Best Pennsylvania Car Insurance Companies: Rates & Coverage
Shopping for the best Pennsylvania car insurance companies for 2027 comes with choices drivers in most states never face, from limited versus full tort to stacked uninsured motorist coverage. Our ranking names Erie, the Pennsylvania-based insurer, the overall winner for the highest J.D. Power score in the Mid-Atlantic region and low prices in most studies, with Travelers and State Farm close behind.
Many Pennsylvania guides still show Erie as A+ and State Farm as A++, ratings both companies lost in 2025, cite J.D. Power scores from 2023 or 2024, or list uninsured motorist coverage as required when Pennsylvania lets you reject it in writing. This guide ranks 20 companies using J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic scores, current AM Best ratings, the Pennsylvania Insurance Department’s (PID) rate data, and rate studies from eight sources.
The rates quoted in this guide come from studies published before 2027. They are not verified 2027 premiums, and insurers may already have approved future-effective changes. We also cover the best insurers by vehicle type, the best companies for teens and seniors, the 10 cheapest cars to insure, city rates, tort options, required discounts, and pro tips.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Erie is our overall winner. It won J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic study with 704 and was the cheapest company in Study F, at $134 a month for full coverage.
- Travelers was the cheapest company in Studies A, C, D, and H and has the best national complaint record of any large insurer.
- Pennsylvania requires only 15/30/5 liability plus $5,000 of medical benefits, among the lowest limits in the country.
- State Farm estimated one animal-collision claim per 64 insured Pennsylvania vehicles over the specified reporting period, the fourth-highest odds in the U.S.
- The Honda HR-V was the cheapest vehicle to insure in Pennsylvania, at $1,026 for six months of full coverage.

Best Pennsylvania car insurance companies at a glance. Sources: J.D. Power 2026 via Study C, Study B (November 2026), State Farm (September 2026), PennDOT, and the Insurance Research Council.
How we ranked the best Pennsylvania car insurance companies
We considered five categories, but did not use a pre-registered numerical weighting formula. Price came from rate studies by eight sources, labeled Study A through Study H because each uses a different driver profile. Customer satisfaction came from J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic region scores, financial strength from AM Best, and recent rate changes from PID and state rate filings. We could not find a current PID complaint ratio list, so we used the national NAIC complaint index, where 1.00 is average.

Pennsylvania bans gender as a rating factor, but insurers can still use your credit, age, ZIP code, and driving record, so your own quote can differ sharply from these averages.
How much car insurance costs in Pennsylvania heading into 2027
Pennsylvania is cheaper than the national average for most drivers. Averages range from about $123 a month for full coverage in Study H to $248 in Study G, because each study uses different limits and drivers. Study B found an average of $161 a month for full coverage and $90 for liability only, below the national averages of about $187 and $99.

Studies use different driver profiles and coverage levels. Study C and Study E monthly figures are our calculations from yearly averages; Studies E and H publish no minimum average. Study G uses actual marketplace quotes.
Prices are stabilizing after sharp increases. Study B found Pennsylvania full coverage rose 38% in 2024, but PID reported that approved auto rate filings averaged a 0.2% decrease in 2025 and a 0.5% decrease in early 2026. No study had published 2027 Pennsylvania rates as of November 2026.
Twenty Pennsylvania car insurance companies to compare
Here is an editorial shortlist of 20 insurers to investigate in Pennsylvania, not a statistically validated ranking. Study B publishes liability-only and full coverage prices for 22 Pennsylvania insurers, so we used it for 14 companies. We used Study C for Travelers, Nationwide, Westfield, and Donegal, and Study E for Encova. Penn National had no comparable prices in the studies we reviewed. Compare companies from the same study when you can.

Ten insurers highlighted by the original editorial comparison. Rates come from different studies; this image is not a standardized price ranking.
Twenty Pennsylvania insurers: published sample rates and satisfaction
| Rank | Company | Liability only (monthly) | Full coverage (monthly) | Rate source | J.D. Power 2026 Mid-Atlantic |
| 1 | Erie | $59 | $96 | Study B | 704 |
| 2 | Travelers | $28 | $119 | Study C | 620 |
| 3 | State Farm | $50 | $83 | Study B | 669 |
| 4 | Nationwide | $37 | $151 | Study C | 618 |
| 5 | USAA | $103 | $168 | Study B | 721* |
| 6 | Westfield | $21 | $222 | Study C | Not rated |
| 7 | Donegal | $27 | $226 | Study C | Not rated |
| 8 | GEICO | $80 | $131 | Study B | 634 |
| 9 | Auto-Owners | $63 | $103 | Study B | Not rated |
| 10 | Allstate | $68 | $126 | Study B | 643 |
| 11 | Plymouth Rock | $46 | $111 | Study B | 622 |
| 12 | Progressive | $69 | $148 | Study B | 630 |
| 13 | Encova | $24 | $105 | Study E | Not rated |
| 14 | Penn National | Not published | Not published | None | Not rated |
| 15 | Safeco (Liberty Mutual) | $83 | $126 | Study B | 623 |
| 16 | Chubb | $119 | $195 | Study B | Not rated |
| 17 | CSAA (AAA) | $169 | $261 | Study B | 685 |
| 18 | National General | $59 | $131 | Study B | 585 |
| 19 | Root | $110 | $180 | Study B | Not rated |
| 20 | The General | $68 | $179 | Study B | Not rated |
*USAA is not eligible for J.D. Power’s official rankings. Study C prices are yearly state minimum and full coverage premiums divided by 12. Study E’s Encova figures are median minimum and full coverage rates for a 50-year-old. “Not rated” means the company was not in J.D. Power’s Mid-Atlantic results. The region average was 651.

