Best New Jersey Car Insurance Companies: Rates & Coverage

With dozens of insurers competing for more than six million insured vehicles, choosing among New Jersey car insurance companies can feel overwhelming, and the stakes are high in a state where recent rate increases have put pressure on household budgets. Our ranking shows that NJM is the overall winner, with low prices, the state’s best complaint record, and the top customer satisfaction score among insurers sold in New Jersey, while GEICO and Plymouth Rock are the strongest low-cost alternatives.

Most guides to New Jersey car insurance cover five to 10 companies and rely on national complaint data.

This guide ranks 20 companies using New Jersey’s own complaint ratios and market share data from the Department of Banking and Insurance (DOBI), J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic satisfaction scores, AM Best ratings, and rate studies from nine sources. It also covers the best insurers for sedans, SUVs, vans, trucks, and sports cars, the best companies for teens, seniors, and women, the 10 cheapest cars to insure in New Jersey, city rates, the 2026 legal requirements, discounts, and pro tips to save money.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • NJM is our overall winner. It was the cheapest or second-cheapest company in most New Jersey studies we reviewed, had just two valid complaints on more than 900,000 insured vehicles in DOBI’s 2024 report, and scored 699 in J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic study, the highest of any insurer sold in New Jersey.
  • GEICO is New Jersey’s largest auto insurer, with 21.39% of insured vehicles, and was cheapest overall in three of the studies we reviewed.
  • New Jersey’s minimum liability limits rose to 35/70/25 on January 1, 2026, for Standard policies.
  • Average full coverage ranges from about $2,736 to $3,687 a year, depending on the study, and a January 2026 report forecast a 10.46% state increase, not a verified final-year result.
  • The Chevrolet Express and Honda HR-V were the cheapest vehicles to insure in New Jersey, at about $942 and $951 for six months of full coverage.

Editorial note: historical infographics are retained as published. Any references in an image to the old A++ State Farm rating, legacy MetLife availability, or a final 2026 rate increase should be checked against the corrected text before reuse.

New Jersey car insurance companies at a glance. Sources: DOBI (June 2025 and 2024 complaint report), J.D. Power 2026 via Study C, a 2026 national rate report, and DOBI Bulletin 25-06.

New Jersey car insurance companies at a glance. Sources: DOBI (June 2025 and 2024 complaint report), J.D. Power 2026 via Study C, a 2026 national rate report, and DOBI Bulletin 25-06.

How we ranked New Jersey car insurance companies

Our editorial assessment considers sample prices, DOBI’s valid-complaint index, J.D. Power’s regional satisfaction survey, AM Best financial-strength ratings and insurer availability. We did not construct or publish a reproducible weighted score, so the displayed order is an editorial shortlist, not a statistically validated national or statewide ranking. Studies A through I use different driver profiles and must be compared separately.

Two cautions apply. Erie Insurance tops J.D. Power’s Mid-Atlantic region but does not sell car insurance in New Jersey, so it is not ranked here. And some websites list Allstate’s rating as A+, but the company that writes New Jersey policies, Allstate New Jersey, was rated A- with a negative outlook in the cited 2025 action; the underwriting entity should be confirmed for an individual quote.

How much car insurance costs in New Jersey

New Jersey is one of the most expensive states for car insurance. Average full coverage ranged from $2,736 a year in Study C to $3,687 in Study E, depending on the driver profile. One national forecast published in January 2026 projected a 10.46% increase for New Jersey. A forecast is not the same as the final statewide increase actually paid by drivers.

Studies use different driver profiles and coverage levels. Monthly figures for Studies C and E are our calculations from yearly averages.

Studies use different driver profiles and coverage levels. Monthly figures for Studies C and E are our calculations from yearly averages.

Study A's trend table. Source: Study A.

Study A’s trend table. Source: Study A.

Study A’s trend data show the average New Jersey premium more than doubling from $1,419 in 2019 to $2,902 in 2026. DOBI said in 2026 that it had blocked almost $1.2 billion in requested increases since 2023, but more than 300 increases were approved from 2022 to early 2026.

The top 20 car insurance companies in New Jersey

The table presents 20 New Jersey insurers for comparison, in editorial order rather than a weighted statistical league table. Study A supplies prices for many carriers, with additional samples from other studies. Different driver profiles, policy terms and quote years mean that prices are not directly comparable across sources. A missing rate is not evidence that a carrier is unavailable or expensive.

Vector illustration of 10 numbered cars labeled with the top New Jersey car insurance companies and monthly full coverage prices: 1 NJM, 155 dollars; 2 GEICO, 179 dollars; 3 Plymouth Rock, 206 dollars; 4 Travelers, 142 dollars; 5 Selective, 220 dollars; 6 Amica, 254 dollars; 7 Progressive, 188 dollars; 8 State Farm, 258 dollars; 9 AAA, 239 dollars; 10 USAA, military only.

The top 10 car insurance companies in New Jersey, ranked on price, complaints, satisfaction, and financial strength.

Top 20 car insurance companies in New Jersey, ranked

Editorial order Company Liability only (monthly) Full coverage (monthly) Rate source DOBI complaint index
1 NJM $73 $155 Study A 0.042
2 GEICO $72 $179 Study A 0.747
3 Plymouth Rock $132 $206 Study B 0.533
4 Travelers $84 $142 Study A 1.092
5 Selective $94 $220 Study A 0.443
6 Amica $153 $254 Study A 0.000
7 Progressive $82 $188 Study A 0.829
8 State Farm $147 $258 Study A 1.583
9 AAA (CSAA) $156 $239 Study B 1.119
10 USAA Not published Not published Military only 2.217
11 Allstate $141 $242 Study A 1.531
12 Penn National $108 $221 Study A Not listed
13 Farmers $102 $226 Study C 1.623
14 Liberty Mutual $261 $324 Study B 2.099
15 CURE Not verified Not verified No comparable quote 4.351 (DOBI 2024)
16 Mercury $224 $309 Study B Not listed
17 The Hanover $182 $529 Study A 1.745
18 Encompass $252 $344 Study A Not listed
19 Direct Auto $173 $320 Study B Not listed
20 Bristol West $182 Not published Study B Not listed

Study A prices are six-month premiums divided by six; Study C prices are yearly premiums divided by 12. DOBI’s *complaint ratio* is valid complaints per 1,000 insured vehicles. Its separate *complaint index* compares a company’s ratio with the statewide ratio, normalized to 1.00; lower is better. “Not listed” means the company was too small or not separately named in DOBI’s 2024 report.

