Best Arizona Car Insurance Companies: Rates, Coverage & Reviews
Golf-ball-sized hail cracked windshields across metro Phoenix on October 21, 2026, a reminder that the best Arizona car insurance companies are the ones that handle glass, storms, and theft well, not just the ones with the lowest sticker price. Travelers is a useful first quote to request because it has low sample premiums in several of the studies reviewed, while CSAA Insurance Group (AAA) led the Southwest customer-satisfaction study for the third consecutive year. Neither finding proves that one company offers the lowest rate or best service for every Arizona driver.
Arizona’s prices land near the national average, above it in some studies and below it in others, and the state has fewer uninsured drivers than most. Its risks are its own: summer heat, monsoon dust storms, hail, cracked glass, and vehicle thefts concentrated in Phoenix and Tucson. This guide compares 10 insurers as an editorial shortlist, then walks through those Arizona-specific situations one at a time. Its rankings are not a mathematical score or a real-time quote comparison.
QUICK ANSWER
- First company to quote for price: Travelers, among the least expensive in several 2025–2026 sample studies. No insurer is cheapest for everyone.
- Best for service: AAA (CSAA Insurance Group), first in J.D. Power’s 2026 Southwest study with 653.
- Phoenix comparison option: Progressive led the city-specific prices in Study F, but other studies use different driver profiles.
- Military-family option: USAA scored 707 in the Southwest study but was excluded from the official rankings because of eligibility restrictions.
- Optional protection: Arizona law requires insurers to offer zero-deductible safety-glass coverage with comprehensive; drivers must choose it.

Best Arizona car insurance companies at a glance. Sources: J.D. Power 2026 via Study C, Studies E and F (October 2026), A.R.S. 28-4009, and the Arizona Automobile Theft Authority.
The short list: 10 best Arizona car insurance companies
We reviewed eight price studies, labeled Study A through Study H, plus J.D. Power’s 2026 Southwest customer-satisfaction study, NAIC national complaint measures, and AM Best financial-strength ratings. These measures address different questions and were not collected using the same Arizona driver, vehicle, date, or coverage limits. We did not apply a published weighting formula; the 10-company list is an editorial shortlist, not a statistically reproducible ranking.

Chart note: The original illustration labels these companies 1–10 and displays a lowest price for each. Those prices were collected with different sample profiles and must not be treated as directly comparable Arizona quotes.
Original graphic: an editorial 10-company selection showing the lowest price found for each insurer across different sources. The figures are not comparable quotes for one driver and do not establish the cheapest insurer in Arizona.
Best Arizona car insurance companies at a glance
| Rank | Company | Best for | Lowest published sample shown (monthly; different methods) | J.D. Power 2026 Southwest | AM Best |
| 1 | Travelers | Lowest prices overall | $86 (Study H) | 630 | A++ |
| 2 | State Farm | Service and drivers with a ticket or accident | $102 (Study B) | 649 | A+ |
| 3 | Progressive | Phoenix and drivers with a DUI | $107 (Study B) | 615 | A+ |
| 4 | GEICO | Minimum coverage and 16-year-olds | $114 (Study H) | 637 | A++ |
| 5 | Auto-Owners | Agent service at low prices | $83 (Study B) | 616 | A+ |
| 6 | AAA (CSAA) | Customer satisfaction | $340 (Study A) | 653 | A |
| 7 | USAA | Military families | $114 (Study B) | 707* | A++ |
| 8 | American Family | Few complaints | $200 (Study B) | 632 | A |
| 9 | Allstate | Agent network and add-ons | $139 (Study B) | 626 | A+ |
| 10 | Mercury | Marketplace shoppers | $136 (Study B) | Not rated | A |
How to read this table: These are not matched quotes: each study uses its own driver, limits, deductibles, and time period, and the lowest observed price for one company cannot be compared directly with another company’s lowest observed price. USAA is not eligible for J.D. Power’s official regional ranking. Study A six-month premiums were divided by six for display; the Southwest satisfaction average was 638. AM Best ratings apply to particular rated entities or groups and should be checked against the company shown on the policy.
1. Travelers: strong published price results
Travelers shows up at or near the top of almost every Arizona price list. Its auto insurance coverage and discount options are explained further in a Spanish-language company review. It was cheapest for full coverage in five of the eight studies, at $113 a month in Study A, $1,707 a year in Study C, $138 a month in Study E, $148 in Study G, and $86 in Study H, and cheapest for minimum coverage in Study F, at $70.
Study E also found it cheapest after a ticket, an accident, or a DUI, and Study H named it cheapest for drivers 16 through 18.
Add an A++ rating and a national complaint index of 0.52, and the only real knock is a J.D. Power score of 630, eight points under the regional average.
2. State Farm
State Farm finished second in the Southwest with 649 and was the cheapest company after a speeding ticket or an at-fault accident in Study F, at $216 and $203 a month. It charged $102 a month for full coverage in Study B and was cheapest after a DUI in Study H. The trade-offs: it was among the pricier options in Study C, at $2,883 a year; it raised Arizona rates 2.4% in 2026, and AM Best lowered it to A+ in November 2025.