*Military families only. Median quotes for Pennsylvania drivers with clean records. Source: Study B, November 2026.
1. Erie: the overall winner
Erie, founded in 1925 in Erie, Pennsylvania, won J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic study with 704, the highest score of any ranked insurer. It was the cheapest company in Study F, at $134 a month for full coverage and $31 for liability only, and the cheapest in every Pennsylvania city in Study F’s data, from $109 a month in Harrisburg to $289 in Philadelphia.
It was also the cheapest company after an accident or a ticket in Study F and for 16- and 17-year-olds in Study H.
Strengths: top satisfaction, low prices for most drivers, about 13% of the Pennsylvania market in 2021 NAIC data, and a Rate Lock feature that keeps your rate the same unless you change drivers, vehicles, or address. Weaknesses: AM Best downgraded Erie from A+ to A in September 2025, it sells through independent agents rather than online, and its Pennsylvania rates rose about 70% over five years in Study F’s rate-filing data.
2. Travelers: cheapest in four studies
Travelers was the cheapest company in Studies A, C, D, and H, at $1,423 a year for full coverage in Study C and $68 a month in Study H, and the cheapest for seniors at 60, 65, 70, and 75 in Study D. It carries an A++ rating, and its national NAIC complaint index of 0.52 is the lowest of any large insurer. Weakness: a J.D. Power score of 620, below the regional average.
3. State Farm: cheapest in Study B
State Farm was the cheapest full coverage company in Study B, at $83 a month, cheapest for teens in Study B’s teen table, and it was the largest Pennsylvania auto insurer in the most recent NAIC data we found. It scored 669 with J.D. Power, above the 651 average, and cut Pennsylvania rates by 2.6% in 2026. Weakness: AM Best downgraded its main auto company to A+ in November 2025, though many guides still show A++.
4. Nationwide: cheapest for 65-year-olds in Study H
Nationwide was second cheapest for full coverage in Studies C and H and cheapest for 65-year-olds in Study H, at $83 a month. Its national complaint index of 0.63 is well below average. Weakness: a J.D. Power score of 618.
5. USAA: for military families
USAA scored 721 with J.D. Power, the highest of any company, though it is not eligible for official rankings, and it was among the cheapest companies for drivers with poor credit in Study F. Only military members, veterans, and their families can buy it.
6. Westfield: cheapest minimum coverage
Westfield had the cheapest state minimum price in Study C, at $256 a year, and in Study H, at $20 a month. It carries an A rating. Weakness: its full coverage prices were higher, at $2,660 a year in Study C.
7. Donegal: a Pennsylvania regional insurer
Donegal, based in Marietta, Pennsylvania, was cheapest after a DUI in Study E and cheapest in Allentown and Pittsburgh in Study H’s city data. It carries an A rating. Weakness: higher full coverage prices in Study C.
8. GEICO: A++ and low minimum prices
GEICO carries AM Best’s highest rating, A++, was priced at $131 a month for full coverage in Study B, and was fourth cheapest for minimum coverage in Study D. Weaknesses: a J.D. Power score of 634 and a 2.5% rate increase filed in 2026.
9. Auto-Owners: low prices through agents
Auto-Owners was third cheapest for full coverage in Study B, at $103 a month. Its AM Best group/entity rating needs a current entity-specific check with a national complaint index of 0.54. It is not included in J.D. Power’s Mid-Atlantic results.
10. Allstate: cheapest after a DUI in Study F
Allstate was the cheapest company after a DUI in Study F, charging the same $228 a month after an accident, a ticket, or a DUI. It scored 643 with J.D. Power, close to average. Weakness: higher prices than Erie, Travelers, and State Farm in most studies.
11 to 15. Plymouth Rock, Progressive, Encova, Penn National, and Safeco
Plymouth Rock had the cheapest liability-only price in Study B, at $46 a month, and was cheapest for liability in every city Study B listed. Progressive cut Pennsylvania rates by 2.8% in 2026. Encova, a regional insurer, was the cheapest company overall in Study E. Penn National, founded in Harrisburg in 1919 and rated A, sells through independent agents but was not priced in the studies we reviewed. Safeco was priced at $126 a month in Study B.
16 to 20. Chubb, CSAA (AAA), National General, Root, and The General
Chubb, rated A++, was cheapest for drivers with poor credit in Study E. CSAA, which sells AAA insurance, scored 685 with J.D. Power, third in the region, but had the highest price in Study B, at $261 a month. National General scored 585 with J.D. Power, the lowest in the region.
