Best Car Insurance Companies in Phoenix: Rates, ZIP Codes & Coverage

Phoenix often posts higher average car insurance prices than nearby Arizona cities in the rate studies reviewed here. Travelers had the lowest full-coverage price in five of the eight studies considered, but only three of those findings were Phoenix-specific; two came from statewide data. State Farm, Auto-Owners, and Root each led a different Phoenix sample. Because the studies use different drivers, vehicles, coverage limits, and dates, no single company can be called the cheapest for every Phoenix resident. To prepare for an insurer application, check the information needed for an online auto insurance quote, including driver records and vehicle details.

Arizona’s statewide uninsured-driver estimate in the cited 2023 research was below the national average, but it does not establish a Phoenix-specific rate. State law also limits surcharges for crashes a driver did not cause or significantly contribute to. Phoenix drivers face monsoon hail, dust storms, vehicle theft, and the city’s photo-speed enforcement program. Arizona voters approved Proposition 319 in November 2026, affecting the future of photo enforcement programs beginning in 2027.

How to read these rates: Figures below come from different companies, drivers, coverage definitions, ZIP codes, and years. Statewide figures are flagged, and rate-study averages are not personalized Phoenix quotes. The editorial top 10 is not a weighted statistical ranking.

Phoenix car insurance by the numbers.

Phoenix car insurance by the numbers.

Source note: Figures drawn inside this image are historical sample estimates. The source studies are not uniform and do not predict your 2027 premium.

What Phoenix drivers pay, and what drives it

The eight rate studies cited below use different driver profiles, cars, dates, and levels of coverage. Published Phoenix full-coverage averages span a wide range, roughly $2,170 to more than $3,800 a year in the selected samples. That range is not a forecast or a reliable personal quote; the right comparison uses the same garaging ZIP code, drivers, coverage limits, deductibles, and policy term.

Monthly and six-month figures converted to yearly. Study A averages all coverage levels; the others are full coverage. Study E reports medians with ,00$500 deductibles. Study C published Arizona figures only. Sources: Studies A, B, and D through H.

Monthly and six-month figures converted to yearly. Study A averages all coverage levels; the others are full coverage. Study E reports medians with $1,000 deductibles. Study C published Arizona figures only. Sources: Studies A, B, and D through H.

Studies A, F, and H all named Phoenix the most expensive city in Arizona. Study D found Phoenix full coverage averaged $2,986 a year, against $2,420 statewide, and Study F’s statewide table put Phoenix at $284 a month, the highest of the Valley cities it listed.

The rest of Arizona is a different story. Study G put the statewide average at $1,927 a year, about 15% below the national figure, and Study B called Arizona 11% cheaper than the U.S. average. Phoenix pays more because of what happens inside the city, not because Arizona is an expensive state.

Theft, storms, and dangerous streets

Phoenix had 4,700 stolen vehicles in 2025, the most of any Arizona city and more than twice Tucson’s 2,060, according to the Arizona Automobile Theft Authority. Statewide thefts fell 24% in the first half of 2026, but thefts in the ZIP code around Sky Harbor Airport, 85034, rose 65%.

Weather adds a different set of claims. On August 25, 2025, a haboob pushed gusts to 70 mph at Sky Harbor and knocked out power to more than 60,000 customers. A month later, hail and flooding hit Maricopa and Pinal counties, and on October 21, 2026, a hailstorm shattered windshields across north Phoenix, Glendale, Tempe, and Mesa. The Valley’s October 2010 hailstorms caused an estimated $2.7 billion in insured losses.

The roads themselves are risky. Arizona’s traffic death rate was about 16.2 per 100,000 residents in 2025, against 11.5 nationally, and pedestrians were involved in 41% of fatal crashes in Phoenix, according to the city’s road safety report.

Increase over a clean-record average of ,601 per six months. Source: Study A.

Increase over a clean-record average of $1,601 per six months. Source: Study A.

A claim that 27% of Phoenix drivers are uninsured could not be independently validated against a comparable city-level dataset and has been omitted. The Insurance Research Council’s cited estimate places the share of uninsured Arizona drivers at 10.6% in 2023, below the 15.4% national estimate for that year. Those are statewide estimates, not a measurement of uninsured drivers within Phoenix city limits.

Our 10 best and cheapest car insurance companies in Phoenix

This is an editorial shortlist, not a statistical ranking computed from a reproducible weighted score. We considered the prices reported by different Phoenix and Arizona rate studies, the 2026 J.D. Power Southwest satisfaction findings, national complaint data, and AM Best financial strength ratings. Price examples are not interchangeable between studies, and availability, insurance company legal entity, and individual underwriting can change the result.

Vector illustration of 10 numbered cars labeled with the best and cheapest car insurance companies in Phoenix: 1 Travelers, 108 dollars a month for full coverage; 2 State Farm, 172 dollars a month; 3 Auto-Owners, 116 dollars a month; 4 GEICO, 604 dollars a year for minimum coverage; 5 Progressive, 249 dollars a month after a DUI; 6 Root, 702 dollars for six months; 7 USAA, 162 dollars a month for military families; 8 AAA, J.D. Power score 653, first in the Southwest; 9 American Family, 4.5 percent rate cut in 2026; 10 Mercury, 153 dollars a month statewide.

Our picks for the best and cheapest car insurance companies in Phoenix, with the figure behind each one.

Editorial image warning: This infographic shows a fixed rank order and figures from different sample profiles. They should not be read as comparable quotes or a reproducible ranking for Phoenix.

Best and cheapest Phoenix car insurers compared

Rank Company Why it made the list J.D. Power 2026 Southwest AM Best
1 Travelers Cheapest full coverage in D, E, and H 630 A++
2 State Farm Cheapest in F; second in J.D. Power 649 A+
3 Auto-Owners Cheapest in every B profile 616 A+ (2024 action)
4 GEICO Cheapest minimum coverage in D 637 A++
5 Progressive Cheapest after a DUI in F 615 A+
6 Root Cheapest full coverage in A Not ranked Not rated
7 USAA Military families 707* A++
8 AAA (CSAA) First in J.D. Power 653 A
9 American Family 4.5% Arizona rate cut in 2026 632 A
10 Mercury Second-cheapest statewide in G Not ranked A

*USAA is not eligible for official J.D. Power rankings. The Southwest average was 638. Source: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, as reported by Study C.

1. Travelers

Travelers had the lowest full coverage price in three Phoenix studies, $108 a month in Study H, $2,068 a year in Study D, and $2,032 in Study E, and it also led statewide in Studies C and G. A Travelers insurance review (in Spanish) describes its coverage options; use your own quote to verify Phoenix pricing.

It was the cheapest company after a ticket, a DUI, or an accident in Study D, after a DUI or accident in Study E, and for drivers with poor credit in Study F, at $301 a month. Study H found it cheapest for both drivers 16 to 25 and seniors.

The catch: its J.D. Power score of 630 sat below the Southwest average, so price, not service, is its main strength.

2. State Farm

State Farm was the cheapest non-military company in Study F, at $172 a month for full coverage and $79 for minimum coverage, and it was cheapest there after a speeding ticket or an at-fault accident. It also finished second in J.D. Power’s Southwest study, at 649. The weak spot is credit: with poor credit, its Study F price jumped to $964 a month, the highest of any company.

3. Auto-Owners

Auto-Owners posted the lowest reported prices in the Phoenix profiles tracked by Study B: $116 a month for full coverage, $67 for liability, $95 after a DUI, and $52 for seniors. These are study-specific averages rather than personalized offers. AM Best downgraded the Auto-Owners Insurance Group financial strength rating from A++ to A+ (Superior) on October 31, 2024; A+ is the documented rating, not an unknown grade.

4. GEICO

GEICO had the cheapest minimum coverage in Study D, at $604 a year, and statewide in Study C, at $435. It was also the cheapest company for teens in both studies, at about $6,100 a year for a teen driver’s full coverage. GEICO holds an A++ rating from AM Best. The Spanish-language review of GEICO auto insurance coverage and discounts describes the policy features separately from these sample prices.

5. Progressive

Progressive was the cheapest company after a DUI in Study F, at $249 a month, and Study F’s statewide table named it the cheapest company in Phoenix and most Valley suburbs. It cut Arizona rates 4.7% in 2026, tied for the largest cut Study F tracked.

6 to 10. Root, USAA, AAA, American Family, and Mercury

Root had the lowest full coverage price in Study A, at $702 per six months, and the cheapest statewide minimum coverage in Study G, but it is not rated by AM Best. USAA had the lowest full coverage price in Studies D, E, and F, but only military families can join. AAA’s CSAA won J.D. Power’s Southwest study for the third year in a row, at 653, though its prices in Study A were among the highest. For a description of its pricing approach, the Root usage-based insurance model is discussed in Spanish.

American Family cut Arizona rates 4.5% in 2026 and finished fifth for full coverage in Study F, at $219 a month. Mercury was the second-cheapest company statewide in Study G, at $153 a month for full coverage.

ALSO WORTH A QUOTE

Farm Bureau Financial Services was the fourth-cheapest in Study E, at $2,818 a year. Usage-based options such as Just Pay-Per-Mile and Mile Auto also ranked near the top of Study B’s Phoenix quotes, which can help low-mileage drivers. In a pay-per-mile insurance pricing model, the base charge and the rate for each mile matter; the total may not favor someone who drives frequently.

Eight studies, one clear front-runner

Travelers led more studies than any other company, but three others had the lowest full coverage price in at least one. The table leaves out USAA, which won several studies but sells only to military families.

Cheapest car insurance company in Phoenix by study, excluding USAA

Study Full coverage leader Price Minimum coverage leader Price
Study A Root $702 per 6 months Travelers $333 per 6 months
Study B Auto-Owners $116 a month Auto-Owners $67 a month
Study C (Arizona) Travelers $1,707 a year GEICO $435 a year
Study D Travelers $2,068 a year GEICO $604 a year
Study E Travelers $2,032 a year Not reported Not reported
Study F State Farm $172 a month State Farm $79 a month
Study G (Arizona) Travelers $148 a month Root $104 a month
Study H Travelers $108 a month Travelers $57 a month

Studies C and G report statewide prices. Study B’s minimum column is liability-only quotes, and Study E reports medians. Sources: Studies A through H. The practical way to compare car insurance quotes with matching limits and deductibles is to hold your driver, vehicle, ZIP code, and term constant across carriers.

Study F published two sets of Phoenix numbers. Its Phoenix page, built on a 2015 Honda Civic, named State Farm cheapest at $172 a month, while its statewide page, using a 2018 Civic, named Progressive cheapest in Phoenix at $215. The lesson is the same either way: quote several companies with your own car.

The top five, side by side

Study H compared the five cheapest Phoenix insurers for both coverage levels. Travelers charged 42% less than the city’s $181 average for full coverage. For households targeting a budget, a full-coverage policy under $150 per month is a search goal rather than a guaranteed Phoenix price; always inspect the liability limits and deductibles.

Phoenix full coverage average: 1 a month. Source: Study H, May 2026.

Phoenix full coverage average: $181 a month. Source: Study H, May 2026.

Study D’s larger gaps show what is at stake. Its 40-year-old driver paid $2,068 a year at Travelers and $2,454 at GEICO, but $3,545 at Allstate, $3,924 at Farmers, and $4,017 at Progressive, nearly twice the cheapest price for the same 100/300/100 policy.

Study A’s Phoenix table shows how wide the field is. Root charged $702 for six months of full coverage, Travelers $821, and GEICO $997, while State Farm charged $1,312 and CSAA $2,608, more than three and a half times Root’s price.

Statewide, the order holds

Study C’s Arizona data, for a 40-year-old with 100/300/100 coverage, shows the same leader. Travelers was cheapest with a clean record and after an accident, while USAA edged it after a ticket.

Statewide averages, November 2025. USAA: ,880, ,894, and ,431. Source: Study C.

Statewide averages, November 2025. USAA: $1,880, $2,894, and $2,431. Source: Study C.

State Farm stood out for a small jump after a ticket in Study C: its price rose only about 6%, to $3,066, while Auto-Owners’ rose 78%. Study E’s statewide figures also put Travelers first for 20-year-olds, 70-year-olds, and drivers with a ticket, accident, DUI, or poor credit, and its Mesa driver paid $1,759 a year at Travelers, about $270 less than in Phoenix.

PRO TIP #1

Get a Travelers quote first, then ask State Farm and Auto-Owners to beat it. Between them, those three had the lowest full coverage price in seven of the eight studies.

Ahwatukee to Maryvale: the ZIP code effect

Where your car is parked overnight can move the price by more than $80 a month. In Study H, full coverage ranged from $143 a month in 85331, near Cave Creek, to $226 in 85037, in Maryvale, for the same driver.

Phoenix-area full coverage by ZIP code, Study H (monthly)

ZIP code Area Full coverage
85331 Cave Creek $143
85048 Ahwatukee Foothills $144
85045 Ahwatukee Foothills $145
85044 Ahwatukee Foothills $150
85054 Desert Ridge $154
85024 North Phoenix $162
85009 West Phoenix $202
85031 Maryvale $209
85040 South Phoenix $219
85012 Midtown $221
85037 Maryvale $226

Selected rows. Source: Study H, May 2026.

Study F’s ZIP table, built on a different driver, agreed on the cheap end: Ahwatukee’s 85044 and 85048 were lowest at $217 a month. Its priciest ZIP codes were in the west-central city, led by 85017, in Grandview, at $290, and 85031 and 85019, in Maryvale, at $289 and $286. Study E’s medians ran from $3,576 a year in 85032, in Paradise Valley Village, to $4,346 in 85035, in Maryvale.

The studies did not agree on every ZIP code. Study H listed 85012 and 85022 among the most expensive, while Study F put 85022 slightly below the city average and Study E ranked it second-cheapest. That is a reminder that ZIP code rankings depend heavily on each study’s sample driver. Spanish-speaking shoppers can compare the inputs needed to cotizar seguro de auto al instante, including their actual garaging address.

Phoenix versus the suburbs

Most Valley suburbs cost less than Phoenix. In Study B’s statewide quotes, full coverage ran $162 a month in Chandler and Scottsdale and $163 in Mesa, against $219 in Phoenix. Glendale and Avondale were the only suburbs within $30 of the Phoenix price.

Average marketplace quotes. Source: Study B Arizona page, November 2026.

Average marketplace quotes. Source: Study B Arizona page, November 2026.

Study F’s statewide table found Progressive the cheapest company in Phoenix and every suburb it listed except Avondale, where Travelers won, with Chandler lowest at $171 a month. Study G’s marketplace data ranked Mesa the cheapest of eight Valley cities, at $176 a month, followed by Chandler at $179, Peoria at $183, and Scottsdale at $185, against $210 in Phoenix. Glendale, Gilbert, and Tempe all landed between $199 and $202.

PRO TIP #2

Moving across the Valley? Get new quotes before you sign a lease. In Study B, the same full coverage cost $57 a month less in Chandler or Scottsdale than in Phoenix.

Arizona’s insurance rules in plain English

Arizona is a fault-based state with no personal injury protection requirement. The driver who causes a crash pays for it through liability insurance, and every Phoenix policy must meet the state minimum, which rose from 15/30/10 to 25/50/15 on July 1, 2020.

Arizona car insurance requirements

Coverage Minimum Notes
Bodily injury liability $25,000 per person, $50,000 per accident Required
Property damage liability $15,000 per accident Required
Uninsured and underinsured motorist From $25,000/$50,000 up to your liability limits Must be offered in writing; optional to buy
Personal injury protection None Not required in Arizona

Sources: Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions; A.R.S. 28-4009 and 20-259.01; DIFI Bulletin 2020-011.

Arizona uses pure comparative negligence under A.R.S. 12-2505, so an injured driver can recover damages even when partly at fault, reduced by his or her share of the blame. And under A.R.S. 20-263, an insurer may not raise your premium because of an accident you did not cause or significantly contribute to.

Read your policy for a household exclusion. Arizona lets insurers limit bodily injury coverage for members of your own family to the state minimum, so a spouse or child hurt in a crash you cause may have only $25,000 of coverage under your liability policy.

The state also publishes how widely prices can vary. In its 2023 premium comparison, the Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions found six-month minimum coverage quotes for a 21-year-old in Phoenix’s 85053 ZIP code ranging from $645 to $6,419, depending on the company.

Caught without insurance

Arizona treats a lapse seriously. A first violation carries a civil penalty of at least $500 and a three-month license suspension; a second within 36 months carries at least $750 and a six-month suspension of the license, registration, and plates; and a third carries at least $1,000, a one-year suspension, and an SR-22 filing to reinstate. With court surcharges, Goodyear City Court lists total fines of $972 to $1,883. A citation is dismissed if you show the court you were insured at the time.

Insurers report policies electronically to the Motor Vehicle Division, and they must report a cancellation within seven days. If your insurer reports late, you can send your own coverage details to MVD for free through ServiceArizona to head off a wrongful suspension.

How prices are set

Arizona is a use-and-file state for personal auto insurance. Under A.R.S. 20-385, insurers can put new rates into effect and file them with the state within 30 days, and the Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions can later order a noncompliant rate stopped.

Credit-based insurance scores are allowed, with limits. Under A.R.S. 20-2110, a score cannot use medical collection accounts, bankruptcies or liens more than seven years old, income, gender, address, ZIP code, ethnic group, religion, marital status, or nationality, and an insurer must tell you the main reasons when credit leads to a higher price.

PRO TIP #3

Can’t find coverage? The Arizona Automobile Insurance Plan assigns drivers who cannot get insurance in the regular market to a participating company. Call (800) 227-4659.

Your record: points, cameras, and price jumps

Arizona’s Motor Vehicle Division assigns points for moving violations, and insurers price the same violations separately. Study D measured what one incident did to a Phoenix driver’s premium at six companies, and Travelers was the cheapest non-military company in every column.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. USAA: ,640, ,170, and ,018. Source: Study D, July 2026.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. USAA: $2,640, $3,170, and $4,018. Source: Study D, July 2026.

The size of the jump varies as much as the price. GEICO’s rate rose 86% after a ticket and 110% after a DUI in Study D, while Progressive’s rose only 23% and 16%. In Study F, State Farm was cheapest after a ticket or accident, and Progressive after a DUI.

Arizona MVD points for common violations

Violation Points
DUI, extreme DUI, reckless or aggressive driving 8
Leaving the scene of an accident 6
Speeding 3
Most other moving violations 2

Eight or more points in 12 months can lead to Traffic Survival School or a suspension of up to 12 months. Source: Arizona Department of Transportation.

For certain eligible civil traffic citations, completing an approved defensive-driving course can result in dismissal so that the violation does not generate points. Phoenix Municipal Court lists eligibility conditions, including limits on how frequently drivers may use the program. It is not a way to erase every citation or DUI. Arizona’s hands-free law, A.R.S. §28-914, also restricts holding a phone while driving; penalties depend on the specific offense and effective law.

A first DUI brings at least 10 consecutive days in jail, a fine of at least $1,250, and an ignition interlock device; an extreme DUI, with a blood alcohol level of 0.15 or higher, means at least 30 days and $2,500.

Another 2026 law matters to motorcyclists. Under HB 2941, effective September 12, 2026, illegal lane splitting can be charged as reckless driving, which carries 8 MVD points, though lane filtering at stops remains legal.

Phoenix’s new speed cameras

Phoenix began issuing speed-camera citations on March 25, 2026, after a warning period. The city operates 17 photo-safety cameras, including rotating corridor sites and school-zone locations; a local report counted 65,371 citations through July 30, 2026. Arizona voters then approved Proposition 319 on November 3, 2026. The measure restricts new photo-enforcement programs from 2027 and subjects qualifying existing local programs to later voter approval; it did not immediately deactivate Phoenix’s cameras. Always check the city’s current program page for operating details.

The consequences of a photo-enforcement citation depend on the cited offense, whether there is a conviction, eligibility for defensive driving, and the applicable court rules. Scottsdale Police describes two points for a red-light-camera conviction and three for a speed-camera conviction; this is not proof that every Phoenix photo citation automatically receives points. SB 1624, a proposed restriction on insurance use of photo tickets, was vetoed in 2026. Proposition 319 addresses the continuation and establishment of camera programs; it should not be confused with a blanket rule cancelling citations already issued.

Credit, teens, and seniors

Poor credit cost Phoenix drivers more than any single violation in Study F, raising the average full coverage premium to $502 a month. The gap between companies was enormous.

USAA, for military families: 4. Source: Study F, October 2026.

USAA, for military families: $324. Source: Study F, October 2026.

For an 18-year-old, the price spread is wider still.

USAA, for military families: 2. Source: Study F, October 2026.

USAA, for military families: $412. Source: Study F, October 2026.

Study F found full coverage from $527 a month at Travelers to $1,748 at Farmers, and Study H named Travelers cheapest for drivers 16 to 25, at $248 a month. Arizona’s graduated license rules help: teens can get a permit at 15½, must hold it six months, and for the first six months of licensing cannot drive from midnight to 5 a.m. or carry more than one passenger under 18 who is not a sibling, unless a parent is in the car.

Seniors pay less. Study H found Travelers cheapest for drivers 65 and older, at $153 a month for full coverage, and Study B found Auto-Owners at $52 a month for a senior’s liability coverage. Study E’s 60-year-old paid the least at USAA, $1,623 a year, and Travelers, $1,676, against $3,291 at COUNTRY Financial.

Service and strength behind the price

J.D. Power has placed Arizona in its Southwest region, alongside neighboring states. In 2026, AAA’s CSAA won the region for the third year in a row, and State Farm finished second. Travelers, the price leader, and Progressive both scored below the regional average.

USAA scored 707 but is not eligible for official rankings. Source: J.D. Power, June 2026, as reported by Study C.

USAA scored 707 but is not eligible for official rankings. Source: J.D. Power, June 2026, as reported by Study C.

Complaint records point in a slightly different direction. Study C’s national complaint indexes, where 1.00 is the expected number for a company’s size, put Travelers at 0.52 and Auto-Owners at 0.54, the best among major insurers, with State Farm at 0.79, Allstate at 1.1, and USAA at 1.18. The Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions closed 4,077 complaint cases in fiscal 2025, about 60% of them involving auto and home policies, and takes complaints at (602) 364-2499.

AM Best ratings for leading Phoenix insurers

Rating Companies Latest action found
A++ (Superior) Travelers, GEICO, USAA Affirmed 2025 and 2026
A+ (Superior) State Farm, Progressive, Allstate, COUNTRY Financial State Farm lowered from A++ in November 2025
A (Excellent) CSAA, American Family, Farmers, Nationwide, Liberty Mutual, Mercury CSAA outlook raised to stable in July 2025
A- (Excellent) Kemper Affirmed August 2025
Not rated by AM Best Root, Clearcover Clearcover is rated by Demotech

Auto-Owners was downgraded by AM Best in October 2024; its current grade could not be confirmed. Sources: AM Best announcements via Business Wire, InsuranceNewsNet, and company releases.

Latest group-level figures found. Source: NAIC data via Stacker, 2024.

Latest group-level figures found. Source: NAIC data via Stacker, 2024.

Vehicles: Arizona prices run below average

Unlike in California or Texas, popular models cost a little less to insure in Arizona than the national average in Study D’s data. The cheapest cars to insure statewide are mostly compact SUVs, led by the Honda CR-V at $944 for six months.

Vector illustration of the 10 cheapest cars to insure in Arizona, six-month full coverage premiums: 1 Honda CR-V 944 dollars; 2 Hyundai Venue 962 dollars; 3 Subaru Outback 965 dollars; 4 Subaru Forester 970 dollars; 5 Chevrolet TrailBlazer 980 dollars; 6 Mini Cooper Electric 981 dollars; 7 Honda HR-V 985 dollars; 8 Mazda CX-5 986 dollars; 9 Honda Pilot 989 dollars; 10 Subaru Crosstrek 994 dollars.

The 10 cheapest cars to insure in Arizona, per six months, from Study D.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D model pages.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D model pages.

The Toyota Camry, Tacoma, and RAV4 were Phoenix’s top-selling new vehicles in an October 2026 dealer snapshot, followed by the Chevrolet Silverado 1500. The Silverado was also Arizona’s most stolen vehicle in 2025, with 627 thefts, followed by the Hyundai Elantra, Hyundai Sonata, and Kia Soul, so pickup and older Hyundai and Kia owners should think twice before dropping comprehensive coverage.

Most stolen vehicles in Arizona, 2025

Rank Vehicle Thefts
1 Chevrolet Silverado 627
2 Hyundai Elantra 418
3 Hyundai Sonata 323
4 Kia Soul 309
5 GMC Savana 278

Source: Arizona Automobile Theft Authority via Claims Journal, February 2026.

Robotaxis are part of Phoenix traffic, too. Waymo’s service area reached about 350 square miles across Phoenix, Scottsdale, Tempe, and the East Valley in August 2026. Tesla Insurance is available in Arizona for Tesla owners who want another quote.

Fewer deaths, but pedestrians remain at risk

Arizona recorded 1,156 traffic deaths in 2025, down 5.2% and the third straight annual decline, according to the Arizona Department of Transportation. In 2024, Maricopa County had 594 deaths and the city of Phoenix 278, down from 307 the year before. Pedestrians remain the biggest concern: the AAA Foundation found Arizona’s pedestrian death rate was nearly double the rest of the country’s from 2018 to 2022.

Arizona rate trends vary by insurer

Arizona’s 2026 premium trend differed by insurer and by source. Study B estimated an average Arizona full-coverage premium of $1,953 a year in June 2026 and projected a 3.9% statewide increase for 2026, while filing-based data in Study F showed cuts for several carriers and increases for others. These estimates are not confirmed 2027 premiums or an individual renewal forecast. Drivers reviewing low-upfront car insurance payment plans should compare installment fees and the total policy cost, not only the first amount due.

Rate filing data as of October 6, 2026. Source: Study F Arizona page.

Rate filing data as of October 6, 2026. Source: Study F Arizona page.

Study F reported cumulative Arizona rate changes over its five-year measurement period of 95.5% at Farmers and 72.1% at Liberty Mutual, compared with 14.7% at AAA and 28.4% at State Farm. Those are historical filing-based comparisons, not predictions for a new policy. WTW projected a broad nationwide personal auto market range of about -2% to +4% for 2027; that forecast is not Phoenix-specific and should not be used as a quote.

Monsoon season and your policy

From dust storms to hail, the Valley’s storms are an important reason to compare comprehensive coverage in Phoenix. Liability insurance pays for covered damage you cause to others, not hail damage to your own parked car. Comprehensive generally covers hail, floodwater, theft, and falling-object losses, subject to the policy’s exclusions and deductible. Under A.R.S. §20-264, insurers selling comprehensive on private passenger cars must offer an optional repair-or-replacement benefit for qualifying damaged safety glass without a deductible; it is not included automatically.

If a haboob catches you on the road

The Arizona Department of Transportation’s “Pull Aside, Stay Alive” advice is simple: do not drive into a dust storm. If you cannot exit the road, pull completely off the pavement, turn off all lights, including your flashers, set the parking brake, take your foot off the brake, and stay buckled in.

Check three things before monsoon season

First, confirm whether comprehensive coverage is worth the cost for your car and what weather-related risks it covers. Second, compare its standard deductible with Arizona’s optional zero-deductible safety-glass benefit, because the standard deductible can absorb much of a windshield claim. Third, obtain an uninsured/underinsured motorist quote and examine the limits; the cited statewide uninsured rate is an estimate, not a Phoenix-specific measure.

PRO TIP #4

Before filing a storm or glass claim, ask your insurer how it would affect your rate. Arizona law separately bars a surcharge for an accident you did not cause or significantly contribute to.

Cartoon infographic about the best and cheapest car insurance companies in Phoenix: Travelers had the lowest full coverage price in five of eight studies; Study F prices ran from 217 dollars a month in Ahwatukee to 290 in Grandview; Arizona requires 25/50/15 liability and has no PIP requirement; Phoenix had 4,700 vehicle thefts in 2025; Phoenix speed cameras started ticketing in March 2026; tip: Arizona law bars insurers from raising your premium for an accident you did not cause.

Phoenix car insurance in six panels, from Ahwatukee to the West Valley.

Editorial image warning: This infographic contains earlier study conclusions and regulatory claims. See the updated text, particularly the post-election 2026 Proposition 319 explanation, for the current qualifications.

Quick answers on car insurance companies in Phoenix

What is the cheapest car insurance company in Phoenix?

Travelers had the lowest listed full-coverage price in the Phoenix-specific Studies D, E, and H and in statewide Studies C and G. State Farm led Study F, Auto-Owners led Study B, and Root led Study A. These studies used different sample profiles and do not establish the cheapest company for an individual driver.

How much does car insurance cost in Phoenix?

Full coverage averaged $181 a month in Study H, $219 in Study B, and $220 in Study F, or roughly $2,200 to $2,650 a year. Minimum coverage averaged $112 a month in Study F.

What car insurance does Arizona require?

Liability coverage of at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for injuries, plus $15,000 for property damage. Insurers must offer uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, and there is no PIP requirement.

Can my insurer raise my rate after an accident that was not my fault?

No. A.R.S. 20-263 bars insurers from raising your premium for an accident you did not cause or significantly contribute to.

Do Phoenix speed camera tickets add points?

