through Costco
CoverageWhat it pays forRequired?
Bodily injury liabilityInjuries you cause to othersRequired in nearly every state
Property damage liabilityDamage you cause to others’ propertyRequired in nearly every state
CollisionDamage to your car in a crashOptional; lenders usually require it
ComprehensiveTheft, fire, weather, animals, and glassOptional; lenders usually require it
Medical expenseMedical bills for you and passengersOptional in most states
Personal injury protectionMedical bills and lost wages, regardless of faultRequired in no-fault states
Uninsured and underinsured motoristYour injuries when the other driver lacks enough insuranceRequired in some states
Rental carA rental while your car is repairedOptional
Roadside assistance and towingTowing, jump-starts, lockouts, and flat tiresOptional; free perk for Executive members

costco.amfam.com car insurance page (accessed October 28, 2026). Requirements vary by state.

Some extras quoted in other reviews, such as gap insurance and new car replacement, do not appear on the program’s official pages, and sources disagree about whether they are offered. If you have a car loan or a new car, ask an agent directly rather than assuming either one is available.

Everything else you can insure through Costco

Other insurance available to Costco members
ProductProviderNotes
Home and condoHomesite companiesExecutive members get extra home perks
RentersAmerican Family programExecutive home perks do not apply
UmbrellaAmerican Family programExtra liability above auto and home
Motorcycle, boat, ATV, floodPartner insurersListed as specialty coverage
BusinessAmerican Family programFor small business owners
PetFigo Pet Insurance15% member discount
HealthCBC Health Insurance MarketplaceIndividual and family plans
Medicare AdvantageSCAN, co-branded with CostcoStarts Jan. 1, 2027, in parts of California and Nevada

costco.amfam.com; costco.com services page (accessed October 28, 2026); Becker’s Hospital Review (October 2, 2026).

Costco Executive membership perks

Executive members get the most out of the program. These perks come on top of the member discount, are not available in every state, and are listed on the program’s benefits page.

Executive member insurance benefits
BenefitWhat you getLimits
Roadside assistanceUp to $75 per occurrence$100 in MA, MT, and SC; $80 in TX; no limit in NC; battery and fluids not covered
Lifetime renewabilityYour auto policy can be renewed as long as you stay an Executive memberNot a contract guarantee; not in CA, MD, MI, or on some FL policies
Home glass repairUp to $1,000 per occurrenceTwo claims per 12 months; not in NY, VT, or WA
Home lockout helpUp to $100 per occurrence, 24/7Two per 12 months; not in NY or VT
Identity fraud expenseUp to $15,000$250 to $500 deductible
Home add-onsService line and equipment breakdown coverageHome policies only

costco.amfam.com benefits and discounts page (accessed October 28, 2026).

Is the upgrade worth it for insurance alone? The Executive tier costs $65 more than Gold Star. Free roadside help can replace a separate plan, and in Massachusetts the member auto discount is only for Executive members. For most other drivers, the upgrade is easier to justify through the 2% reward on store purchases than through insurance.

What many Costco car insurance reviews get wrong

Several pages that rank for this topic repeat details that are no longer true. If you are comparing what you read elsewhere, this table shows the current facts as of October 2026.

Outdated claims vs. current facts
What you may readWhat is true in October 2026Source
The insurer is CONNECTRenamed American Family Insurance in December 2025Program FAQ
The insurer is AmeripriseAmerican Family bought the business in 2019Ameriprise Financial
Membership costs $60 or $120$65 Gold Star; $130 Executive since Sept. 1, 2024Costco
The 2% reward is capped at $1,000Capped at $1,250, and insurance is excludedCostco
Members save about $580 to $600No official savings figure is publishedProgram site
Not available in California or FloridaProgram fine print covers both statesProgram site

costco.amfam.com; costco.com Executive Rewards page; Ameriprise Financial (October 1, 2019). Accessed October 28, 2026.

Gold Star or Executive: which membership fits an insurance shopper?

Both membership levels can buy a policy and get the member discount in most states. The difference is the perks. This table shows when the extra $65 for Executive makes sense from an insurance point of view alone.