3. Progressive
Progressive had the lowest full coverage price in Study F, at $176 a month, and was the cheapest company in Phoenix, Tucson, Mesa, Scottsdale, and nearly every other city in that study. It was also cheapest after a DUI there, at $226, and cut Arizona rates 4.7% in 2026. Its J.D. Power score of 615 is the main weakness.
4. GEICO
GEICO, the largest auto insurer in Arizona by 2021 premium, had the cheapest state minimum coverage in Study C, at $435 a year, and the cheapest rate for a 16-year-old there, at $6,143. It scored 637 in the Southwest customer-satisfaction study, just below the regional average of 638, and the cited AM Best release affirmed an A++ rating for GEICO members.
5. Auto-Owners
Auto-Owners had the lowest prices in Study B, at $49 a month for liability and $83 for full coverage, and was cheapest for teens there too. Its $83 example illustrates that car insurance under $100 a month may be possible for some profiles, not that the same price is widely available. It sells through independent agents, holds an A+ rating, and has a national complaint index of 0.54, though it scored 616 with J.D. Power.
6. AAA (CSAA Insurance Group): high regional satisfaction
AAA-branded auto policies are not necessarily underwritten by the same company in every territory or program. CSAA Insurance Group won J.D. Power’s Southwest customer-satisfaction region for the third straight year, scoring 653; confirm the actual underwriter shown on any Arizona AAA quote. A study reported a 4.7% Arizona rate-filing reduction for the AAA group it tracked in 2026. Price may be the trade-off: Study C put CSAA at $4,965 a year for its specific full-coverage driver profile, the highest within that study, not a universal Arizona premium.
7. USAA
USAA scored 707 with J.D. Power, the highest score in the Southwest, though it is not eligible for an official ranking. It charged $114 a month for full coverage in Study B and $165 in Study F, and it holds an A++ rating. Only service members, veterans, and their families can join.
8. American Family
American Family has the lowest national complaint index of any company we track, at 0.33, and it cut Arizona rates 4.5% in 2026. It scored 632 with J.D. Power, just under the regional average, and charged $200 a month for full coverage in Study B, so it is best for drivers who value service over the lowest price.
9. Allstate
Allstate scored 626 with J.D. Power and charged $139 a month for full coverage in Study B, about average. It was more expensive in Study C, at $2,846 a year, but its large agent network and A+ rating make it worth a quote if you want local service.
10. Mercury
Mercury was the second cheapest for full coverage in Study G’s marketplace quotes, at $1,841 a year, and charged $136 a month in Study B. AM Best affirmed its A rating in February 2026 and moved its outlook to stable.
OTHER NAMES YOU WILL SEE IN ARIZONA QUOTES
Farmers scored 610 with J.D. Power and raised Arizona rates 5.2% in 2026, the biggest increase in Study F’s data. Root had the cheapest minimum coverage in Study G, at $1,247 a year, but has no AM Best rating in the sources reviewed. Its driving-based insurance model is described in a Spanish-language review; eligibility and prices must be checked directly. The General, now owned by Sentry, carries an A+ rating and focuses on drivers who have trouble finding coverage. Commonwealth Casualty, an Arizona-focused insurer founded in 2010, had no AM Best rating in the sources we reviewed.
What Arizona drivers pay, and why the studies disagree
Published sample averages for full coverage in Arizona ranged from roughly $140 to $245 a month across the studies reviewed; these figures refer to different driver samples and coverage configurations. Differences reflect driver ages, vehicles, deductibles, liability limits, dates, and methodologies; a marketplace quote sample is not interchangeable with modeled premiums based on filed rates. Comparing car insurance quote details (Spanish-language checklist) helps keep the driver, vehicle, limits, and deductible consistent.

Study A is a six-month premium divided by 6, and Studies C and E are yearly premiums divided by 12 (our calculations). National comparisons: $187 in Study B, about $197 in Study E, and $123 in Study H.
Study B’s data shows Arizona rates peaked in August 2024 and have eased since. Its projections conflict, though: its Arizona page projects an average of $1,813 a year by the end of 2026, while its August 2026 national report projects $1,971 for Arizona, up 3.9% for the year. Treat both as rough guides rather than promises.
Cheapest company in each study
Cheapest Arizona insurer in each rate study (USAA excluded)
| Study | Full coverage leader | Price | Minimum or liability leader | Price |
| Study A (6 months) | Travelers | $676 | Auto-Owners | $267 |
| Study B (monthly) | Auto-Owners | $83 | Auto-Owners | $49 |
| Study C (yearly) | Travelers | $1,707 | GEICO | $435 |
| Study E (monthly) | Travelers | $138 | Travelers and GEICO | $45 |
| Study F (monthly) | Progressive | $176 | Travelers | $70 |
| Study G (yearly) | Travelers | $1,770 | Root | $1,247 |
| Study H (monthly) | Travelers | $86 | