Best Car Insurance Companies in Florida: 2026–2027 Guide

By the editorial team · Updated for 2027 · Last updated: November 1, 2026

Generalinsurance.org Editorial Team

Independent insurance information and research

Editorial standards, sources and limitations

Our editorial team compares third-party rate studies, regulatory publications and insurer materials. This article describes sample rates, not individual quotes; its ranking is editorial and combines studies that may use different underwriting criteria.

We distinguish Florida legal requirements from coverage recommendations, identify sample-profile differences and link to original references. No named insurer has reviewed this material. We do not claim that the writers hold an insurance producer license or professional credential.

Reviewed November 20, 2026. Florida requirements and insurer rates can change; confirm coverage with a licensed agent and state agencies.

Comparing car insurance companies in Florida heading into 2027 requires more than one price table. Multiple insurers filed rate reductions in 2026, but premiums still depend heavily on the driver, ZIP code, limits and vehicle. Our editorial selection highlights State Farm, GEICO and Travelers as frequent low-price contenders in different studies, while Florida Farm Bureau led the 2026 Florida customer-satisfaction survey. No company is cheapest for everyone.

Many Florida guides still show State Farm with an A++ rating it lost in November 2025, list Travelers as A- when it is rated A++, say Florida requires bodily injury coverage when it does not, or name GEICO the J.D. Power winner from 2025. This guide ranks 20 companies using J.D. Power’s 2026 Florida scores, current AM Best ratings, the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation’s (OIR) rate data, and rate studies from eight sources.

The cited studies do not provide a comparable statewide set of 2027 premiums, so the prices in this guide are the latest available heading into 2027. We also cover the best insurers for sedans, SUVs, vans, trucks, sports cars, and Teslas, the best companies for teens, seniors, and women, the 10 cheapest cars to insure, city rates, Florida’s PIP rules and required discounts, and pro tips to save money.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • State Farm is an editorial overall pick, not a verified statewide cheapest insurer. It led the primary comparison in Study B, but a separate page from that same source showed a lower Auto-Owners average.
  • Florida Farm Bureau won J.D. Power’s 2026 Florida study with 693, the highest score of any ranked insurer, and Farmers and the Auto Club (AAA) finished second and third.
  • Florida OIR reported a -12.6% indicated average 2026 rate change among the five largest auto insurance groups as of fall 2026; an indicated filing trend is not a guaranteed reduction for every policyholder.
  • Florida requires only $10,000 of PIP and $10,000 of property damage liability, and 20.6% of drivers were uninsured in 2023.
  • The Chrysler Voyager had the lowest six-month premium among vehicles sampled in Study D ($1,192); this is not a price available to every Florida driver.

Best car insurance companies in Florida at a glance. Sources: J.D. Power 2026 via Study C, Study B (November 2026), Florida OIR, Florida Statutes, and the Insurance Research Council.

Best car insurance companies in Florida at a glance. Sources: J.D. Power 2026 via Study C, Study B (November 2026), Florida OIR, Florida Statutes, and the Insurance Research Council.

How we ranked the best car insurance companies in Florida

We weighed five factors. Price came from rate studies by eight sources, labeled Study A through Study H because each uses a different driver profile. Customer satisfaction came from J.D. Power’s 2026 Florida region scores, financial strength from AM Best, and recent rate trends from OIR. For this comparison we used a national NAIC auto complaint index, where 1.00 is average; it should not be interpreted as a Florida-specific complaint measure. One factor worth evaluating alongside price is the insurance deductible and how it affects claims.

Florida lets insurers price by credit, age, gender, and ZIP code, so your own quote can differ sharply from these averages. Several studies also leave out USAA, Florida Farm Bureau, and the Auto Club, so a missing price does not mean a company is expensive.

How much car insurance costs in Florida heading into 2027

Florida is one of the most expensive states for car insurance. Averages range from about $219 a month for full coverage in Study H to $321 in Study C, because each study uses different limits and drivers. Study B found an average of $235 a month for full coverage and $143 for liability only, well above the national averages of $187 and $99.

Studies use different driver profiles and coverage levels. Study C and Study E monthly figures are our calculations from yearly averages; Study G uses actual marketplace quotes.

Studies use different driver profiles and coverage levels. Study C and Study E monthly figures are our calculations from yearly averages; Study G uses actual marketplace quotes.

The trend is moving in drivers’ favor. Study B projected Florida full coverage would end 2026 about 3% cheaper than a year earlier, and dozens of insurers filed rate cuts in 2026. The studies reviewed did not establish a comparable statewide 2027 rate table as of November 2026.

The top 20 car insurance companies in Florida

Important comparison limit: this top-20 list is an editorial shortlist, not a single actuarial price ranking. The rates combine different studies, driver profiles and policy assumptions. In particular, the $90/month Auto-Owners result from a separate Study B page is lower than State Farm’s $125/month main-table figure; those samples are not confirmed comparable. Do not interpret rank number as proof that a company costs less.

Here is our ranking of the 20 best car insurance companies in Florida. Study B publishes liability-only and full coverage prices for more than 20 Florida insurers, so we used it for 14 companies. We used Study C for Travelers, Nationwide, UAIC, and Farmers, and Study G for Kemper.

Florida Farm Bureau, the Auto Club, and USAA had no comparable Florida prices in the studies we reviewed, so we ranked them on satisfaction, ratings, and rate trends. Compare companies from the same study when you can.

Vector illustration of 10 numbered cars labeled with the best Florida car insurance companies: 1 State Farm, 125 dollars a month; 2 GEICO, 189 dollars; 3 Travelers, 210 dollars; 4 Florida Farm Bureau, J.D. Power score 693; 5 Auto Club (AAA), J.D. Power 672; 6 Progressive, 142 dollars; 7 USAA, J.D. Power 728 for military families; 8 Allstate, 173 dollars; 9 Nationwide, 278 dollars; 10 UAIC, 218 dollars.

The top 10 car insurance companies in Florida, ranked on price, satisfaction, financial strength, and rate trends.

Top 20 car insurance companies in Florida, ranked

Rank Company Liability only (monthly) Full coverage (monthly) Rate source J.D. Power 2026 Florida
1 State Farm $81 $125 Study B 648
2 GEICO $92 $189 Study B 642
3 Travelers $65 $210 Study C 627
4 Florida Farm Bureau Not published Not published None 693
5 Auto Club (AAA) Not published Not published None 672
6 Progressive $90 $142 Study B 634
7 USAA Not published Not published None 728*
8 Allstate $123 $173 Study B 641
9 Nationwide $109 $278 Study C Not rated
10 UAIC $151 $218 Study C Not rated
11 Auto-Owners $48 $90 Study B 619
12 Mercury $132 $185 Study B Not rated
13 Farmers $95 $398 Study C 675
14 Kemper $120 $211 Study G Not rated
15 Clearcover $89 $216 Study B Not rated
16 Direct Auto $122 $193 Study B 581
17 Bristol West $139 $204 Study B Not rated
18 Root $173 $297 Study B Not rated
19 Dairyland $125 $316 Study B 624
20 The General $128 $251 Study B 606

*USAA is not eligible for J.D. Power’s official rankings. Study C prices are yearly state minimum and full coverage premiums divided by 12. Study G’s Kemper figures are averages of actual quotes. Auto-Owners’ Study B figures come from a separate page of the same study. “Not rated” means the company was not in J.D. Power’s Florida results. The Florida region average was 639.

Partner quotes for Florida drivers with clean records and good credit. Source: Study B, November 2026.

Partner quotes for Florida drivers with clean records and good credit. Source: Study B, November 2026.

1. State Farm: the overall winner

State Farm was cheaper than GEICO for full coverage in Studies B, C and D as tabulated here, but its $125 monthly rate in Study B was not the lowest figure published anywhere by that source: a separate Auto-Owners page showed $90. The sources may use different samples, so they should not be treated as a unified ranking. It was the cheapest company for a Toyota RAV4, Corolla, Silverado, Tacoma, and Mustang in Study C’s Florida model data and the cheapest after an accident in Study F’s data.

It scored 648 with J.D. Power, above the 639 average, and OIR approved a 10.1% rate cut in early 2026, its third decrease since 2024.

Strengths: low prices across many profiles, local agents statewide, and steadily falling rates. Weaknesses: AM Best downgraded its main auto company to A+ in November 2025, and it was not the cheapest company in Studies F and H, where GEICO edged it out.

2. GEICO: cheapest in three studies

GEICO was the cheapest company in Studies E, F, and H, at $175, $213, and $163 a month for full coverage, and the cheapest in Miami, Tampa, Orlando, and Jacksonville in Study F’s city data. It carries AM Best’s highest rating, A++, scored 642 with J.D. Power, and filed cuts reaching more than 1.3 million Florida drivers in 2026. Weakness: its full coverage price in Study B, $189 a month, was well above State Farm’s and Progressive’s.

3. Travelers: cheapest for full coverage in three studies

Travelers was the cheapest full coverage company in Studies A, C, and D, and in Study G’s quote data, and it was cheapest for seniors in Study D. It carries an A++ rating and the best national complaint index of any company in our top 10, at 0.52. Several competing guides still show it as A-. Weaknesses: a J.D. Power score of 627, below average, and much higher prices in Study B.

4. Florida Farm Bureau: highest customer satisfaction

Florida Farm Bureau won J.D. Power’s 2026 Florida study with 693, 54 points above the regional average, and OIR approved an 8.7% rate cut for it in early 2026. Weaknesses: you must join the Farm Bureau, and none of the major rate studies published Florida prices for it.

5. Auto Club (AAA): strong service and falling rates

The Auto Club Group, which sells AAA insurance in Florida, scored 672 with J.D. Power, third in Florida, and OIR reported three AAA rate cuts totaling about 15%. Weaknesses: AAA membership is required, and no major study published comparable Florida prices.

6. Progressive: second cheapest in Study B

Progressive was second cheapest in Study B, at $142 a month for full coverage, cut rates by about 8% in 2026, and returned about $1 billion to roughly 2.7 million Florida policyholders. It is one of Florida’s five largest auto insurers. Weaknesses: a J.D. Power score of 634 and the highest full coverage price in Study C, at $6,622 a year.

7. USAA: for military families

USAA scored 728 with J.D. Power, the highest of any company, though it is not eligible for official rankings, and it cut Florida rates by about 7% on more than 498,000 policies in 2026. Only military members, veterans, and their families can buy it.

8. Allstate: improving prices

Allstate scored 641 with J.D. Power, just above average, carries an A+ rating, and cut rates by 7% for more than 171,000 Florida drivers in 2026. Weakness: it was among the most expensive companies in Studies C, D, and F.

9. Nationwide: cheapest for many vehicles

Nationwide was the cheapest company for a Honda Accord, Odyssey, Toyota Sienna, Ford Explorer, F-150, and both Tesla models in Study C’s Florida model data. Weakness: its average state price in Study C was higher, at $3,335 a year for full coverage.

10. UAIC: best for drivers with poor credit

United Automobile Insurance Company (UAIC) was the cheapest company for drivers with poor credit in Studies E, F, and H and second cheapest for full coverage in Study C. We found no AM Best rating for it, and it was not included in J.D. Power’s Florida results.

11 to 15. Auto-Owners, Mercury, Farmers, Kemper, and Clearcover

Auto-Owners, rated A+, posted the lowest prices on Study B’s best-companies page, at $90 a month for full coverage, though that figure comes from a separate page of Study B, and Auto-Owners scored 619 with J.D. Power. Mercury was second cheapest in Study G’s full coverage quotes. Farmers scored 675 with J.D. Power, second in Florida, but was among the most expensive in Study C. Kemper and Clearcover were cheap for minimum coverage in Studies G and B.

16 to 20. Direct Auto, Bristol West, Root, Dairyland, and The General

These companies are worth a quote if you have trouble finding coverage elsewhere. Root and Bristol West had the two cheapest minimum coverage quotes in Study G, but Direct Auto and The General scored 581 and 606 with J.D. Power, the lowest in Florida.

Editorial choice: State Farm, with important caveats

OVERALL WINNER

State Farm is our provisional editorial choice for drivers who value a mix of sample prices, agent access and customer satisfaction; it is not demonstrably the best or least expensive insurer for most Florida drivers. It performed competitively across the published rate comparisons and model-specific tables, but the source samples and coverage assumptions differ; rankings cannot establish a single Florida-wide winner.

It scored 648 in J.D. Power’s 2026 Florida study, above the 639 average, and OIR approved a 10.1% average rate cut for it in early 2026.

State Farm did not win every category. GEICO was cheaper in Studies E, F, and H and in most big South Florida cities, Travelers was cheapest for full coverage in four studies, and Florida Farm Bureau scored 45 points higher with J.D. Power. The table below compares the top three by price.

State Farm vs. GEICO vs. Travelers

Measure State Farm GEICO Travelers
Full coverage, Study B (monthly) $125 $189 $260
Full coverage, Study C (yearly) $2,681 $2,865 $2,520
Full coverage, Study H (monthly) $168 $163 $165
J.D. Power 2026 Florida score 648 642 627
NAIC complaint index (national) 0.79 0.69 0.52
AM Best rating A+ A++ A++
Best for Lowest price for most drivers South Florida and young drivers Seniors and full coverage

The NAIC complaint index is national, not Florida-specific; 1.00 is average, and lower is better. Source for complaint figures: NAIC data as published by Study D in August 2026.

Runner-up: GEICO

GEICO is the strongest choice in South Florida and for young drivers. It was the cheapest company for a 16-year-old in Study H’s data, and after a speeding ticket in Studies E, F, and H, it has the highest A++ rating AM Best gives.

Best for customer satisfaction: Florida Farm Bureau

Florida Farm Bureau won J.D. Power’s 2026 Florida study with 693, ahead of Farmers at 675 and the Auto Club at 672. None of the competing guides we reviewed included this result; several still name GEICO and Allstate, who tied in 2025.

Best car insurance companies in Florida by need

Need Best pick Why
Overall State Farm Cheapest in Study B, J.D. Power 648, 10.1% rate cut
South Florida GEICO Cheapest in Miami, Hialeah, Tampa, and Orlando in Study F
Customer satisfaction Florida Farm Bureau No. 1 in J.D. Power 2026 Florida, at 693
Seniors Travelers or GEICO Cheapest at 65 to 75 in Studies D and H
Teens GEICO or State Farm Cheapest at 16 and 18 in Study H
Military families USAA J.D. Power 728 and a 7% rate cut
Poor credit UAIC Cheapest for poor credit in Studies E, F, and H
After a DUI Travelers or UAIC Cheapest after a DUI in Studies F and H
Tesla owners Nationwide Cheapest for the Model 3 and Model Y in Study C

Cheapest car insurance companies in Florida by study

The cheapest of the car insurance companies in Florida changes with the driver profile and the data, but State Farm, GEICO, and Travelers were first or second in nearly every study we reviewed.

Cheapest company in each Florida rate study

Study Cheapest for full coverage Price Cheapest for minimum or liability Price
Study A (monthly) Travelers $165 Travelers $42
Study B (monthly) State Farm $125 State Farm $81
Study C (yearly) Travelers $2,520 GEICO $611
Study D (yearly) Travelers $2,448 GEICO $716
Study E (monthly) GEICO $175 GEICO $30
Study F (monthly) GEICO $213 GEICO $37
Study G (yearly) Travelers $2,130 Root $1,237
Study H (monthly) GEICO $163 GEICO $42

Study B’s Auto-Owners figures, from a separate page, were lower than State Farm’s. Study G figures are averages of actual marketplace quotes. Study A does not publish its driver profile.

State minimum, liability, and full coverage by company, Study C (yearly)

Company State minimum Liability 50/100/50 Full coverage
Travelers $784 $1,218 $2,520
UAIC $1,815 $2,223 $2,612
State Farm $901 $1,512 $2,681
GEICO $611 $1,646 $2,865
Nationwide $1,309 $2,053 $3,335
Mercury $1,056 $2,361 $4,144
Allstate $1,238 $2,415 $4,531
Farmers $1,140 $2,475 $4,777
National General $1,523 $2,780 $4,961
Progressive $1,734 $3,638 $6,622

40-year-old driver, Honda Accord, good credit, clean record, $500 deductibles. Source: Study C, January 2026.

Florida car insurance market share

Five groups dominate Florida auto insurance: Progressive, GEICO, State Farm, Allstate, and USAA. OIR says they held 81% of the market as of October 2026. The most recent company-level figures we found are for 2022, when GEICO and Progressive together wrote about 45% of Florida auto premium.

Rounded shares of 2022 private passenger auto premium. Source: S&P Global data as published by Study F, July 2026.

Rounded shares of 2022 private passenger auto premium. Source: S&P Global data as published by Study F, July 2026.

Car insurance complaints in Florida

Florida does not publish auto complaint ratios by insurer, so we used the NAIC’s national auto complaint index, which compares each company’s share of complaints with its share of the market. An index of 1.00 is average, and lower is better. Among large insurers, Travelers and Nationwide had the fewest complaints for their size, while Liberty Mutual had nearly three times the expected number.

Lower is better. National data, not Florida-specific. Source: NAIC data as published by Study D, August 2026.

Lower is better. National data, not Florida-specific. Source: NAIC data as published by Study D, August 2026.

Customer satisfaction: J.D. Power Florida scores

Florida is its own region in J.D. Power’s U.S. Auto Insurance Study. Florida Farm Bureau won in 2026 with 693, after Allstate and GEICO tied for first in 2025. Six companies beat the regional average of 639, while Direct Auto finished last at 581.

USAA scored 728 but is not rank-eligible. Source: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study; full table as reported by Study C; first place confirmed by Florida Farm Bureau.

USAA scored 728 but is not rank-eligible. Source: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study; full table as reported by Study C; first place confirmed by Florida Farm Bureau.

Financial strength ratings for Florida insurers

Several Florida guides still show State Farm as A++, Travelers as A-, or Auto-Owners as A++. These are the current AM Best financial strength ratings reported by the cited sources.

AM Best financial strength ratings, verified November 2026

Insurer Rating Latest action
GEICO A++ (Superior) Current as of November 2025
USAA A++ (Superior) Affirmed July 2, 2025
Travelers A++ (Superior) Affirmed August 8, 2025
State Farm Mutual Automobile A+ (Superior) Downgraded from A++ on November 14, 2025
Progressive A+ (Superior) Affirmed April 3, 2025
Allstate A+ (Superior) Affirmed August 28, 2025
Auto-Owners A+ (Superior) Downgraded from A++ in October 2024
Nationwide A (Excellent) Affirmed November 7, 2025
Farmers A (Excellent) Affirmed August 1, 2025
Mercury A (Excellent) Affirmed February 24, 2026
Liberty Mutual A (Excellent) Affirmed August 2, 2024
Kemper A- (Excellent) Affirmed August 15, 2025

We found no AM Best rating for UAIC or Root.

PRO TIP #1

Call the Florida Department of Financial Services’ insurance consumer helpline at 1-877-693-5236 if you have a claim dispute or want to check on a company. The state also offers a free mediation program for auto claim disputes.

Best car insurance in Florida by vehicle type

Florida is one of the few states where a study publishes company-by-company prices for many individual models. Study C’s Florida model tables show the same pattern for almost every vehicle: Nationwide or State Farm was cheapest, Travelers and UAIC were usually next, and the most expensive company often charged more than twice as much. Model prices below come from Study D’s August 2026 Florida data unless noted. An additional insurer overview describes National General car insurance coverage.

Best car insurance in Florida for sedans

The Subaru Legacy was the cheapest sedan to insure in Florida, at $1,321 for six months of full coverage, followed by the Volkswagen Jetta at $1,407 and the Honda Civic sedan at $1,433. The most popular sedans cost a little more: the Honda Accord was $1,478, the Toyota Camry $1,513, and the Toyota Corolla $1,537.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, 0 deductibles. Source: Study D, August 2026.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D, August 2026.

Best companies for sedan owners: Nationwide and State Farm. In Study C’s Florida tables, Nationwide was cheapest for a Honda Accord, at $2,278 a year, and State Farm was cheapest for a Toyota Corolla, at $2,438, and a Nissan Altima, at $2,502.

2025 models; 40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, 0 deductibles. Source: Study C, October 2026.

2025 models; 40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study C, October 2026.

Best car insurance in Florida for SUVs

Small SUVs are among the cheapest vehicles to insure in Florida. The Subaru Forester was the cheapest SUV, at $1,218 for six months, followed by the Volkswagen Tiguan, Honda HR-V, Subaru Crosstrek, and Honda CR-V. The Toyota RAV4, Florida’s most-registered vehicle, cost $1,352.

Best companies for SUV owners: State Farm and Nationwide. State Farm was cheapest for a Toyota RAV4 in Study C’s Florida data, at $1,833 a year, and Nationwide was cheapest for a Ford Explorer, at $1,988.

Best car insurance in Florida for vans and minivans

The Chrysler Voyager minivan was the cheapest vehicle of any kind to insure in Florida, at $1,192 for six months. In Study C’s Florida tables, Nationwide was cheapest for both a Honda Odyssey, at $1,684 a year, and a Toyota Sienna, at $2,025, with State Farm second for both.

Best car insurance in Florida for pickup trucks

Pickups cost about the same to insure as midsize sedans in Florida. On Study D’s model pages, the Ford F-150 averaged $2,859 a year, the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 $2,871, the Toyota Tacoma $2,881, and the Ram 1500 $3,091. The compact Ford Ranger made Florida’s top 10 cheapest vehicles at $1,277 for six months.

2024 models; 40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, 0 deductibles. Source: Study C, September 2025.

2024 models; 40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study C, September 2025.

Best companies for truck owners: Nationwide, cheapest for a Ford F-150 at $1,947 a year, and State Farm, cheapest for a Chevrolet Silverado 1500 at $2,075 and a Toyota Tacoma at $2,108.

Best car insurance in Florida for sports cars

Some sports cars are cheap to insure in Florida. The Mazda MX-5 Miata ranked fourth among all Florida vehicles, at $1,236 for six months. A Ford Mustang cost $1,627, a Chevrolet Corvette $1,730, and a Porsche 911 $2,152. State Farm was cheapest for a Mustang in Study C’s Florida data, at $2,397 a year, and Nationwide for a Corvette, at about $2,000.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, 0 deductibles. Source: Study D, August 2026.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D, August 2026.

Best car insurance in Florida for Teslas and EVs

Florida has the second-most electric vehicles in the country, about 450,400 in 2025, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. Teslas averaged $4,743 a year to insure in Florida in Study C’s data, but company choice makes a huge difference: State Farm and Nationwide averaged about $2,250 across Tesla models, while AIG averaged $6,438. Other EVs were cheaper, with the Mini Cooper Electric at $1,370 for six months in Study D’s data.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, 0 deductibles. Source: Study C, May 2026.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study C, May 2026.

Best car insurance in Florida by vehicle type

Vehicle type Cheapest model in Florida (Study D) Cheapest companies (Study C)
Sedan Subaru Legacy, $1,321 per 6 months Nationwide (Accord), State Farm (Corolla, Altima)
SUV Subaru Forester, $1,218 per 6 months State Farm (RAV4), Nationwide (Explorer)
Van or minivan Chrysler Voyager, $1,192 per 6 months Nationwide (Odyssey, Sienna)
Pickup truck Ford Ranger, $1,277 per 6 months Nationwide (F-150), State Farm (Silverado, Tacoma)
Sports car Mazda MX-5 Miata, $1,236 per 6 months State Farm (Mustang), Nationwide (Corvette)
Tesla or EV Mini Cooper Electric, $1,370 per 6 months Nationwide (Model 3, Model Y)

Top 10 cheapest cars to insure in Florida

These are the 10 cheapest vehicles to insure in Florida in Study D’s August 2026 data, for a 40-year-old with full coverage. The list is unusually varied: a minivan, several small SUVs, the Mazda MX-5 Miata roadster, and the Ford Ranger pickup all cost less than $1,300 for six months.

Vector illustration of 10 numbered cars labeled with the cheapest vehicles to insure in Florida and their six-month full coverage prices: 1 Chrysler Voyager 1,192 dollars; 2 Subaru Forester 1,218 dollars; 3 Mini Cooper Countryman JCW 1,231 dollars; 4 Mazda MX-5 Miata 1,236 dollars; 5 Volkswagen Tiguan 1,260 dollars; 6 Subaru Outback 1,264 dollars; 7 Honda HR-V 1,276 dollars; 8 Ford Ranger 1,277 dollars; 9 Subaru Crosstrek 1,277 dollars; 10 Honda CR-V 1,283 dollars.

The 10 cheapest cars to insure in Florida, six-month full coverage premiums.

Top 10 cheapest cars to insure in Florida, Study D

Rank Model 6-month premium About per month
1 Chrysler Voyager $1,192 $199
2 Subaru Forester $1,218 $203
3 Mini Cooper Countryman JCW $1,231 $205
4 Mazda MX-5 Miata $1,236 $206
5 Volkswagen Tiguan $1,260 $210
6 Subaru Outback $1,264 $211
7 Honda HR-V $1,276 $213
8 Ford Ranger $1,277 $213
9 Subaru Crosstrek $1,277 $213
10 Honda CR-V $1,283 $214

For an 18-year-old, the same data shows a Chrysler Voyager costs $4,091 for six months and a Subaru Forester $4,257, more than three times the 40-year-old price.

PRO TIP #2

Get insurance quotes before you buy a car in Florida. A Chrysler Voyager cost $1,192 for six months in Study D’s data, while a Nissan Z cost $2,370, a difference of more than $2,300 a year.

Best car insurance companies in Florida for teens

Teens are the most expensive drivers to insure in Florida. Study H found a 16-year-old averaged $439 a month for full coverage and an 18-year-old $312. GEICO was cheapest at 16, at $339 a month, and State Farm at 18, at $259, with Travelers close behind at both ages.

100/300/100 limits, ,000 deductibles. Source: Study H, October 2026.

100/300/100 limits, $1,000 deductibles. Source: Study H, October 2026.

Other studies agree on the same short list. Study B found Progressive and State Farm cheapest for 18-year-olds, at $242 and $245 a month for full coverage, while Study F found GEICO cheapest for an 18-year-old man who wants liability only, at just $83 a month. Keeping a teen on a parent’s policy saves money: Study B found an 18-year-old paid about $354 a month for full coverage on a parent’s policy, compared with $465 on their own.

PRO TIP #3

Ask every insurer about good student and driver training discounts before your teen is licensed. GEICO advertises a good student discount of up to 15%, and Florida law lets insurers give up to 10% for an approved driver improvement course.

Best car insurance companies in Florida for seniors

Florida has about 4.5 million licensed drivers aged 65 and older, and senior prices climb with age. Study D found average full coverage rose from $3,449 a year at age 65 to $3,970 at 75. GEICO, Travelers, and State Farm were the cheapest companies for seniors in nearly every study.

100/300/100 limits, ,000 deductibles. Source: Study H, October 2026.

100/300/100 limits, $1,000 deductibles. Source: Study H, October 2026.

Study D named Travelers cheapest for 65-, 70-, and 75-year-olds, starting at $182 a month at 65, and Study E found GEICO cheapest at 70, at $156. For minimum coverage, Mercury and Travelers charged 70-year-olds less than $30 a month in Study E’s data.

Florida’s mature driver discount

Florida law requires insurers to give drivers 55 and older a discount on liability, PIP, and collision coverage for three years after they complete a state-approved mature driver course. The law does not set a percentage, insurers may require a clean record, and the course can be taken online from providers approved by the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (FLHSMV). A course ordered by a court after a ticket does not count.

Best car insurance companies in Florida for women

Florida allows insurers to use gender in pricing, but the difference for adults is small and the studies disagree on who pays more. Study G’s September 2026 quotes found women paid $2,017 a year and men $2,065, while Study A found women paid about 2.2% more for the same profile. Among teens, girls consistently pay less: Study B found 18-year-old girls paid $387 a month for full coverage, compared with $411 for boys.

Study G uses actual quotes from September 2026. Study D uses an 18-year-old added to a parents' full coverage policy. Sources: Study G, October 2026; Study D, May 2025.

Study G uses actual quotes from September 2026. Study D uses an 18-year-old added to a parents’ full coverage policy. Sources: Study G, October 2026; Study D, May 2025.

We found no study naming the cheapest Florida companies for women specifically, so women should start with the companies that are cheapest overall: GEICO, State Farm, and Travelers.

Best Florida car insurance after an accident, ticket, or DUI

A speeding ticket raised the average Florida rate by about 14%, a DUI by 22%, and an at-fault accident by 26% in Study B’s data. GEICO was cheapest after a ticket in Study H, Study F, and Study E’s data; Travelers was cheapest after an accident in Study H, and UAIC and Travelers were cheapest after a DUI in Studies H and F. If you also drive for an app, check the separate rules on insurance for Uber and DoorDash drivers.

Florida full coverage after a violation or with poor credit, Study H (monthly)

Company Speeding ticket At-fault accident DUI Poor credit
GEICO $173 $195 $317 $305
State Farm $176 $199 $319 $339
Travelers $179 $181 $290 $308
Progressive $201 $208 $317 $305
UAIC $204 $223 $288 $295
Allstate $251 $260 $386 $448
Nationwide $285 $302 $407 $464
Florida average $219 $232 $343 $376

Florida lets insurers use credit-based insurance scores, and Study F found drivers with poor credit paid about twice as much as those with good credit. UAIC was the cheapest company for poor credit in Studies E, F, and H, at $192 to $295 a month.

Car insurance rates in Florida cities

South Florida is the most expensive region in the state. Study F found full coverage averaged $428 a month in Hialeah and $401 in Miami, compared with $235 in Gainesville and $252 in Tallahassee. GEICO was the cheapest company in Miami, Tampa, Orlando, and Jacksonville, and State Farm in Fort Lauderdale, St. Petersburg, and Tallahassee.

30-year-old man, 2018 Honda Civic, 50/100/50 limits, ,000 PIP, 0 deductibles. Source: Study F, October 2026.

30-year-old man, 2018 Honda Civic, 50/100/50 limits, $10,000 PIP, $500 deductibles. Source: Study F, October 2026.

PRO TIP #4

If you live in Miami-Dade or Broward County, get a GEICO quote first. GEICO was cheapest in Miami, Hialeah, Miami Gardens, and North Miami in Study F’s data, at $224 a month, roughly $180 to $200 less than those cities’ averages.

Florida car insurance requirements for 2027

Florida is a no-fault state with some of the lowest required limits in the country. Every registered vehicle must carry $10,000 of personal injury protection (PIP) and $10,000 of property damage liability (PDL) for the entire registration period. The differences between personal injury protection and other coverages are explored in this explanation of Florida no-fault insurance. Drivers who need coverage for a limited period should also understand the restrictions on temporary car insurance in Florida. A deeper explanation of insurer-specific options appears in the National General versus GEICO auto insurance comparison.

PIP pays 80% of your medical bills and 60% of lost income after a crash, no matter who caused it, plus a $5,000 death benefit. Bodily injury liability is not required for most drivers, but it is the coverage that protects you if you injure someone else.

Florida car insurance requirements at a glance

Coverage Requirement
Personal injury protection (PIP) $10,000
Property damage liability (PDL) $10,000
Bodily injury liability Not required for most drivers; 10/20/10 after certain crashes
FR-44 after a DUI 100/300/50 liability, kept for at least three years
Uninsured motorist coverage Optional, but strongly recommended
Collision and comprehensive Optional, but usually required by a lender

Low required limits leave many Florida drivers underinsured. About 20.6% of Florida drivers had no insurance in 2023, the seventh-highest rate in the country, according to the Insurance Research Council. That is why uninsured motorist coverage and bodily injury liability of at least 50/100 are worth considering even though the law does not require them.

Florida ranked seventh highest. Source: Insurance Research Council, via the Insurance Information Institute.

Florida ranked seventh highest. Source: Insurance Research Council, via the Insurance Information Institute.

Penalties for driving uninsured in Florida

Situation Penalty
Lapse in PIP or PDL License and registration suspended
First reinstatement $150 fee
Second reinstatement within three years $250 fee
Later reinstatements within three years $500 fee
After reinstatement Proof of coverage required for two years

Source: Fla. Stat. 324.0221 and FLHSMV.

How tort reform changed Florida car insurance

Florida’s 2023 tort reform law, HB 837, took effect March 24, 2023. State officials attribute part of the improving insurance market to legal reforms, although falling premiums cannot be attributed entirely to that legislation without a causal analysis. It moved Florida to modified comparative negligence, so a person more than 50% at fault for a crash cannot recover damages, cut the time to file a negligence lawsuit from four years to two, ended one-way attorney fees, and gave insurers a safe harbor from bad-faith claims if they pay within 90 days.

Premium filings and insurer loss ratios changed in subsequent years, but that timing alone does not demonstrate how much of the change the law caused. The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) reports that the five largest auto insurance groups raised rates by an average of 31.7% in 2023, then 4.3% in 2024, before cutting them by 6.5% in 2025. By October 2026, OIR reported that those groups’ indicated 2026 change had reached a 12.6% decrease, and the personal auto loss ratio fell from 89.7% in 2022 to 57.5% in 2024.

Bars show the size of each change: +31.7% in 2023, +4.3% in 2024, -6.5% in 2025, and -12.6% indicated for 2026 as of October. Source: Florida Office of Insurance Regulation.

Bars show the size of each change: +31.7% in 2023, +4.3% in 2024, -6.5% in 2025, and -12.6% indicated for 2026 as of October. Source: Florida Office of Insurance Regulation.

Bills to repeal PIP and require bodily injury coverage were filed again in 2026, but they died in committee, so the no-fault system remains in place for 2027.

Car insurance discounts in Florida

Florida law requires some discounts that many states leave optional. Insurers must give discounts for factory-installed antilock brakes and air bags, for anti-theft devices, and for the mature driver course. They may also give up to 10% for a driver improvement course and approve discounts for collision-avoidance technology. One additional example of available savings programs is the article on National General auto insurance discounts in Florida.

Discounts required or allowed by Florida law

Discount Coverage it lowers Required?
Anti-lock brakes (four-wheel, factory-installed) Liability, PIP, collision Yes
Anti-theft device or recovery system Comprehensive Yes
Factory-installed airbags PIP and medical payments Yes
Mature driver course, age 55 and older Liability, PIP, collision for three years Yes
Driver improvement course, any age Liability, PIP, collision; up to 10% Optional
VIN etching on windows Comprehensive Optional
Collision-avoidance technology Liability, PIP, collision Optional

Florida car insurance discounts by company

Company Notable discounts Telematics program
GEICO Clean record up to 22%, multi-vehicle up to 25%, good student up to 15% DriveEasy, typically 5% to 15%
State Farm Defensive driving, good driver, multi-car Drive Safe & Save, 10% to enroll, up to 30%
Progressive Multi-car and bundling Snapshot, average savings of $328 a year; rates can rise
Allstate Varies; ask for the current list Drivewise; rates can rise
USAA Military families only SafePilot, up to 30%; confirm Florida availability

Company discount figures from GEICO, State Farm, Progressive, and USAA. Discount amounts vary by driver and may change.

How to save money on car insurance in Florida

  1. Compare at least three quotes, including GEICO, State Farm, and Travelers or Nationwide.
  2. Keep the same limits and deductibles on every quote so you compare like with like.
  3. Ask for every discount Florida law requires, including anti-lock brakes, airbags, and anti-theft devices.
  4. Take the mature driver course if you are 55 or older, and renew it every three years.
  5. Raise your comprehensive and collision deductibles if you can afford the out-of-pocket cost.
  6. Choose a cheap-to-insure vehicle, such as a small SUV or minivan.
  7. Try a telematics program if you drive safely.
  8. Shop again at renewal, because many Florida insurers cut rates in 2025 and 2026.

PRO TIP #5 For drivers concerned about the first bill, compare the rules for Florida car insurance with a low initial payment.

Do not drop comprehensive coverage just because your car is paid off if you live near the coast. Comprehensive is what pays for flood and storm damage to your car, and Hurricane Helene alone led to about 59,000 private auto claims in Florida.

Florida car insurance outlook for 2027

Florida drivers enter 2027 with the best rate trend in years. OIR approved more cuts in early 2026, including 10.1% at State Farm, 8.7% at Florida Farm Bureau, 8% at Progressive, and 7% at USAA, and reported that 42 companies had filed decreases over the previous year. Progressive also returned about $1 billion to roughly 2.7 million Florida policyholders.

Average rate decreases approved or reported in early 2026. Sources: Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (January 2026) and Florida Realtors (March 2026).

Average rate decreases approved or reported in early 2026. Sources: Florida Office of Insurance Regulation (January 2026) and Florida Realtors (March 2026).

What to watch in 2027

Issue Status as of November 2026 What it could mean
Rate filings Top five groups indicated at -12.6% for 2026 Individual renewals may rise or fall; filings do not guarantee a decrease
PIP repeal Bills died in committee in 2026 No-fault rules stay in place for now
Hurricane season Helene and Milton caused nearly $5.2 billion in insured losses A major storm could slow the cuts
Repair costs and tariffs Higher parts prices nationally Could raise collision and comprehensive costs
National forecasts A major broker’s 2027 outlook ranges from -2% to +10% for personal auto Expect wide differences between companies

Buying direct or through an agent in Florida

Florida drivers can buy online or by phone from direct insurers such as GEICO and Progressive, from captive agents who sell one company, such as State Farm and Allstate, or from independent agents who compare several companies at once. Florida Farm Bureau and the Auto Club require a membership, and USAA serves only military families, so many online quote tools leave them out. Getting at least one quote from a local agent is the easiest way to include them. For drivers considering a direct online purchase, see how an instant auto insurance quote application.