Not automatically. Whether a citation leads to points depends on the offense, court disposition, and any eligible defensive-driving dismissal. Scottsdale Police lists two points for red-light-camera convictions and three for speed-camera convictions, but that does not establish the outcome of every Phoenix citation. Proposition 319 passed on November 3, 2026 and changes the rules for photo-enforcement programs going forward.

Which Phoenix ZIP codes have the cheapest car insurance?

Ahwatukee’s 85044, 85045, and 85048 were among the cheapest in Studies F and H, and 85331, near Cave Creek, was the lowest in Study H at $143 a month. Maryvale and the west-central city were the most expensive.

Is car insurance cheaper in Mesa or Chandler?

Usually. Study B’s quotes for full coverage were $163 a month in Mesa and $162 in Chandler, compared with $219 in Phoenix.

Does Arizona allow credit-based pricing?

Yes, with limits. Insurers may use a credit-based insurance score, but it cannot include medical collections, income, ZIP code, or several other factors. Poor credit raised Study F’s average Phoenix premium to $502 a month.

What happens if I drive without insurance in Arizona?

A first violation brings a civil penalty of at least $500 and a three-month license suspension. Repeat violations within 36 months bring higher penalties, longer suspensions of your license and plates, and, after a third, an SR-22 filing.

Which company has the best service in Phoenix?

AAA’s CSAA, which won J.D. Power’s 2026 Southwest study with 653. State Farm was second, at 649, and USAA scored 707 but serves military families only.

Is there a cheaper option for low-mileage drivers?

Possibly. Pay-per-mile insurers Just Pay-Per-Mile and Mile Auto were among the cheapest in Study B’s Phoenix quotes, at $68 and $82 a month for liability coverage, behind only Auto-Owners.

Is Root a safe choice in Phoenix?

Root had the lowest full coverage price in Study A and the cheapest statewide minimum coverage in Study G, but it does not hold an AM Best rating. Compare its coverage and claims process carefully before you switch.

Do I need uninsured motorist coverage in Arizona?

It is not required, but insurers must offer it in writing. With about one Arizona driver in 10 uninsured, it is the coverage that pays your own injury costs when the at-fault driver has no insurance.

Does a DUI make Phoenix insurance unaffordable?

It raises the price sharply, but not equally. Study F’s average Phoenix DUI premium was $421 a month, while Progressive charged $249 and Travelers $286, and Travelers was the cheapest non-military company after a DUI in Studies D and E.

Are Arizona car insurance rates going up?

Not uniformly. One study projected a 3.9% Arizona-wide increase during 2026, while other data showed cuts by Progressive, AAA, and American Family and increases by other carriers. Nothing in the cited studies guarantees Phoenix premiums will rise by a specific amount in 2027.

The final word on car insurance companies in Phoenix

The insurer most likely to offer a competitive quote depends on the driver and the coverage being purchased. Travelers led several samples, with State Farm, Auto-Owners, and Root leading other profiles; none is guaranteed to win for an individual driver. Households with teenagers should compare several insurers, drivers with a DUI can also request a Progressive quote, and those prioritizing customer satisfaction may want to include AAA’s CSAA. USAA may be an option for eligible military households.

Compare quotes at every renewal using the car’s actual garaging address, the same limits and deductibles, and the full payment schedule. Arizona’s rules on not-at-fault accidents and eligible defensive driving dismissals may help in particular situations, but neither guarantees a lower premium. Rates differ materially by ZIP code, and a move should be reported accurately to the insurer rather than treated as an opportunity to change the address on paper. For a plain-language explanation in Spanish, seguro de auto barato covers shopping and protection trade-offs rather than a promised cheapest insurer.

Sources

Disclaimer

This guide to Phoenix car insurance pulls together independent rate studies, Arizona statutes, and public safety data to help drivers compare their options. It is for general information and is not legal, financial, or insurance advice. Your quote, your policy documents, and your insurer’s decisions govern your actual price and coverage.

Each study used its own sample profile, so the prices you see may differ. Travelers, State Farm, Auto-Owners, GEICO, Progressive, Root, USAA, AAA and CSAA, American Family, Mercury, and the other companies named here have no affiliation with us and did not pay for, review, or approve this guide.

We are also independent of J.D. Power, AM Best, the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions, the Arizona Department of Transportation, and the City of Phoenix. All trademarks are the property of their owners.

Related Articles