Six-month premiums divided by six. Source: Study A.

Six-month premiums divided by six. Source: Study A.

1. NJM: the overall winner

NJM, founded in 1913 and based in West Trenton, is New Jersey’s third-largest auto insurer, with 14.61% of insured vehicles. It was cheapest overall in Studies B, C, D, and H, and it led most studies for seniors, drivers with an accident, and drivers with poor credit. It had only two valid complaints on 912,378 vehicles in DOBI’s 2024 report, by far the best record of any large insurer, and scored 699 in J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic study.

Strengths: low prices, outstanding complaint record, possible policyholder dividends, A+ (Superior) AM Best rating, and now open to all New Jersey residents. Weaknesses: no telematics program listed, sold only in five states, and AM Best moved its credit rating outlook to negative in April 2025 after underwriting losses, though its A+ financial strength rating did not change.

2. GEICO: cheapest for many drivers

GEICO insures more New Jersey vehicles than any other company, at 21.39%. It was cheapest overall in Studies E, F, and G and cheapest for 16- and 18-year-olds in Studies C and F. Its complaint index of 0.747 is better than average.

For an insurer-to-insurer look at how products differ, see National General vs. GEICO coverage comparison; it is not a New Jersey price study.

Strengths: very low prices, especially for liability only, an A++ AM Best rating, strong digital tools, and a 3.2% rate decrease filed for 2026. Weaknesses: a J.D. Power score of 634, below the regional average, and an October 2026 DOBI order to refund more than $10.5 million to about 15,000 New Jersey customers and pay a $1.2 million penalty after charging rates above approved levels and other problems.

3. Plymouth Rock: strong local value

Plymouth Rock, which absorbed the New Jersey insurer Palisades, insures 6.17% of New Jersey vehicles. It was second cheapest in Study B, at $206 a month for full coverage, cheapest after a speeding ticket in Study F, and cheapest for minimum coverage in every New Jersey city Study H listed.

Strengths: low prices across many driver profiles, a better-than-average complaint index of 0.533, and a Road Rewards app that pays gift cards for safe driving. Weaknesses: a J.D. Power score of 622, below average, and much higher prices in some studies, such as Study D.

4. Travelers: cheapest full coverage in Study A

Travelers had the cheapest full coverage in Study A, at about $142 a month, and was second cheapest in Studies D and E. Strengths: low full coverage prices, an A++ AM Best rating, and broad coverage options. Weaknesses: an average complaint index of 1.092, a J.D. Power score of 620, and high prices for teens in Study B.

5. Selective: low complaints, sold through agents

Selective was cheapest for minimum coverage and tied for cheapest full coverage in Study H, and second cheapest in Study C. Its complaint index of 0.443 was second best among large insurers. Strengths: low prices, A+ AM Best rating, local agent service. Weaknesses: no online quotes and a small New Jersey market share of 0.65%.

6. Amica: zero complaints

Amica had no valid complaints in DOBI’s 2024 report and was named runner-up in Study E’s best-company ranking. It was rated A+ by AM Best and ranked first in J.D. Power’s 2026 New England study; New England satisfaction results are not specific to New Jersey. Strengths: excellent service record and possible dividend policies, which Amica says return 5% to 20% of premium on average where offered. Weaknesses: higher prices, at about $254 a month in Study A, and we could not confirm whether dividend policies are sold in New Jersey.

7. Progressive: good for many risk profiles

Progressive is New Jersey’s second-largest insurer, at 17.78% of vehicles, and was among the cheapest in Studies A, E, and G. Strengths: competitive liability prices, Snapshot telematics savings averaging $328, and a complaint index of 0.829. Weaknesses: a J.D. Power score of 630 and very high prices for 16-year-olds in Study C.

8. State Farm: above-average satisfaction

State Farm scored 669 in J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic study, above the region’s 651 average, and offers up to 30% off through Drive Safe and Save. Weaknesses: higher prices in most studies, a complaint index of 1.583, and a DUI increase of 305% in Study D, the largest we found.

9. AAA (CSAA): high satisfaction for members

CSAA, which sells AAA insurance, scored 685 in J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic study, second among New Jersey insurers. It was the third cheapest in Study B, at $239 a month for full coverage. Weaknesses: AAA membership is required and its complaint index of 1.119 is about average.

10. USAA: for military families

USAA insures 4.40% of New Jersey vehicles and scored 721 in J.D. Power’s 2026 study, though it is not eligible for official rankings. Most studies exclude it from New Jersey rate tables. Its weakness in New Jersey is a high complaint index of 2.217, more than twice the state average.

11 to 15. Allstate, Penn National, Farmers, Liberty Mutual, and CURE

Allstate scored 643 with J.D. Power but has a complaint index of 1.531, and its New Jersey company carries an A- rating with a negative outlook.

Penn National was among the five cheapest companies in Study E and below average in Study A. Farmers had competitive prices in some samples, but the underlying profiles differ. Liberty Mutual had a complaint index of 2.099. MetLife Auto & Home was acquired by Farmers in 2021, so any MetLife-branded premium in a historical table should not be treated as a presently available independent insurer. For the twentieth position, this guide instead identifies CURE, which publishes information about its New Jersey auto policies, but no comparable rate is available from these studies.

16 to 20. Mercury, The Hanover, Encompass, Direct Auto, and Bristol West

Mercury and Encompass were among the more expensive companies in Studies A and B. The Hanover, sold through agents, had the highest full coverage price in Study A, at about $529 a month, and was the most expensive company for 16-year-olds in Study C. Direct Auto and Bristol West are nonstandard insurers that may accept drivers other companies decline, at about $173 and $182 a month for liability in Study B.

The overall winner: NJM

OVERALL BEST CAR INSURANCE COMPANY IN NEW JERSEY: NJM

Our editorial preference is NJM because its 2024 DOBI complaint index was 0.042 (two valid complaints among 912,378 vehicles) and its published sample premiums were competitive in several studies. These measures do not establish that it is cheapest or best for every driver. NJM earned 699 in J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic results and carried an A+ AM Best rating in the cited reporting period.

Why NJM wins: head-to-head with the next two companies

Measure NJM GEICO Plymouth Rock
Full coverage, Study B (monthly) $136 $276 $206
Liability or minimum, Study B (monthly) $111 $216 $132
DOBI complaint index (2024) 0.042 0.747 0.533
J.D. Power Mid-Atlantic (2026) 699 634 622
AM Best rating A+ A++ A- (group)
NJ market share (June 2025) 14.61% 21.39% 6.17%
Online quotes Yes Yes Yes

RUNNER-UP: GEICO

GEICO is the best choice for many young drivers and drivers who want the lowest liability price, and it was cheapest overall in three studies. Its lower satisfaction score and the October 2026 DOBI penalty keep it in second place.

Best New Jersey car insurance company by need

Best New Jersey car insurance company for each need

Need Best pick Why
Overall NJM Low prices, best complaint record, top J.D. Power score in NJ
Cheapest liability only GEICO Cheapest minimum coverage in Studies D, E, and F
Teen drivers GEICO or NJM Cheapest for teens in Studies B, C, and F
Seniors NJM Cheapest at ages 65, 70, and 75 in Study D
After an accident NJM Smallest increase after an accident in Study D
After a speeding ticket Plymouth Rock Cheapest in Studies F and G
After a DUI GEICO Cheapest in Studies E and F
Poor credit NJM Cheapest in Studies E, F, and G
Fewest complaints Amica Zero valid complaints in DOBI’s 2024 report
Military families USAA Eligibility required; high satisfaction
Local agent service Selective Low prices and complaints; sold through agents

Cheapest car insurance companies in New Jersey

The cheapest company depends on the study, but the same three names, NJM, GEICO, and Plymouth Rock, appear at or near the top of almost every list.

You can also review how National General accident forgiveness works when comparing post-accident coverage features, if applicable.

Cheapest New Jersey company for full coverage, by study

Study Cheapest 2nd 3rd
Study B NJM $136/mo Plymouth Rock $206/mo AAA $239/mo
Study C NJM $2,134/yr Selective $2,232/yr Plymouth Rock $2,400/yr
Study D NJM $2,373/yr Travelers $2,522/yr GEICO $2,597/yr
Study E GEICO $159/mo Travelers $181/mo NJM $184/mo
Study F GEICO $141/mo NJM $168/mo Plymouth Rock $178/mo
Study G GEICO $132/mo NJM $137/mo Plymouth Rock $164/mo
Study H NJM and Selective $123/mo (tie) Plymouth Rock $143/mo

35-year-old driver, 2023 Toyota Camry. Source: Study E, October 2026.

35-year-old driver, 2023 Toyota Camry. Source: Study E, October 2026.

Liability vs. full coverage, Study D (yearly, 2026 minimums)

Company State minimum (35/70/25) Liability 50/100/50 Full coverage
NJM $1,108 $1,108 $2,373
Travelers $1,514 $1,595 $2,522
GEICO $846 $1,057 $2,597
Farmers $1,188 $1,126 $2,726
Progressive $1,370 $1,460 $3,069
Allstate $1,355 $1,499 $3,311
State Farm $2,310 $2,490 $3,997
Plymouth Rock $1,579 $1,838 $4,534

Study D is one of the few studies that priced New Jersey’s new 2026 minimum of 35/70/25. In that data, GEICO had the cheapest state-minimum policy, at $846 a year, while NJM had the cheapest full coverage.

Data-quality warning: Study D lists Farmers at $1,188 for state minimum and $1,126 for 50/100/50 liability. The higher-limit sample being cheaper is possible under different rating assumptions, but those values should not be read as a controlled same-driver coverage comparison until the source methodology is reconciled.

2026 rate changes by company

Not every New Jersey insurer raised rates for 2026. Study F’s review of state rate filings shows GEICO cutting rates by 3.2% and Palisades, part of Plymouth Rock, by 2.4%, while NJM, Liberty Mutual, Allstate, Farmers, and American Family filed increases. Over five years, every company in the table raised rates by at least 23%, and State Farm’s increases totaled 77.3%.

New Jersey rate changes by company, Study F

Company 2026 rate change Five-year change
GEICO -3.2% +42.9%
Palisades (Plymouth Rock) -2.4% +46.2%
State Farm -0.8% +77.3%
USAA 0.0% +27.2%
Travelers 0.0% +34.4%
Progressive 0.0% +44.5%
NJM +2.5% +59.4%
Liberty Mutual +2.7% +53.8%
Allstate +3.1% +65.4%
Farmers +4.8% +39.8%
American Family +6.4% +23.5%

Cumulative filed rate changes over five years. Source: Study F, October 2026.

Cumulative filed rate changes over five years. Source: Study F, October 2026.

New Jersey auto insurance market share

DOBI’s semi-annual report counts every insured vehicle in New Jersey. As of June 30, 2025, 74 companies in 32 groups insured 6,227,181 vehicles, and the top five groups insured about 72% of them.

Source: DOBI Private Passenger Automobile semi-annual report, June 30, 2025.

Source: DOBI Private Passenger Automobile semi-annual report, June 30, 2025.

New Jersey car insurance complaints by company

DOBI publishes New Jersey’s own complaint data, which is more useful than national figures because it reflects how companies treat New Jersey drivers. Its 2024 report counted 319 valid complaints across 6.1 million insured vehicles. An index of 1.00 is average, and lower is better.

DOBI complaint ratios, 2024 (insurers with 10,000+ vehicles)

Insurer Valid complaints Insured vehicles Complaint index
Amica 0 28,981 0.000
NJM 2 912,378 0.042
Selective 1 43,189 0.443
Plymouth Rock 11 394,867 0.533
GEICO 53 1,357,530 0.747
Progressive 41 947,274 0.829
Travelers 13 227,932 1.092
CSAA (AAA) 6 102,612 1.119
Allstate 44 550,104 1.531
State Farm 52 628,742 1.583
Farmers 9 106,152 1.623
The Hanover 3 32,917 1.745
Liberty Mutual 21 191,521 2.099
USAA 31 267,616 2.217
Personal Service Insurance 6 40,894 2.809
Nationwide 3 19,353 2.967
CURE 13 57,192 4.351

Lower is better. Amica, American Family, Founders, and American National had zero valid complaints. Source: DOBI 2024 Auto Insurance Consumer Information Report.

Lower is better. Amica, American Family, Founders, and American National had zero valid complaints. Source: DOBI 2024 Auto Insurance Consumer Information Report.

Customer satisfaction: J.D. Power Mid-Atlantic scores

J.D. Power’s U.S. Auto Insurance Study groups New Jersey with neighboring states in its Mid-Atlantic region. In the 2026 study, as reported by Study C, NJM had the highest score of any company sold in New Jersey. NJM also ranked first in the region in 2025, with a score of 721.

Erie (704) leads the region but does not sell in New Jersey. USAA scored 721 but is not rank-eligible. Source: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, as reported by Study C.

Erie (704) leads the region but does not sell in New Jersey. USAA scored 721 but is not rank-eligible. Source: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, as reported by Study C.

Financial strength ratings for New Jersey insurers

AM Best financial strength ratings

Insurer AM Best rating Note
GEICO A++ (Superior) April 2026
Travelers A++ (Superior) August 2025
State Farm Group A+ (Superior), rating action November 2025 Downgraded from A++ on November 14, 2025
NJM A+ (Superior) Credit rating outlook revised to negative, April 2025
Progressive A+ (Superior) May 2026
Selective A+ (Superior) December 2025
Amica A+ (Superior) March 2026
Allstate group A+ (Superior) August 2025
Allstate New Jersey A- (Excellent), negative outlook August 2025
Plymouth Rock Assurance Group A- (Excellent), outlook positive March 2026

Other New Jersey insurers worth knowing

CURE, a not-for-profit reciprocal exchange founded in Princeton in 1990, says it does not use credit scores, education, or occupation to set rates, which can help drivers with poor credit. But it had the worst complaint index in DOBI’s 2024 report, at 4.351. Foremost, Markel, and Personal Service Insurance each insure tens of thousands of New Jersey vehicles, often for nonstandard drivers, but we found no reliable New Jersey rate data for them.

PRO TIP #1

Check DOBI’s complaint report before you switch. Two companies can quote similar prices, but in 2024 USAA and Liberty Mutual drew more than twice the average complaints in New Jersey, while NJM, Selective, and Plymouth Rock drew far fewer.

Best car insurance in New Jersey by vehicle type

Your car matters almost as much as your company. We could not find any study that ranks New Jersey insurers separately for each vehicle type, so this section does two things. It shows which models in each class are cheapest to insure in New Jersey, using Study D’s New Jersey data, and it names the companies that were cheapest overall for New Jersey drivers, which is where we recommend starting your quotes for any vehicle.

Best car insurance in New Jersey for sedans

Sedans are usually inexpensive to insure because they are common, affordable to repair, and score well in crash tests. In Study D’s New Jersey data, the Subaru Legacy was the cheapest sedan at $1,059 for six months of full coverage, followed by the Honda Civic sedan and Nissan Sentra. A Toyota Camry averaged $2,340 a year in New Jersey on Study D’s model page, slightly below its $2,400 national average.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, 0 deductibles. Source: Study D.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D.

Best companies for sedan owners: NJM and Travelers, the two cheapest companies for a 40-year-old driving a Honda Accord in Study D’s statewide rankings, followed by GEICO.

Best car insurance in New Jersey for SUVs

Small SUVs were the cheapest vehicles of any type to insure in New Jersey. Eight of the 10 cheapest vehicles in Study D’s New Jersey list were SUVs, led by the Honda HR-V at $951 for six months. A Honda CR-V averaged $2,009 a year in New Jersey on its model page.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, 0 deductibles. Source: Study D.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D.

Best companies for SUV owners: NJM, GEICO, and Plymouth Rock. Our Study G data used a 2018 Honda CR-V, and GEICO, NJM, and Plymouth Rock were the three cheapest companies for that SUV.

Best car insurance in New Jersey for vans and minivans

Full-size cargo vans were surprisingly cheap to insure in New Jersey. The Chevrolet Express was the cheapest vehicle of any kind in Study D’s list, at $942 for six months, and the GMC Savana tied for fifth at $982. For minivans, a Toyota Sienna averaged $2,259 a year in New Jersey, below its $2,304 national average.

We found no New Jersey company rankings for minivans. National model-specific comparisons found different inexpensive insurers for the Toyota Sienna and Chrysler Pacifica; those results are not New Jersey minivan quotes. In New Jersey, we would add NJM, the state’s cheapest overall company in most studies, to your quote list.

Best car insurance in New Jersey for pickup trucks

40-year-old male driver, 100/300/100 limits, 0 deductibles, 10,000 miles a year. Source: Study D model pages.

40-year-old male driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles, 10,000 miles a year. Source: Study D model pages.

Pickups cost a bit more than small SUVs but less than many sedans. In New Jersey, the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 averaged $2,226 a year, the Toyota Tacoma $2,256, and the Ford F-150 $2,535 on Study D’s model pages. Nationally, the cheapest companies for these trucks were Progressive, State Farm, and GEICO for the Tacoma, and Nationwide, GEICO, and State Farm for the Silverado and F-150. Work trucks used for a business may need a commercial policy instead.

Best car insurance in New Jersey for sports cars

Sports cars can cost more to insure because of their performance, parts costs, losses, and insured-driver mix; no single cause or universal premium ranking follows from the vehicle category alone. In Study D’s New Jersey data, the Honda Civic Si was the cheapest sports car at $1,274 for six months, while a Chevrolet Corvette Z06 cost $1,914 and a Porsche 911 GT3 cost $2,194.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, 0 deductibles. Source: Study D.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D.

Best companies for sports car owners: start with NJM and GEICO in New Jersey. Nationally, Study C found USAA, Travelers, and GEICO cheapest for the Ford Mustang.

Best car insurance in New Jersey by vehicle type

Vehicle type Cheapest model in NJ (Study D) Start your quotes with Note
Sedan Subaru Legacy, $1,059 per 6 months NJM, Travelers, GEICO Cheapest for a Honda Accord in Study D
SUV Honda HR-V, $951 per 6 months GEICO, NJM, Plymouth Rock Cheapest for a CR-V in Study G
Van or minivan Chevrolet Express, $942 per 6 months NJM, Progressive, Travelers National minivan data plus NJ leaders
Pickup truck Silverado 1500, $2,226 a year NJM, GEICO, Progressive National truck data plus NJ leaders
Sports car Honda Civic Si, $1,274 per 6 months NJM, GEICO, Travelers National Mustang data plus NJ leaders

Top 10 cheapest cars to insure in New Jersey

If you are shopping for a car, the model you choose can save you hundreds of dollars a year. These are the 10 cheapest vehicles to insure in New Jersey in Study D’s data, for a 40-year-old with full coverage.

For a broader model shortlist, see the cheapest cars to insure comparison; it does not replace New Jersey-specific quotes.

Vector illustration of 10 numbered cars labeled with the cheapest vehicles to insure in New Jersey and their six-month full coverage prices: 1 Chevrolet Express 942 dollars; 2 Honda HR-V 951 dollars; 3 Volkswagen Tiguan 955 dollars; 4 Chevrolet TrailBlazer 968 dollars; 5 GMC Savana 982 dollars; 6 Hyundai Kona 982 dollars; 7 Volkswagen Taos 988 dollars; 8 Mazda CX-5 991 dollars; 9 Jeep Wrangler 997 dollars; 10 Honda CR-V 1,004 dollars.

The 10 cheapest cars to insure in New Jersey, six-month full coverage premiums.

Top 10 cheapest cars to insure in New Jersey, Study D

Rank Model 6-month premium About per month
1 Chevrolet Express $942 $157
2 Honda HR-V $951 $159
3 Volkswagen Tiguan $955 $159
4 Chevrolet TrailBlazer $968 $161
5 (tie) GMC Savana $982 $164
5 (tie) Hyundai Kona $982 $164
7 Volkswagen Taos $988 $165
8 Mazda CX-5 $991 $165
9 Jeep Wrangler $997 $166
10 Honda CR-V $1,004 $167

The same list shows how much age matters: an 18-year-old would pay about $3,638 for six months to insure a Honda HR-V, nearly four times what a 40-year-old pays.

PRO TIP #2

Get insurance quotes before you buy a car. In New Jersey, the gap between the cheapest small SUV, at $951 for six months, and a high-performance sports car, at $2,194, is more than $2,400 a year.

Best car insurance companies in New Jersey for teens

Teen drivers in New Jersey pay some of the highest rates in the country. Study B found the average New Jersey teen pays about $438 a month for full coverage and $308 for liability only. The good news is that the cheapest companies charge far less than average, and the gap between the cheapest and most expensive company for a 16-year-old was more than $22,000 a year in Study C’s data.

Our separate National General versus GEICO guide for young drivers explains comparison questions, but is not an NJ teen quote.

Full coverage 100/300/100, 0 deductibles. Source: Study C, January 2026.

Full coverage 100/300/100, $500 deductibles. Source: Study C, January 2026.

Cheapest New Jersey companies for 18-year-olds, Study F (monthly)

Company Liability only Full coverage
GEICO $96 $191
NJM $222 $365
Travelers $351 $586
Allstate $413 $1,024
Farmers $485 $1,036

Cheapest New Jersey companies for teen drivers, Study B (monthly)

Company Full coverage Liability only
NJM $264 $216
Plymouth Rock $350 $225
Progressive $458 $315
GEICO $483 $376
Allstate $521 $286
Mercury $538 $389
CSAA (AAA) $541 $356
Liberty Mutual $545 $440
State Farm $593 $487
Direct Auto $601 $325
Travelers $823 $677

Studies disagree on whether GEICO or NJM is cheapest for teens, which is normal because they use different ages and profiles. GEICO led for 16- and 18-year-olds in Study C and Study F, while NJM led Study B’s all-teen table. Get quotes from both.

Adding a teen to a parent’s policy may cost less than buying a separate policy when the teen is eligible to be included and all household drivers and principal vehicle users are disclosed accurately. Study B found a New Jersey teen on a family policy costs about $314 a month, compared with $419 on the teen’s own policy, a savings of about $1,256 a year.

For a 20-year-old added to a family policy, Study E found GEICO cheapest at about $315 a month in total, an increase of $111, followed by Travelers at $391 and Progressive at $427. Amica was most expensive in that comparison, adding $273 a month.

NJM was the cheapest company for teens in Study H's data. Source: Study H, October 2026.

NJM was the cheapest company for teens in Study H’s data. Source: Study H, October 2026.

PRO TIP #3

Ask NJM about its driver training discount for drivers under 21 who complete 30 classroom hours and six behind-the-wheel hours, and stack it with a good student discount for a B average or better.

Best car insurance companies in New Jersey for seniors

New Jersey seniors generally pay less than younger drivers, but rates start to climb in the 70s. In Study D’s data, average full coverage rose from $3,096 a year at age 65 to $3,175 at 70 and $3,340 at 75. NJM was the cheapest company at all three ages, at $173 a month at 65, $177 at 70, and $205 at 75.

Full coverage 100/300/100. Source: Study D.

Full coverage 100/300/100. Source: Study D.

Source: Study D.

Source: Study D.

Cheapest New Jersey companies for a 70-year-old, Study E (monthly)

Company Full coverage Liability only
NJM $161 $66
Travelers $186 Not listed
Plymouth Rock $203 $79
GEICO $212 $83
Penn National $219 Not listed

Study H also found NJM cheapest for 70-year-olds, at $122 a month for full coverage, followed by Amica at $158, Travelers at $163, Plymouth Rock at $165, and State Farm at $168.

Seniors should ask about defensive driving discounts. New Jersey regulations require insurers to offer a discount, generally at least 5%, for completing an approved course, and NJM applies it for up to three years.

Best car insurance companies in New Jersey for women

The relationship between gender and New Jersey auto premiums requires checking the insurer’s approved rating plan. New Jersey prohibits denying insurance solely because of sex, but that rule by itself does not establish whether gender is an approved pricing variable. Study I’s October 2026 data shows women in New Jersey paying about $2,996 a year on average, compared with $3,226 for men, about $230 less.

We could not find a New Jersey ranking of the cheapest companies specifically for women. For young women, NJM was the cheapest company in Study H’s teen data, from $326 a month at 16 to $280 at 19. For adult drivers, NJM, GEICO, and Plymouth Rock are sensible starting points for otherwise comparable quotes; published gender averages do not identify a universally cheapest carrier.

Blended full and minimum coverage policies. Source: Study I, October 2026.

Blended full and minimum coverage policies. Source: Study I, October 2026.

Best New Jersey car insurance after an accident, ticket, or DUI, or with poor credit

Cheapest New Jersey companies by driving record and credit, Study F (monthly, full coverage)

Profile 1st 2nd 3rd
At-fault accident NJM $183 GEICO $195 Plymouth Rock $253
Speeding ticket Plymouth Rock $178 GEICO $181 NJM $223
DUI GEICO $199 Plymouth Rock $216 NJM $223
Poor credit NJM $288 Progressive $391 GEICO $407

Yearly full coverage before and after one at-fault accident. Source: Study D.

Yearly full coverage before and after one at-fault accident. Source: Study D.

NJM stands out for drivers with a recent accident. In Study D’s data, one at-fault accident raised NJM’s yearly price by only 9%, compared with 43% at GEICO, 66% at Progressive, and 73% at Travelers. On average, Study B found a speeding ticket raised New Jersey rates by 45%, an at-fault accident by 23%, and a DWI by 61%.

A DUI is especially costly in New Jersey. Study A put the average six-month premium after a DUI at $2,865, about $1,530 more than with a clean record, with NJM cheapest at $1,169, followed by Progressive at $1,218 and GEICO at $1,458. On top of that, the MVC charges a $1,000 surcharge every year for three years after a first or second DWI.

Car insurance rates in New Jersey cities

Where you live in New Jersey can change your rate by more than $1,400 a year. Urban areas in the north, including Newark, Paterson, and Elizabeth, cost the most, while suburban towns such as Princeton and Toms River cost the least.

30-year-old man, good credit, clean record, 2018 Honda CR-V. Source: Study G, May 2026.

30-year-old man, good credit, clean record, 2018 Honda CR-V. Source: Study G, May 2026.

New Jersey city rates compared with the state average, Study G

City Monthly Yearly (our calculation) Vs. NJ average
Newark $314 $3,768 +50%
Paterson $303 $3,636 +45%
Elizabeth $302 $3,624 +45%
Camden $278 $3,336 +33%
Jersey City $272 $3,264 +30%
Trenton $230 $2,760 +10%
Edison $215 $2,580 +3%
Cherry Hill $200 $2,400 -4%
Toms River $198 $2,376 -5%
Princeton $195 $2,340 -6%

Plymouth Rock had the cheapest minimum coverage in all eight New Jersey cities Study H listed, from $61 a month in Edison to $85 in Paterson and Elizabeth.

New Jersey car insurance requirements in 2026

New Jersey raised its minimum liability limits under a 2022 law. For Standard policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2026, the minimum is $35,000 per person and $70,000 per accident for bodily injury, plus $25,000 for property damage, up from 25/50/25 in 2023 and 15/30/5 before that. New Jersey drivers choose between a Standard policy and a much more limited Basic policy, and Medicaid recipients may qualify for a special low-cost policy.

New Jersey auto policy options, 2026

Coverage Standard policy Basic policy Special Automobile Insurance Policy (SAIP)
Bodily injury liability $35,000 / $70,000 minimum None; $10,000 optional None
Property damage liability $25,000 minimum $5,000 None
Personal injury protection $15,000 to $250,000+; $250,000 default $15,000, up to $250,000 for certain serious injuries Emergency care; up to $250,000 for serious brain and spinal injuries
Uninsured and underinsured motorist Required None None
Death benefit Varies Varies $10,000
Cost Varies by insurer Usually much less than Standard $365 a year, or $360 paid in full
Who it is for Most drivers Drivers with few assets Drivers on Federal Medicaid with hospitalization

Standard policy minimums under P.L.2022, c.87. Source: New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance (DOBI).

Standard policy minimums under P.L.2022, c.87. Source: New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance (DOBI).

Personal injury protection (PIP)

New Jersey is a no-fault state, so your own PIP pays your medical bills after a crash regardless of who caused it. You can choose PIP limits of $15,000, $50,000, $75,000, $150,000, or $250,000. If you do not choose a lower limit in writing, your insurer must give you $250,000. Certain serious injuries, such as permanent brain or spinal cord injuries, are covered up to $250,000, whatever limit you choose.

When comparing policy components, the car insurance basics guide explains liability and physical-damage coverage in more detail.

You can also make your health insurance primary for auto injuries, which DOBI says may reduce your premium, but Medicare and Medicaid cannot be primary, and a lapse in your health coverage adds a $750 PIP deductible. Raising your PIP deductible to $2,500 may reduce the PIP portion of the premium; a quoted reduction for PIP is not a 25% reduction of the total policy premium.

The lawsuit option

New Jersey drivers choose between the Limitation on Lawsuit option, which limits your right to sue for pain and suffering to serious injuries such as a displaced fracture, permanent injury, or significant scarring, and the No Limitation option, which keeps your full right to sue.

Limitation costs less and applies by law if you make no choice. As of June 30, 2025, 97.21% of Standard policies in New Jersey carried the Limitation option, according to DOBI. Each insurer must show on its coverage selection form how much more No Limitation costs.

Share of Standard policy exposures. Source: DOBI semi-annual report.

Share of Standard policy exposures. Source: DOBI semi-annual report.

What most New Jersey drivers choose

DOBI’s 2026 Buyer’s Guide shows the options most New Jersey drivers pick, which is a useful starting point for your own policy.

Common New Jersey coverage choices vs. our recommendation

Coverage What most drivers choose (DOBI) Our recommendation
Bodily injury liability Varies At least 100/300, more if you own a home or have savings
PIP medical limit $250,000 $250,000 unless your health plan can be primary
PIP deductible $250 $1,000 to $2,500 if you have savings
Uninsured and underinsured motorist $300,000 Match your liability limits
Lawsuit option Limitation on Lawsuit Limitation for most budgets
Collision deductible $500 (Standard default is $750) $500 to $1,000

Penalties for driving uninsured in New Jersey

Penalties for driving without insurance in New Jersey

Offense Fine Other penalties
First offense $300 to $1,000 Community service; license suspension of up to 1 year
Repeat offense Up to $5,000 14 days in jail, 30 days of community service, suspension of up to 2 years
MVC insurance surcharge $250 a year for 3 years $750 total

About 14.1% of New Jersey drivers were uninsured in 2023, according to the Insurance Research Council, ranking 20th in the nation, slightly below the 15.4% national rate. That is why uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, which is required on Standard policies, is worth carrying at limits well above the minimum.

MVC surcharges can cost more than your insurance increase

New Jersey’s Motor Vehicle Commission charges its own surcharges on top of any insurance increase, billed every year for three years.

New Jersey MVC insurance surcharges

Violation Yearly surcharge Three-year total
6 or more points in 3 years $150, plus $25 per point over 6 Varies
First or second DWI $1,000 $3,000
Third DWI within 3 years $1,500 $4,500
Refusing a breath test $1,000 $3,000
Driving while suspended $250 $750
Uninsured vehicle $250 $750
Unlicensed or expired license $100 $300

New Jersey points for common violations

New Jersey MVC points for common violations

Violation Points
Speeding 1 to 14 mph over the limit 2
Speeding 15 to 29 mph over 4
Speeding 30 mph or more over 5
Reckless driving 5
Tailgating 5
Careless driving 2
Failure to stop for a light or stop sign 2
Improper turn or U-turn 3
Leaving the scene of a crash with injury 8
Red-light camera ticket 0

Six or more points within three years triggers an MVC surcharge of $150 a year, plus $25 for each extra point, on top of any increase from your insurer. Study B found a speeding ticket raised the average New Jersey premium by about 45%.

Car insurance discounts in New Jersey

New Jersey requires every insurer to offer a discount for completing an approved defensive driving course, generally at least 5% on liability, PIP, and collision coverage, and the course can also remove two points from your record once every five years. Beyond that, discounts vary by company.

New Jersey car insurance discounts by company

Company Discounts with published amounts Other discounts listed
NJM None published Defensive driving (up to 3 years), driver training, good student, home and auto bundle, multi-vehicle, new car, paid in full, e-payment, paperless, safety equipment
GEICO Clean record up to 22%; multi-vehicle up to 25%; good student up to 15%; DriveEasy typically 5% to 15% Defensive driving, multi-policy, paperless, paid in full
Progressive Snapshot average $328; multi-car average 12%; sign online average 10%; online quote average 7% Pay in full, paperless, continuous insurance, teen driver
State Farm Drive Safe and Save up to 30%; good student up to 25% Steer Clear, defensive driving, anti-theft, bundling
Plymouth Rock Defensive driver up to 5% Paid in full; home, condo, or renters bundle; Road Rewards gift cards
Travelers None confirmed for NJ Continuous insurance, good student, multi-policy, multi-car

Maximum or average amounts as published by each insurer; NJ defensive driving minimum from N.J.A.C. 11:3-24.3.

Maximum or average amounts as published by each insurer; NJ defensive driving minimum from N.J.A.C. 11:3-24.3.

PRO TIP #4

Take an MVC-approved defensive driving course even with a clean record. New Jersey insurers must give a discount, generally at least 5%, and the course can remove two points from your license if you ever need it, once every five years.

How to save money on car insurance in New Jersey

  1. Compare quotes from NJM, GEICO, and Plymouth Rock first, since they were cheapest in most New Jersey studies we reviewed.
  2. Compare the Limitation on Lawsuit and No Limitation options; the less expensive option restricts certain claims for noneconomic damages, so do not select it solely because it is common.
  3. Consider making your health insurance primary for PIP if your plan qualifies and is not Medicare or Medicaid.
  4. Price several PIP deductibles and compare the full-policy premium, considering the extra out-of-pocket cost after an injury.
  5. Choose higher collision and comprehensive deductibles if you have savings to cover them.
  6. Add a teen to a parent’s policy instead of buying a separate policy, and ask for good student and driver training discounts.
  7. Bundle auto with home, condo, or renters insurance.
  8. Enroll in a telematics program such as State Farm Drive Safe and Save or Progressive Snapshot if you drive safely.
  9. Pay in full and use electronic payments where your insurer offers a discount.
  10. Avoid points and DWIs, which bring both insurance increases and MVC surcharges.
  11. Shop again at every renewal, since New Jersey approved more than 300 rate increases from 2022 to early 2026.

PRO TIP #5

Do not lower your PIP limit just to save money unless you understand the tradeoff. A lower limit cuts your premium, but serious medical bills can exceed $15,000 quickly, and only certain catastrophic injuries are covered up to $250,000 regardless of your choice.

PRO TIP #6

If you are on Federal Medicaid with hospitalization and cannot afford a Standard policy, ask about New Jersey’s Special Automobile Insurance Policy. It costs $365 a year and meets the legal requirement to drive, though it does not cover damage you cause to others.

New Jersey car insurance rate trends

New Jersey drivers have seen steep increases. GEICO requested a 26% increase and Allstate 29% in 2023, and Allstate later reported approval of just under 17% in one statement and 20% in another.

According to a May 2026 report, regulators approved more than 300 rate increases since 2022, including 69 double-digit increases, and said they blocked almost $1.2 billion in requested increases since 2023. In October 2026, DOBI ordered GEICO to refund more than $10.5 million to about 15,000 New Jersey policyholders and pay a $1.2 million penalty after finding rates above approved levels and other problems.