If no company will insure you

Drivers who cannot find coverage in the regular market can apply to the Florida Automobile Joint Underwriting Association, the state’s insurer of last resort for auto coverage, through a licensed agent. It is usually more expensive, so get quotes first from companies that insure higher-risk drivers, such as Direct Auto, Bristol West, Dairyland, and The General.

How to choose the best Florida car insurance company

  1. Decide on your coverage: PIP and property damage, plus bodily injury liability, uninsured motorist coverage, and comprehensive for storms.
  2. Get quotes from at least three companies, including State Farm, GEICO, and Travelers.
  3. Add a membership insurer, such as Florida Farm Bureau or the Auto Club, if you qualify.
  4. Compare identical limits and deductibles on every quote.
  5. Check each company’s J.D. Power score and AM Best rating, not just its price.
  6. Ask about every discount Florida law requires.

Common mistakes Florida drivers make

  • Buying only the $10,000 PIP and $10,000 property damage minimum, which leaves your savings exposed if you injure someone.
  • Skipping uninsured motorist coverage in a state where about one in five drivers is uninsured.
  • Dropping comprehensive coverage before hurricane season.
  • Trusting outdated ratings, such as an A++ for State Farm or an A- for Travelers.
  • Letting a policy renew without shopping while many insurers are cutting rates.

Pro tips for Florida drivers

PRO TIP #6

Ask your insurer to confirm every discount Florida law requires, including antilock brakes, air bags, and anti-theft devices. These are easy to miss when a policy is set up online.

PRO TIP #7

Add bodily injury liability even though Florida does not require it for most drivers. PIP covers your own injuries, but only bodily injury liability protects your savings if you injure someone else in a crash you cause.

Cartoon infographic summarizing the best car insurance companies in Florida: State Farm overall winner at 125 dollars a month for full coverage with a J.D. Power score of 648; Florida Farm Bureau 693 and Farmers 675 in J.D. Power 2026; top five insurers indicated a 12.6 percent rate decrease for 2026; Florida requires 10,000 dollars of PIP and 10,000 dollars of property damage, with 20.6 percent of drivers uninsured; Chrysler Voyager cheapest car at 1,192 dollars for six months; compare three quotes.

The best car insurance companies in Florida, explained in pictures.

Frequently asked questions about the best car insurance companies in Florida

What is the best car insurance company in Florida?

State Farm is a reasonable quote to request based on several sampled rate comparisons and its 2026 satisfaction score; it is not a guaranteed lowest-cost choice. GEICO and Travelers are close behind.

Who has the cheapest car insurance in Florida?

GEICO was cheapest in three studies, Travelers was cheapest for full coverage in four, and State Farm was cheapest in Study B.

Which company has the best customer satisfaction in Florida?

Florida Farm Bureau, with a score of 693 in J.D. Power’s 2026 Florida study. Farmers and the Auto Club finished second and third.

What car insurance is required in Florida?

$10,000 of personal injury protection and $10,000 of property damage liability. Bodily injury liability is required only after certain crashes or a DUI.

Are Florida car insurance rates going down?

Yes. OIR reported a 12.6% average decrease indicated for 2026 among the five largest insurers, after years of increases.

Who has the cheapest car insurance in Florida for seniors?

GEICO and Travelers. GEICO was cheapest at 65 and 75 in Study H, and Travelers at 65, 70, and 75 in Study D.

Is State Farm still rated A++?

No. AM Best downgraded State Farm’s main auto insurer to A+ (Superior) in November 2025, though many websites still show A++.

What is the cheapest car to insure in Florida?

The Chrysler Voyager, at $1,192 for six months of full coverage in Study D, followed by the Subaru Forester.

Who has the cheapest car insurance in Florida for teens?

GEICO was cheapest for a 16-year-old in Study H, at $339 a month for full coverage, and State Farm was cheapest at 18, at $259.

Who has the cheapest car insurance in Miami?

GEICO, at $224 a month for full coverage in Study F, compared with a Miami average of $401.

Did Florida repeal PIP in 2026?

No. Bills to repeal PIP died in committee in 2026, so Florida remains a no-fault state.

The final word on the best car insurance companies in Florida

The best Florida insurer depends on the driver and policy terms. State Farm, GEICO and Travelers performed competitively in different published comparisons, while Florida Farm Bureau led the 2026 regional satisfaction study. GEICO is the price leader in South Florida, Travelers is a strong choice for full coverage and seniors, and Florida Farm Bureau leads in satisfaction.

Compare at least three quotes, buy more than the minimum, and shop again at renewal while rates are falling.

Sources

Additional primary verification: Florida OIR rate trend releases (March and October 2026), J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, and the Florida Senate statutes on motor vehicle insurance and financial responsibility.

Disclaimer

This article is an independent review provided for informational purposes only. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or paid by any insurer named here, including State Farm, GEICO, Travelers, Florida Farm Bureau, the Auto Club, Progressive, USAA, Allstate, Nationwide, UAIC, Auto-Owners, Mercury, Farmers, Kemper, Clearcover, Direct Auto, Bristol West, Root, Dairyland, or The General, or by J.D. Power, AM Best, or the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. All trademarks belong to their owners.

This article is not insurance, legal, or financial advice, and it is not an offer to sell insurance. We are not an insurance company or licensed agent.

Our ranking reflects our own editorial judgment based on public data. Complaint indexes are national NAIC figures, not Florida-specific. Prices are averages from third-party studies using sample driver profiles and are not quotes, the studies use different methods, and no 2027 rates had been published when we updated this article. Rates, laws, ratings, and complaint data change often. Always confirm details with the insurer, OIR, and FLHSMV, read your policy, and consult a licensed professional before you decide.

Related Articles