Gold Star vs. Executive for insurance
FeatureGold Star ($65)Executive ($130)
Buy a policy and get the member discountYes (not on MA auto)Yes
Roadside assistanceNot includedUp to $75 per occurrence in most states
Lifetime renewabilityNoYes, in most states
Home glass, lockout, and identity fraud perksNoYes, with home policies
2% reward on insuranceNoNo

costco.amfam.com benefits page; costco.com Executive Rewards page (accessed October 28, 2026).

If you live in Massachusetts, the choice is easy, because only Executive members get the auto discount there. Elsewhere, the upgrade makes most sense if you would otherwise pay for a roadside plan, or if you also bundle a home policy and want the extra home perks.

Every Costco car insurance discount

The official discount page lists the discounts below, but it does not publish percentages, except for DriveMyWay. Reviews that quote exact percentages for the other discounts are using industry averages, not Costco figures. For context beyond this program, see our guide to common car insurance discounts.

Costco car insurance discounts
DiscountWho qualifiesNotes
Costco memberCostco members who give a membership numberNot on MA auto for non-Executive members
DriveMyWayDrivers who use the app15% for enrolling; most save 10% to 35%
Premier SafetyEvery driver free of accidents, violations, and claimsReviews say four years
Good DriverCalifornia drivers who qualifyCalifornia only
Defensive driverDrivers who complete an approved courseOften used by seniors
Vehicle safety featuresCars with qualifying safety equipmentAsk which features count
GaragingCars kept in a garageLimited availability
Good studentStudents with good gradesTeens and young adults
Student awayStudents at school 100+ miles away, without a carKeeps the student on the policy
Multi-vehicleTwo or more cars on one policyCommon family discount
Multi-productBundling auto with home, condo, or rentersBundle through the same program
Continuous coverageDrivers with prior insuranceListed in a December 2025 review

costco.amfam.com benefits and discounts and DriveMyWay pages (accessed October 28, 2026). Discounts vary by state.

Bundling Costco auto and home insurance

The multi-product discount is the program’s bundling tool. You can combine auto with home, condo, or renters insurance through the same site, though the home policy comes from Homesite rather than American Family. Executive members who bundle also gain the home glass, lockout, and identity fraud benefits.

One limit matters in the South: the Costco member discount does not apply to home insurance in Florida or Tennessee, so a bundle there may not save as much as it would elsewhere. Price the bundle and the separate policies side by side before you decide.

Costco Insurance Ratings, complaints, and customer satisfaction

Financial strength is not a concern. On October 22, 2026, AM Best affirmed an A (Excellent) financial strength rating with a stable outlook for the American Family Connect companies, Midvale, and the Homesite companies.

Complaints are the weak spot. Review sites cite complaint index figures from about 2 to 4.4 for the Connect companies, where 1.0 is the expected level for an insurer’s size. California’s 2026 complaint study, which uses state data, shows the trend clearly.

American Family Connect insurance complaints in California rose from 2.1 per 100,000 policies in 2023 to 2.8 in 2024 and 3.0 in 2025.
California Department of Insurance, 2026 Consumer Complaint Study (auto). Ranked 24th among companies in the 2025 data. Lower is better.

Customer satisfaction scores are more mixed. In J.D. Power’s 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, released June 9, 2026, American Family scored above its regional average in four of five regions. The Connect brand was not ranked separately.

J.D. Power 2026 auto insurance satisfaction scores comparing American Family with regional averages in California, Central, North Central, Northwest, and Southwest.
J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study (June 9, 2026), as reported June 23, 2026; 1,000-point scale.
Costco car insurance ratings scorecard
RatingScoreWhat it means
AM Best (Oct. 22, 2026)A (Excellent), stableStrong ability to pay claims
J.D. Power 2026 shopping study670 vs. 662 averageAbove average buying experience (American Family)
J.D. Power 2026 satisfactionAbove average in 4 of 5 regionsSolid for American Family overall
California complaints (2025 data)3.0 per 100,000Rising since 2023
Complaint index (review sites)About 2 to 4.4More complaints than expected
BBB customer reviewsAbout 1.25 out of 5Few reviews, mostly negative

AM Best; J.D. Power 2026 studies as reported June 2026; California Department of Insurance; BBB figure as reported by review sites in 2026.