How to choose the right New Jersey car insurance company

  1. Decide on your coverage first: Standard or Basic policy, PIP limit, lawsuit option, liability limits above the 35/70/25 minimum, and whether you need collision and comprehensive.
  2. Get quotes from at least three companies, starting with NJM, GEICO, and Plymouth Rock, and add Travelers or Selective.
  3. Compare the same coverage on every quote, including the same PIP limit and deductibles.
  4. Check each company’s DOBI complaint index and J.D. Power score, not just the price.
  5. Ask about every discount, including the required defensive driving discount.
  6. Review your coverage selection form carefully before you sign it, since New Jersey choices such as the lawsuit option and PIP limit are made there.

Buying direct or through an agent in New Jersey

New Jersey drivers can buy car insurance in three ways. Direct insurers such as NJM and GEICO sell online and by phone. Agency companies such as Selective sell only through independent agents and do not offer online quotes. Some companies sell both ways, and Plymouth Rock’s Road Rewards program in New Jersey requires a policy bought through an independent agent.

For broader steps to reduce car insurance costs, compare coverage as well as the premium.

Shopping online is now the norm. J.D. Power’s 2026 shopping study found that 48% of new auto policies nationwide were bought digitally and that shoppers got about 3.5 quotes on average. An independent agent can still save time by quoting several companies at once, especially agency-only insurers like Selective and The Hanover that you cannot quote online.

For a separate discussion of comparing general insurance quotes and the information you should prepare, see our quoting guide.

Common mistakes New Jersey drivers make

  • Buying only the minimum liability limits, which can leave you personally responsible after a serious crash.
  • Choosing the Basic policy without realizing it includes no bodily injury liability unless you add $10,000.
  • Making Medicare or Medicaid your primary PIP coverage, which New Jersey does not allow.
  • Letting coverage lapse, which brings fines, a possible license suspension, and a $250-a-year MVC surcharge for three years.
  • Comparing quotes with different PIP limits, deductibles, or lawsuit options.
  • Assuming Erie is an option, when it does not sell car insurance in New Jersey.

Pro tips for New Jersey drivers

PRO TIP #7

Include NJM among the first quotes, along with GEICO and Plymouth Rock. It was the cheapest or among the three cheapest companies in nearly every New Jersey study we reviewed, and its complaint record is the best of any large insurer in the state.

PRO TIP #8

If you live in Newark, Paterson, or Elizabeth, compare Plymouth Rock and GEICO carefully. City drivers pay up to 50% more than the state average in Study G, and Plymouth Rock had the cheapest minimum coverage in every city Study H listed.

PRO TIP #9

Raise your uninsured and underinsured motorist limits to match your liability limits. About one in seven New Jersey drivers was uninsured in 2023, and many more carry only the minimum.

Cartoon infographic summarizing New Jersey car insurance companies: NJM overall winner with 699 J.D. Power score and 0.042 complaint index; GEICO largest insurer at 21.4 percent share; Plymouth Rock third; 2026 minimum limits 35/70/25; rates up 10.46 percent in 2026; cheapest car to insure Chevrolet Express at 942 dollars per six months; compare three quotes.

New Jersey car insurance companies, explained in pictures.

Frequently asked questions about New Jersey car insurance companies

What is the best car insurance company in New Jersey?

NJM is our overall winner for its low prices, the state’s best complaint record among large insurers, and the top J.D. Power score of any company sold in New Jersey.

Who has the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey?

NJM, GEICO, and Plymouth Rock. NJM was cheapest in four studies we reviewed and GEICO in three.

What is the largest car insurance company in New Jersey?

GEICO, with 21.39% of insured vehicles as of June 2025, followed by Progressive and NJM.

What are New Jersey’s minimum car insurance limits in 2026?

For Standard policies, 35/70/25: $35,000 per person and $70,000 per accident for injuries, and $25,000 for property damage.

How much is car insurance in New Jersey?

Average full coverage ranges from about $2,736 to $3,687 a year, depending on the study and driver profile.

Can anyone buy NJM insurance?

Yes. NJM says it now offers personal insurance to all residents of the states it serves, subject to underwriting.

Is NJM cheaper than GEICO in New Jersey?

It depends on the driver. NJM was cheaper in Studies B, C, D, and H, while GEICO was cheaper in Studies E, F, and G, so compare quotes from both.

What is the New Jersey Basic policy?

A low-cost option with $5,000 property damage, $15,000 PIP, and no bodily injury liability unless you add $10,000. DOBI says it usually costs much less but gives far less protection.

Does Erie sell car insurance in New Jersey?

No. Erie appears in J.D. Power’s Mid-Atlantic ranking but does not sell car insurance in New Jersey.

What is the cheapest car to insure in New Jersey?

The Chevrolet Express, at about $942 for six months of full coverage, followed by the Honda HR-V in Study D.

The final word on New Jersey car insurance companies

New Jersey car insurance companies vary widely in price, service, and complaints, and that matters more than ever after a January 2026 report projected a substantial rate increase. NJM is our overall winner, with low prices, the best complaint record among large insurers, and the top satisfaction score in the state. GEICO and Plymouth Rock are the strongest alternatives, and Travelers, Selective, and Amica stand out for full coverage value, low complaints, and service.

To get the best deal, compare at least three quotes with identical coverage, choose your PIP limit and lawsuit option carefully, take a defensive driving course, and pick a car that is cheap to insure. Check DOBI’s complaint data before you switch, and shop again at every renewal.

Sources

Disclaimer

This article is an independent review provided for informational purposes only. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or paid by any insurer named here, including NJM, GEICO, Plymouth Rock, Travelers, Selective, Amica, Progressive, State Farm, CSAA (AAA), USAA, Allstate, Penn National, Farmers, Liberty Mutual, MetLife, Mercury, The Hanover, Encompass, Direct Auto, Bristol West, CURE, or Erie, or by J.D. Power, AM Best, or the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance. All trademarks belong to their owners.

This article is not insurance, legal, or financial advice, and it is not an offer to sell insurance. We are not an insurance company or licensed agent.

Our ranking reflects our own editorial judgment based on public data. Prices are averages from third-party studies using sample driver profiles and are not quotes, and the studies use different methods. Rates, laws, ratings, and complaint data change often. Always confirm details with the insurer and DOBI, read your policy and coverage selection form, and consult a licensed professional before you decide.

Related Articles