A NOTE ON NJM
NJM finished second in J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic study with 699 and won in 2025, but none of the rate studies we reviewed published Pennsylvania prices for it, so we could not rank it. It may still be worth a quote.
The overall winner: Erie
OVERALL WINNER
Erie is our provisional editorial leader based on regional satisfaction and competitive prices in selected published studies. It is not demonstrably the best or cheapest for every Pennsylvania driver. It won J.D. Power’s 2026 Mid-Atlantic study with 704, was the cheapest company in Study F and in every Pennsylvania city in that study, and ranked among the three cheapest for full coverage in Studies A, B, C, and D.
Erie did not win every category. Travelers was cheaper in four studies and has a better complaint record and financial strength rating, and State Farm was cheaper in Study B. The table below compares the top three.
Erie vs. Travelers vs. State Farm
| Measure | Erie | Travelers | State Farm |
| Full coverage, Study C (yearly) | $1,848 | $1,423 | $2,795 |
| Full coverage, Study F (monthly) | $134 | $173 | $184 |
| Full coverage, Study B (monthly) | $96 | $125 | $83 |
| J.D. Power 2026 Mid-Atlantic score | 704 | 620 | 669 |
| NAIC complaint index (national) | 0.89 | 0.52 | 0.79 |
| AM Best rating | A | A++ | A+ |
| Best for | Service and most drivers | Seniors and lowest prices | Teens and agent support |
The NAIC complaint index is national, not Pennsylvania-specific; 1.00 is average and lower is better.
Runner-up: Travelers
Travelers has the lowest modeled price in several of the sampled studies, cheapest in four of the eight studies we reviewed, and it has the strongest financial rating and complaint record among the top three. Its main drawback is a J.D. Power score 31 points below the regional average.
Best car insurance companies in Pennsylvania by need
| Need | Best pick | Why |
| Overall | Erie | J.D. Power 704 and cheapest in Study F and every city in it |
| Lowest price | Travelers | Cheapest in Studies A, C, D, and H |
| Seniors | Travelers or Nationwide | Cheapest at 60 to 75 in Study D and at 65 in Study H |
| Teens | Erie or State Farm | Cheapest at 16 and 17 in Study H and for teens in Study B |
| Minimum coverage | Westfield | Cheapest state minimum in Studies C and H |
| After a DUI | Allstate or Donegal | Cheapest after a DUI in Studies F and E |
| Poor credit | USAA, Chubb, or Nationwide | Cheapest for poor credit in Studies F, E, and H |
| Military families | USAA | J.D. Power 721 |
Cheapest car insurance companies in Pennsylvania by study
The lowest sampled insurer changes with the driver profile and the data, but Travelers, Erie, and State Farm came out on top in six of the eight studies we reviewed.
Cheapest company in each Pennsylvania rate study
| Study | Cheapest for full coverage | Price | Cheapest for minimum or liability | Price |
| Study A (monthly) | Travelers | $81 | Travelers | $27 |
| Study B (monthly) | State Farm | $83 | Plymouth Rock | $46 |
| Study C (yearly) | Travelers | $1,423 | Westfield | $256 |
| Study D (yearly) | Travelers | $1,770 | Westfield | $302 |
| Study E (yearly) | Encova | $1,506 | Westfield / Erie | $276 |
| Study F (monthly) | Erie | $134 | Erie | $31 |
| Study G (yearly) | National General | $2,120 | National General | $790 |
| Study H (monthly) | Travelers | $68 | Westfield | $20 |
Study E’s minimum figure is a 50-year-old’s median monthly rate of $23, shown per year. Study G figures are averages of actual marketplace quotes. Study A does not publish its driver profile.
State minimum, liability, and full coverage by company, Study C (yearly)
| Company | State minimum (15/30/5) | Liability 50/100/50 | Full coverage |
| Travelers | $340 | $481 | $1,423 |
| Nationwide | $444 | $527 | $1,809 |
| Erie | $266 | $367 | $1,848 |
| USAA* | $322 | $445 | $1,958 |
| Allstate | $723 | $863 | $2,533 |
| Westfield | $256 | $498 | $2,660 |
| Donegal | $321 | $458 | $2,715 |
| State Farm | $514 | $667 | $2,795 |
| GEICO | $384 | $621 | $2,974 |
| Progressive | $659 | $967 | $3,600 |
*Military families only. 40-year-old driver, Honda Accord, good credit, clean record, $500 deductible. Source: Study C, November 2025.
Pennsylvania car insurance market share
State Farm, Erie, Progressive, Allstate, and GEICO wrote nearly two-thirds of Pennsylvania’s $9.3 billion in auto premium in 2021, the most recent company-level NAIC data we found. Erie’s 13% share makes it the largest Pennsylvania-based auto insurer, and PID says more than 200 insurers compete for Pennsylvania drivers.

Private passenger auto direct premiums written, 2021. Source: NAIC data as published in February 2024.
Car insurance complaints in Pennsylvania
We could not find a current Pennsylvania complaint ratio list by company, so we used the NAIC’s national private passenger auto complaint index. An index of 1.00 is the expected number of complaints for a company’s size, and lower is better. Travelers and Auto-Owners had about half the expected number, while Liberty Mutual had nearly three times as many.

Lower is better. National data, not Pennsylvania-specific. Source: NAIC data as published by Study D, August 2026.
Customer satisfaction: J.D. Power Mid-Atlantic scores
Pennsylvania is part of J.D. Power’s Mid-Atlantic region. Erie moved from second place in 2025 to first in 2026, at 704, ahead of NJM, which won in 2025. Four companies beat the regional average of 651, while National General finished last at 585.

USAA scored 721 but is not rank-eligible. Source: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study; full table as reported by Study C.
Financial strength ratings for Pennsylvania insurers
Several Pennsylvania guides still show Erie as A+ and State Farm as A++. These are the current AM Best financial strength ratings we verified.
AM Best financial strength ratings, verified November 2026
| Insurer | Rating | Latest action |
| GEICO | A++ (Superior) | Affirmed April 16, 2026 |
| USAA | A++ (Superior) | Affirmed June 25, 2026 |
| Travelers | A++ (Superior) | Affirmed August 8, 2025 |
| Chubb | A++ (Superior) | Affirmed January 2026 |
| State Farm Mutual Automobile | A+ (Superior) | Downgraded from A++ on November 14, 2025 |
| Progressive | A+ (Superior) | Affirmed May 1, 2026 |
| Allstate | A+ (Superior) | Affirmed September 2026 |
| Auto-Owners | Verify by underwriting entity | Downgraded from A++ in November 2024 |
| Erie | A (Excellent) | Downgraded from A+ on September 5, 2025 |
| Nationwide | A (Excellent) | Affirmed November 7, 2025 |
| Westfield | A (Excellent) | Affirmed March 4, 2025 |
| Donegal | A (Excellent) | Affirmed May 13, 2025 |
| Penn National | A (Excellent) | Upgraded October 2023 |
We found no AM Best rating for Root.
PRO TIP #1
Call the Pennsylvania Insurance Department’s consumer line at 1-877-881-6388 if you have a question about a claim or a company. PID reviews auto rate filings and blocked $91 million in proposed auto increases in 2025.
Best car insurance in Pennsylvania by vehicle type
Pennsylvania drivers face one risk that shapes every vehicle decision: deer. State Farm estimates Pennsylvania drivers have a 1 in 64 chance of an animal collision, the fourth-highest odds in the country, and the state had the most animal-collision claims of any state, about 141,000 from July 2025 to June 2026. Those claims are paid by comprehensive coverage, so keep it on any vehicle you could not afford to repair yourself.
No study we found ranks Pennsylvania insurers separately for each vehicle type, so this section shows the cheapest models in each class from Study D’s Pennsylvania data and names the companies to start with based on their statewide results.
Best car insurance in Pennsylvania for sedans
The Subaru Legacy was the cheapest sedan to insure in Pennsylvania, at $1,125 for six months of full coverage, followed by the Volkswagen Jetta and the Honda Civic sedan. The Honda Accord cost $1,219, the Toyota Camry $1,262, and the Toyota Corolla $1,281.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D.
Best companies for sedan owners: Erie, Travelers, and State Farm, the three companies that were cheapest or near the cheapest in most Pennsylvania studies.
Best car insurance in Pennsylvania for SUVs
Small SUVs are the cheapest vehicles to insure in Pennsylvania. The Honda HR-V led Study D’s list at $1,026 for six months, followed by the Honda CR-V and Volkswagen Tiguan at $1,048. The Toyota RAV4, Pennsylvania’s best-selling new vehicle in recent sales data, cost $1,096, and the Subaru Outback and Forester were both under $1,100. Best companies for SUV owners: Erie, Travelers, and State Farm.
Best car insurance in Pennsylvania for vans and minivans
The Honda Odyssey was the ninth-cheapest vehicle of any kind to insure in Pennsylvania, at $1,092 for six months, and Study H found it the cheapest of 19 popular models it priced in the state, at $148 a month for full coverage. A Toyota Sienna averaged $2,468 a year on Study D’s model page. Start with Erie, Travelers, and Nationwide.
Best car insurance in Pennsylvania for pickup trucks
The compact Ford Ranger was the fourth-cheapest vehicle to insure in Pennsylvania, at $1,065 for six months. Full-size pickups cost more: on Study D’s model pages, the Toyota Tacoma averaged $2,456 a year, the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 $2,512, the Ford F-150 $2,589, and the Ram 1500 $2,723.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits. Study H monthly figures multiplied by 12 (our calculation). Sources: Study D model pages (2025 data) and Study H model pages (May to August 2026).
Best companies for truck owners: Erie, Travelers, and State Farm. If you use your truck for a business, ask about a commercial policy.
Best car insurance in Pennsylvania for sports cars
The Mazda MX-5 Miata was the cheapest sports car to insure in Pennsylvania, at $1,215 for six months. A Ford Mustang cost $1,534, a Chevrolet Corvette $1,730, and a Porsche 911 Turbo $2,426, about twice the Miata’s price.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D.
Best car insurance in Pennsylvania for Teslas and EVs
Pennsylvania had about 113,400 registered electric vehicles in 2025, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. Teslas are expensive to insure: Study C found a Model 3 averaged $4,205 a year in Pennsylvania and a Model Y $4,140. Other EVs cost much less, led by the Mini Cooper Electric at $1,135 for six months in Study D’s data. We found no Pennsylvania company rankings for Teslas, so start with Erie, Travelers, and State Farm.
Best car insurance in Pennsylvania by vehicle type
| Vehicle type | Cheapest model in Pennsylvania (Study D) | Start your quotes with |
| Sedan | Subaru Legacy, $1,125 per 6 months | Erie, Travelers, State Farm |
| SUV | Honda HR-V, $1,026 per 6 months | Erie, Travelers, State Farm |
| Van or minivan | Honda Odyssey, $1,092 per 6 months | Erie, Travelers, Nationwide |
| Pickup truck | Ford Ranger, $1,065 per 6 months | Erie, Travelers, State Farm |
| Sports car | Mazda MX-5 Miata, $1,215 per 6 months | Erie, Travelers, State Farm |
| Tesla or EV | Mini Cooper Electric, $1,135 per 6 months | Erie, Travelers, State Farm |
Top 10 cheapest cars to insure in Pennsylvania
These are the 10 cheapest vehicles to insure in Pennsylvania in Study D’s data, for a 40-year-old with full coverage. All 10 cost less than $1,100 for six months, and the list includes SUVs, a minivan, a wagon, a hatchback, and a pickup.

Ten lower-cost vehicle examples from Study D in Pennsylvania, six-month full coverage premiums.
Top 10 cheapest cars to insure in Pennsylvania, Study D
| Rank | Model | 6-month premium | About per month |
| 1 | Honda HR-V | $1,026 | $171 |
| 2 (tie) | Honda CR-V | $1,048 | $175 |
| 2 (tie) | Volkswagen Tiguan | $1,048 | $175 |
| 4 | Ford Ranger | $1,065 | $178 |
| 5 (tie) | Mini Cooper Countryman JCW | $1,073 | $179 |
| 5 (tie) | Subaru Outback | $1,073 | $179 |
| 7 | Subaru Impreza | $1,083 | $181 |
| 8 | Volkswagen Taos | $1,086 | $181 |
| 9 | Honda Odyssey | $1,092 | $182 |
| 10 | Mazda CX-5 | $1,093 | $182 |
For an 18-year-old, the same data shows a Honda HR-V costs $2,898 for six months and a Subaru Outback $2,912, nearly three times the 40-year-old price.
PRO TIP #2
Get insurance quotes before you buy a car in Pennsylvania. A Honda HR-V cost $1,026 for six months in Study D’s data, while a Porsche 911 Turbo cost $2,426, a difference of $2,800 a year.
Best car insurance companies in Pennsylvania for teens
Erie, Travelers, and State Farm are the cheapest companies for Pennsylvania teens. In Study H’s data for a teen added to a family policy, Erie was cheapest for 16- and 17-year-olds, at $315 and $301 a month, and Travelers for 18- to 20-year-olds. Study B found State Farm cheapest for teens overall, at $154 a month for full coverage, with Erie second at $168.

*Military families only. 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study C, November 2025.
For an 18-year-old, Study F found Erie cheapest at $71 a month for minimum coverage and $304 for full coverage.
Cheapest companies for a Pennsylvania 18-year-old, Study F (monthly)
| Company | Minimum coverage | Full coverage |
| Erie | $71 | $304 |
| GEICO | $119 | $388 |
| Travelers | $127 | $367 |
| Progressive | $155 | $435 |
| USAA* | $86 | $392 |
*Military families only. Source: Study F, October 2026.
Keeping a teen on a family policy saves money: Study B found a teen cost about $209 a month on a family policy, compared with $279 on their own, a savings of about $835 a year.
PRO TIP #3
Ask Erie about its teenSMART program, which can save up to 20% for young drivers who complete it, and ask every insurer about good student and driver training discounts before your teen is licensed.
Best car insurance companies in Pennsylvania for seniors
Travelers is the standout choice for Pennsylvania seniors. Study D found it cheapest at 60, 65, 70, and 75, starting at $133 a month for full coverage at 65, while average full coverage rose from $2,119 a year at 65 to $2,477 at 75. Study H found Nationwide cheapest at 65, at $83 a month, with Travelers close behind at $86.

*Military families only. 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D, June 2026.
Pennsylvania’s mature driver discount
Pennsylvania law, 75 Pa.C.S. 1799.2, requires insurers to give a discount of at least 5% to policies where all named insureds are 55 or older and have completed a PennDOT-approved Mature Driver Improvement Course. The discount lasts three years, and a refresher course every three years keeps it. Insurers may require a clean record, and a course ordered by a court does not count.
Car insurance for women in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania generally prohibits using sex as an auto insurance rating factor. Quoted premiums can nevertheless differ for other lawful reasons, including territory, driving record, coverage and credit-based insurance scores where permitted. Compare otherwise identical profiles rather than assuming all men and women receive identical quotes.
Best Pennsylvania car insurance after an accident, ticket, or DUI
A speeding ticket raised the average Pennsylvania rate by about 14%, an at-fault accident by 24%, and a DUI by 61% in Study B’s data. Erie charged the same $150 a month after an accident or a ticket in Study F’s data, and Allstate charged $228 after any of the three, making it the cheapest company after a DUI.
Pennsylvania full coverage after a violation or with poor credit, Study F (monthly)
| Company | At-fault accident | Speeding ticket | DUI | Poor credit |
| Erie | $150 | $150 | $248 | $312 |
| Allstate | $228 | $228 | $228 | $376 |
| Travelers | Not listed | $227 | $271 | Not listed |
| State Farm | $184 | $196 | Not listed | Not listed |
| USAA* | Not listed | $191 | $286 | $171 |
*Military families only. 30-year-old man, 2018 Honda Civic, 50/100/50 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study F, October 2026.
Pennsylvania allows insurers to use credit-based insurance scores. Bills to ban the practice have been introduced but have not passed, and Study E found Chubb cheapest for drivers with poor credit, at $2,482 a year.
Car insurance rates in Pennsylvania cities
Philadelphia is by far the most expensive place to insure a car in Pennsylvania. Study F found full coverage averaged $367 a month there, compared with $211 in Pittsburgh and $173 in Lebanon. Erie was the cheapest company in every city in Study F’s data, though even Erie’s Philadelphia rate, $289, was higher than the average in every other city listed.

30-year-old man, 2018 Honda Civic, 50/100/50 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study F, October 2026.
PRO TIP #4
If you live in Philadelphia, compare Erie, Travelers, and Plymouth Rock. Erie was cheapest in Study F’s data, Travelers in Study H’s, at $126 a month, and Plymouth Rock had the cheapest liability-only price in Study B’s, at $83.
Pennsylvania car insurance requirements for 2027
Pennsylvania requires every driver to carry at least 15/30/5 liability coverage: $15,000 for injuries to one person, $30,000 for all injuries in one crash, and $5,000 for property damage. You must also carry $5,000 of first-party medical benefits, which pay your own medical bills after a crash no matter who caused it. Those limits are among the lowest in the country, and a single modern car can cost far more than $5,000 to repair.
Pennsylvania car insurance requirements at a glance
| Coverage | Requirement |
| Bodily injury liability | $15,000 per person, $30,000 per accident |
| Property damage liability | $5,000 per accident |
| First-party medical benefits | $5,000 |
| Uninsured/underinsured motorist | Must be offered; reject only in writing |
| Stacking of UM/UIM | Stacked by default; waive only on a signed form |
| Tort option | Choose limited or full tort |
| Collision and comprehensive | Optional, but usually required by a lender |
Pennsylvania also lets you buy more first-party benefits than the $5,000 minimum. These optional coverages pay you and your family directly after a crash, regardless of fault.
Optional first-party benefits in Pennsylvania
| Benefit | What it pays |
| Extra medical benefits | Limits above $5,000, up to $1.1 million in extraordinary medical coverage |
| Income loss | 80% of lost income, up to $2,500 a month and $50,000 in total |
| Accidental death | At least $25,000 |
| Funeral benefits | At least $2,500 |
| Combination package | At least $177,500 across these benefits |
Limited tort vs. full tort
Pennsylvania is a “choice no-fault” state, and every driver chooses a tort option. Full tort keeps your right to sue an at-fault driver for pain and suffering. Limited tort costs less, but you can recover pain and suffering only for a serious injury or in a few exceptions, such as when the at-fault driver was drunk, uninsured, or registered out of state.
We found no rate study that measures the savings in Pennsylvania. One Pennsylvania law firm estimates limited tort costs about 15% less, so compare both options on your quote and weigh the savings against the rights you give up.
Uninsured motorist coverage and stacking
Insurers must offer uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, and you can reject it only in writing. Pennsylvania’s uninsured rate is lower than most states, 11.0% in 2023, ranked 36th, but that still means about one driver in nine has no coverage. If you have more than one car, UM/UIM is stacked by default, which multiplies your limit by the number of vehicles; you can waive stacking on a signed form to lower your premium.

Pennsylvania ranked 36th. Source: Insurance Research Council, via the Insurance Information Institute.
Penalties for driving uninsured in Pennsylvania
| Situation | Penalty |
| Driving without insurance | Fine of at least $300 |
| Registration | Suspended for three months |
| Driver’s license | Suspended for three months; $94 restoration fee |
| Alternative to registration suspension | $500 civil penalty, once in 12 months |
| Lapse under 31 days | No suspension if you prove the vehicle was not driven |
Source: PennDOT.
Deer collisions and comprehensive coverage
Pennsylvania drivers file more animal-collision claims than drivers in any other state, about 141,000 between July 2025 and June 2026, according to State Farm. State Farm estimated approximately one animal-collision claim per 64 insured Pennsylvania vehicles during its reporting year, more than twice the national odds of 1 in 145. Damage from hitting a deer is paid by comprehensive coverage, not collision, so dropping comprehensive to save money is riskier in Pennsylvania than almost anywhere else.

Lower means higher risk. Pennsylvania ranked fourth-highest for odds and first for the number of claims. Source: State Farm, July 2025 to June 2026 claims data, September 2026.
Car insurance discounts in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania law requires a discount of at least 5% for drivers 55 and older who complete a mature driver course. Other discounts vary by company, and Pennsylvania insurers offer several telematics programs that track how you drive.
Pennsylvania car insurance discounts by company
| Company | Notable discounts | Telematics or special program |
| Erie | Rate Lock, teenSMART up to 20%, multi-policy 15% to 25% | YourTurn safe-driving rewards app |
| State Farm | Mature driver 5%, Steer Clear, good student, anti-theft, passive restraint | Drive Safe & Save, up to 30% |
| Progressive | Multi-car and bundling | Snapshot, average $322 a year at renewal; rates can rise |
| Allstate | Varies; ask for the current list | Drivewise, 10% to enroll, up to 40% at renewal |
| USAA | Military families only | SafePilot, up to 30% |
Sources: company websites and published reviews. Discount amounts vary by driver.

Maximum advertised savings; most drivers save less. Sources: company websites and 75 Pa.C.S. 1799.2.
How to save money on car insurance in Pennsylvania
- Compare at least three quotes, including Erie, Travelers, and State Farm.
- Keep the same limits, deductibles, and tort option on every quote.
- Price both limited and full tort, and decide whether the savings are worth the rights you give up.
- Waive UM/UIM stacking only if you understand the lower limit you will have.
- Take a PennDOT-approved mature driver course if you are 55 or older.
- Add a teen to your policy instead of buying a separate one.
- Ask Erie about Rate Lock if you want a stable price.
- Shop again at renewal, because rates moved in both directions in 2026.
Pennsylvania car insurance outlook for 2027
Pennsylvania rates have stabilized after the big increases of 2022 to 2024. PID reported that approved auto rate filings averaged a 0.2% decrease in 2025 and a 0.5% decrease in early 2026, and it blocked $91 million in proposed personal auto increases in 2025. Company filings were mixed in 2026: Farmers cut rates 4.7%, Progressive 2.8%, and State Farm 2.6%, while GEICO raised them 2.5% and Liberty Mutual 3.1%.
Insurance Commissioner Michael Humphreys called the trend a “stabilization of the personal auto insurance market in Pennsylvania,” and Study B projected Pennsylvania full coverage would end 2026 only about 0.4% higher than a year earlier. The article does not establish verified 2027 quotes, so compare quotes at renewal rather than letting your policy renew automatically.

Bars show the size of each change: Farmers -4.7%, AAA -3.1%, Progressive -2.8%, State Farm -2.6%, Erie +0.4%, Allstate +1.7%, GEICO +2.5%, Liberty Mutual +3.1%. Source: Study F, from state rate filings, October 2026.
What to watch in 2027
| Issue | Status as of November 2026 | What it could mean |
| Rate filings | Approved changes averaged -0.5% in early 2026 | Not enough evidence to forecast individual renewals |
| Credit scoring | Bills to ban credit-based pricing have not passed | Credit will likely still affect 2027 rates |
| Deer collisions | About 141,000 animal-collision claims in a year | May contribute to comprehensive loss costs; impact not quantified here |
| Repair costs and tariffs | Higher parts prices nationally | Could raise collision and comprehensive costs |
| National forecasts | A major broker’s 2027 outlook ranges from -2% to +10% for personal auto | Insurers could respond differently; this is not a Pennsylvania forecast |
Buying direct or through an agent in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania drivers can buy online or by phone from direct insurers such as GEICO and Progressive, from captive agents who sell one company, such as State Farm and Allstate, or from independent agents who compare several companies at once. Many of Pennsylvania’s best-rated insurers, including Erie, Westfield, Donegal, and Penn National, sell through independent agents, so many online quote tools leave them out. Getting at least one quote from a local independent agent is the easiest way to include them.
If no company will insure you
Drivers who cannot find coverage in the regular market can apply to the Pennsylvania Automobile Insurance Plan, the state’s assigned risk plan, through a licensed agent. It is usually more expensive, so first try companies that insure higher-risk drivers, such as National General, The General, and Root.
How to choose the best Pennsylvania car insurance company
- Decide on your liability limits, tort option, UM/UIM limits, and whether you need collision and comprehensive.
- Get quotes from at least three companies, including Erie, Travelers, and State Farm.
- Add an agent-sold regional insurer, such as Westfield, Donegal, or Penn National.
- Compare identical limits, deductibles, and tort options on every quote.
- Check each company’s J.D. Power score and AM Best rating, not just its price.
- Ask about the mature driver discount and any teen programs.
Common mistakes Pennsylvania drivers make
- Choosing limited tort to save money without understanding that it limits pain and suffering claims.
- Carrying only $5,000 of property damage coverage, which may not cover even a minor crash with a newer car.
- Dropping comprehensive coverage in a state with some of the highest deer-collision odds in the country.
- Signing a stacking waiver without realizing it lowers your UM/UIM limit.
- Trusting outdated ratings, such as A+ for Erie or A++ for State Farm.
Pro tips for Pennsylvania drivers
PRO TIP #5
Raise your property damage limit well above $5,000. The cost to move from 15/30/5 to 50/100/50 ranged from $83 to $308 a year in Study C, and it protects you from paying for another driver’s car yourself.
PRO TIP #6
If you value a predictable bill, ask Erie about Rate Lock. Your premium stays the same from year to year unless you add or remove a driver or vehicle or change your address, which can be valuable when rates are rising.

The best Pennsylvania car insurance companies, explained in pictures.
(FAQs) Frequently asked questions about the best Pennsylvania car insurance companies
What is the best car insurance company in Pennsylvania?
Erie is our overall winner for the top J.D. Power score in the Mid-Atlantic region and low prices in most studies. Travelers and State Farm are close behind.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Pennsylvania?
Travelers was cheapest in four of the eight studies we reviewed. Erie, State Farm, Encova, and National General were each cheapest in one.
What car insurance is required in Pennsylvania?
Liability of 15/30/5 plus $5,000 of first-party medical benefits. Uninsured motorist coverage must be offered but can be rejected in writing.
Is limited tort worth it in Pennsylvania?
It lowers your premium, by about 15% by one estimate, but limits your right to sue for pain and suffering. Price both options before you decide.
Does gender affect car insurance in Pennsylvania?
No. Pennsylvania bans gender as a rating factor, so men and women with the same profile pay the same.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Pennsylvania for seniors?
Travelers, cheapest at 60 to 75 in Study D. Nationwide was cheapest at 65 in Study H.
Is Erie still rated A+?
No. AM Best downgraded Erie to A (Excellent) in September 2025, though many websites still show A+.
What is the cheapest car to insure in Pennsylvania?
The Honda HR-V, at $1,026 for six months of full coverage in Study D, followed by the Honda CR-V and Volkswagen Tiguan.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Pennsylvania for teens?
Erie was cheapest for 16- and 17-year-olds in Study H, Travelers at 18, and State Farm for teens overall in Study B.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Philadelphia?
Erie, at $289 a month for full coverage in Study F, compared with a Philadelphia average of $367.
What happens if I drive uninsured in Pennsylvania?
You face a fine of at least $300 and three-month suspensions of your registration and license.
The final word on the best Pennsylvania car insurance companies
The best Pennsylvania car insurance companies for 2027 pair low prices with good service, and Erie does that best for most drivers. Travelers is the price leader and the top pick for seniors, State Farm is cheapest in some studies, and Westfield leads on minimum coverage.
Compare at least three quotes, choose your tort option carefully, keep comprehensive coverage for deer season, and shop again at renewal.
Sources
- Study A: The Zebra, Pennsylvania car insurance and The Zebra, gender differences by state.
- Study B: Insurify, Pennsylvania car insurance (November 1, 2026); Insurify, Pennsylvania teens (November 1, 2026); and Insurify, Pennsylvania average cost (November 1, 2026).
- Study C: Insurance.com, Pennsylvania car insurance (November 27, 2025); Insurance.com, Tesla Model 3 (April 10, 2026); Insurance.com, Tesla Model Y (April 8, 2026); and Insurance.com, J.D. Power ratings (June 23, 2026).
- Study D: CarInsurance.com, cheapest car insurance in Pennsylvania (July 9, 2026); CarInsurance.com, best car insurance in Pennsylvania (March 25, 2026); CarInsurance.com, cheapest cars to insure in Pennsylvania; CarInsurance.com, Pennsylvania seniors (June 4, 2026); CarInsurance.com, NAIC complaint data (August 13, 2026); and model pages for the Toyota Sienna, Ford F-150, Chevrolet Silverado 1500, Ram 1500, and Toyota Tacoma.
- Study E: NerdWallet, best car insurance in Pennsylvania (October 1, 2026) and NerdWallet, cheap car insurance in Pennsylvania (October 2, 2026).
- Study F: ValuePenguin, cheap car insurance in Pennsylvania (October 13, 2026).
- Study G: Experian, cheapest car insurance in Pennsylvania (October 13, 2026).
- Study H: MoneyGeek, best car insurance in Pennsylvania (August 25, 2026); MoneyGeek, most affordable car insurance in Pennsylvania (August 25, 2026); and model pages for the Honda Odyssey, Ford F-150, Ram 1500, and Toyota Tacoma.
- Pennsylvania government and law: Pennsylvania Insurance Department, rate stabilization (April 22, 2026); Insurance Journal, PID blocked increases (January 22, 2026); PID, consumer help; PennDOT, insurance law FAQs; PennDOT, penalties; PennDOT, mature driver course; 75 Pa.C.S. 1799.2; 75 Pa.C.S. 1738; and PennDOT, driver and vehicle statistics.
- Ratings, companies, and news: AM Best, Erie (September 5, 2025); AM Best, State Farm (November 14, 2025); AM Best, GEICO (April 16, 2026); AM Best, Progressive (May 1, 2026); AM Best, Allstate (September 2026); AM Best, USAA (June 25, 2026); AM Best, Travelers (August 8, 2025); AM Best, Nationwide (November 7, 2025); AM Best, Westfield (March 4, 2025); AM Best, Donegal (May 13, 2025); Penn National, financial stability; The Insurer, Auto-Owners (November 1, 2024); Bernews, AM Best affirms Chubb (January 2026); NJM, J.D. Power 2025; NAIC market share data via Stacker (February 20, 2024); State Farm, animal collision data (September 15, 2026); State Farm, Pennsylvania discounts; Erie review with Rate Lock and teenSMART details (October 1, 2026); USAA, SafePilot; Munley Law, full tort vs. limited tort; Consumer Federation of America, HB 657 letter (March 25, 2026); U.S. Department of Energy, Pennsylvania vehicle registrations; WTW, 2027 personal lines outlook (October 2026); and Insurance Information Institute, uninsured motorists.
Disclaimer
This article is an independent review provided for informational purposes only. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or paid by any insurer named here, including Erie, Travelers, State Farm, Nationwide, USAA, Westfield, Donegal, GEICO, Auto-Owners, Allstate, Plymouth Rock, Progressive, Encova, Penn National, Safeco, Liberty Mutual, Chubb, CSAA, National General, Root, The General, or NJM, or by J.D. Power, AM Best, PennDOT, or the Pennsylvania Insurance Department. All trademarks belong to their owners.
This article is not insurance, legal, or financial advice, and it is not an offer to sell insurance. We are not an insurance company or licensed agent.
Our ranking reflects our own editorial judgment based on public data. Complaint indexes are national NAIC figures, not Pennsylvania-specific. Prices are averages from third-party studies using sample driver profiles and are not quotes, the studies use different methods, and no 2027 rates had been published when we updated this article. Rates, laws, ratings, and complaint data change often. Always confirm details with the insurer, PID, and PennDOT, read your policy, and consult a licensed professional before you decide.