In a separate 2026 claims survey by a consumer insurance site, 82% of American Family customers said they were satisfied with their claim, up from 67% the year before. Taken together, the data says the parent company is strong and improving, while the Costco-linked companies draw more complaints than their size predicts.

Costco car insurance pros and cons

Pros and cons
ProsCons
Below-average prices in 2026 real-quote dataMost expensive of six insurers in an Illinois test
Backed by American Family, rated A by AM BestComplaints above expected levels
DriveMyWay: 15% to sign up, 10% to 35% typicalBad driving can raise your DriveMyWay rate
Free roadside help for Executive membersBest perks require the $130 Executive tier
Lifetime renewability for Executive membersNot a contract right; not in CA, MD, MI
Good prices for seniors and DUI driversNot sold through Costco in New York; not in Michigan
Bundle with home, condo, or rentersNo 2% Executive reward on insurance

Who benefits most from Costco car insurance?

The program works best for drivers whose profile and state line up with its pricing. Use this table to see where you fit.

Who should get a Costco quote
DriverGood fit?Why
Existing Executive membersYesRoadside help and lifetime renewability at no extra cost
Seniors with clean recordsYes$61 a month in Study A, $25 below average
Drivers with a DUI or accidentWorth a quoteBelow national averages in Study A
Safe drivers open to trackingYesDriveMyWay can cut 10% to 35%
Homeowners who want one bundleWorth a quoteMulti-product discount and Executive home perks
Clean-record drivers in high-cost statesCompare carefullyAbove state averages in Arizona and Nevada
New York or Michigan residentsNoNot sold through Costco there
Non-members buying only for insuranceMaybeSavings must exceed the $65 fee

If you are a Costco member already, a quote costs nothing and takes a few minutes, and you can get one before you join. If you are not a member, you can still get a quote, but you will need a membership to buy.

How Costco car insurance compares with other options

Costco vs. major competitors
FactorCostco (American Family)GEICOProgressiveState Farm
Illinois full coverage (Study B)$177$94$81$148
Illinois minimum coverage (Study B)$85$55$55$69
J.D. Power 2026 shopping score670 (American Family)656645674
Membership requiredYesNoNoNo
Telematics programDriveMyWayYesYesYes

Study B, Illinois, updated September 30, 2026; J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Insurance Shopping Study, as reported June 2026. Study average 662.

Costco’s buying experience scores well, and its parent company outscored GEICO and Progressive in J.D. Power’s 2026 shopping study. On price, the big national brands often win for a single clean-record driver. You can also buy directly from American Family, but the Costco member discount and Executive perks apply only through the Costco program.

A worked example: one household, two choices

Here is a hypothetical example to show how the numbers can play out. A married couple in their 60s, both with clean records, already hold a Gold Star membership. Using Study A’s senior average of $61 a month and the $86 national senior average, each driver could save about $25 a month on liability-only coverage.

For two drivers, that is about $600 a year (our calculation, not a quote). If they enroll in DriveMyWay and keep the full 15% enrollment discount, they could trim another $9 or so per driver each month. In a state like Arizona or Nevada, though, the same couple could find Costco priced above the state average, so the quote is what counts.

Questions to ask before you buy Costco Auto Insurance

  • Is the Costco member discount available on my policy in my state?
  • Which underwriting company will issue my policy?
  • Do you offer gap insurance or new car replacement for my car?
  • Will you file an SR-22 if my state requires one?
  • How would a change or lapse in my membership affect my discount or renewal?
  • Can I pay in full for a lower total, or in installments?
  • What is the quote with DriveMyWay, and what if my score is poor?

Common mistakes to avoid

The first mistake is assuming the Costco name means the lowest price. In Study B, it was the highest. The second is buying an Executive upgrade only for the 2% reward on insurance, which does not exist.

The third is comparing quotes with different limits or deductibles, which makes any price comparison meaningless. The fourth is canceling your old policy before the new one is confirmed in writing, which can leave you uninsured for a day or more. Finally, do not rely on old reviews for state availability or perks, since the program changed its name and some benefits in the past year.

How to get a quote and switch

  1. Visit costco.amfam.com or call 1-888-404-5365.
  2. Have your Costco membership number, driver’s license, and vehicle details ready.
  3. Ask for a quote with and without DriveMyWay, and ask which discounts apply in your state.
  4. Compare the six-month total with at least two other insurers for the same coverage.
  5. Set the new policy to start on the day your old one ends, so there is no gap.
  6. Cancel your old policy only after the new one is confirmed in writing.

Filing a Costco Car Insurance claim

Claims are handled by American Family, not Costco. You can report a claim online through your account or by phone at 1-800-872-5246, which the program says is open 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. Glass, roadside, and theft claims can also be filed online.

Take photos, collect the other driver’s information, and get a police report number if there is one. Because complaints run above average, keep notes of every call and ask for the adjuster’s name and direct line early in the process.

Is Costco car insurance legit?

Yes. The program is run for Costco members by a licensed agency, Costco Insurance Agency, Inc., and the policies are issued by American Family companies that AM Best rates A (Excellent). More than 500,000 Costco members have switched, according to the program site, which cites Costco records.

Because the program site is operated by a third party, it is easy to land on a look-alike page. Start from costco.com or go directly to costco.amfam.com, and never give your membership number or payment details to a site you reached through an unsolicited email or text.

Paying for your policy

The program lets you pay in full or in installments, and you can manage your account online. Paying in full avoids any installment charges your state allows, so ask for both totals before you choose. If the initial payment is a concern, our guide to low-upfront car insurance plans explains the trade-offs; it does not mean Costco offers a zero-down policy. If you sign up for DriveMyWay, your rate can change after the app finishes reviewing your trips, so check your renewal notice closely.

Costco car insurance at a glance

This illustrated summary pulls together the main points of this review.

Costco car insurance infographic summarizing prices, program benefits, coverage, and reasons to compare quotes before switching
Costco car insurance at a glance. Published averages, not individual insurance quotes.

Costco car insurance at a glance. Sources: 2026 real-quote analysis; costco.amfam.com; AM Best; Costco. Averages, not quotes.

Frequently asked questions

Who underwrites Costco car insurance?

Auto policies are underwritten by American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company, American Family Connect Insurance Company, or Midvale Indemnity Company. Costco Insurance Agency sells the policies but does not pay claims. Home policies come from Homesite companies. AM Best rates the underwriters A (Excellent) as of October 2026.

Is Costco car insurance the same as CONNECT?

Yes. CONNECT, powered by American Family Insurance, changed its name to American Family Insurance in December 2025. The program calls it a name change only, with no change to coverage, billing, premiums, or claims. Before 2019, the same business sold as Ameriprise Auto and Home.

Is Costco car insurance cheaper?

Often, but not always. In 2026 real-quote data, Costco’s insurer averaged $83 a month for liability-only coverage against a $99 national average. But an Illinois rate study found it the most expensive of six insurers, and it cost more than state averages in Arizona and Nevada. Compare quotes.

Do I need a Costco membership?

You can get a quote without one, but you need a membership to buy a policy and receive the member discount. Gold Star membership costs $65 a year and Executive costs $130. Executive members also get roadside help and lifetime renewability where available.

Does the Executive 2% reward apply to insurance?

No. Costco excludes insurance services from the Executive 2% reward, which is capped at $1,250 a year. Executive members instead get insurance-specific perks, such as roadside assistance up to $75 per occurrence and lifetime renewability on auto policies in most states.

Is Costco car insurance available in every state?

No. Costco Insurance Agency is not licensed in New York, and a December 2025 state list did not include Michigan. Some benefits and discounts also vary in Massachusetts, Florida, Tennessee, California, and Maryland. Enter your ZIP code on the program site to confirm availability.

What is DriveMyWay?

DriveMyWay is American Family’s driving-tracking app. You get a 15% discount for enrolling, and the program says most customers end up saving 10% to 35%. It reviews about 99 trips to set your rate, and unsafe driving habits can increase what you pay.

How do I file a Costco car insurance claim?

File online through your American Family account or call 1-800-872-5246, which is open 24 hours a day, every day of the year. Glass, roadside, and theft claims can also be filed online. Costco itself does not handle claims, so contact American Family directly.

The final word on Costco car insurance

Costco car insurance is a solid program wrapped in a lot of outdated information. The insurer behind it is American Family, financially strong and rated A, and in 2026 real-quote data its prices were below national averages for every driver type, especially seniors and drivers with a DUI.

But the savings are not automatic. In one Illinois test, Costco was the most expensive option, and it cost more than state averages in Arizona and Nevada. Complaints also run higher than expected. The smart move for any member is simple: get a free Costco quote, then compare it with two others for the same coverage. Our car insurance savings guide covers other factors worth checking before you switch.

Prices, discounts, coverage options, benefits, and ratings change and vary by state, driver, and vehicle. The figures in this review are published averages and our calculations, not quotes or offers. This review is for information only and is not legal or financial advice. The publisher is not an insurance company or a licensed insurance agency.

The bottom line on Costco car insurance: for Executive members, seniors, and safe drivers in the right states, it can be one of the better deals available, but only a side-by-side quote will tell you whether it is the right deal for you.

Sources

  • Costco and American Family program site: home, car insurance, benefits and discounts, DriveMyWay, FAQ, underwriting companies, and claims (accessed October 28, 2026).
  • Costco, Auto and Home Insurance, Executive Rewards, and Services (accessed October 28, 2026).
  • Ameriprise Financial, sale of Auto and Home business (October 1, 2019).
  • Business Wire, CONNECT launch (August 4, 2020).
  • AM Best, rating affirmation (October 22, 2026).
  • California Department of Insurance, 2026 Consumer Complaint Study, Auto.
  • Insurance.com, J.D. Power 2026 auto insurance satisfaction (June 23, 2026), 2026 shopping study, and 2026 claims survey.
  • Insurify, CONNECT car insurance (October 27, 2026).
  • ValuePenguin, Costco insurance review (September 30, 2026).
  • NerdWallet, CONNECT review (December 19, 2025).
  • Becker’s Hospital Review, SCAN and Costco Medicare Advantage (October 2, 2026).
  • TipRanks, Costco membership fee increase (July 2024).

Disclaimer

This website provides an independent review. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, or connected to Costco Wholesale Corporation, Costco Insurance Agency, Inc., American Family Insurance, American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company, American Family Connect Insurance Company, Midvale Indemnity Company, Homesite, or any of their affiliates.

All company names, brand names, trademarks, and logos are the property of their respective owners and are used here only to identify the companies and programs being reviewed. Their use does not imply any affiliation or endorsement.

The information on this page is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not insurance, legal, tax, or financial advice, and it is not an offer, quote, or solicitation to buy or sell insurance. We are not an insurance company, insurance agency, or licensed insurance producer, and we cannot bind coverage, change a policy, or handle claims.

Prices, discounts, coverage options, benefits, ratings, and company details are drawn from public sources and third-party studies that use specific driver profiles, and they can change at any time. They are estimates and averages, not guarantees of what you will pay. Coverage, eligibility, discounts, and member benefits vary by state, driver, vehicle, and membership level, and are subject to the insurer’s underwriting rules and policy terms.

While we make reasonable efforts to keep this review accurate and current, we make no representations or warranties, express or implied, about its completeness, accuracy, or reliability. Opinions in this review are our own. Always confirm details directly with the insurer, read your policy documents, and consult your state’s department of insurance or a licensed professional before making a decision. Your use of this information is at your own risk, and we are not liable for any loss or damage arising from reliance on it.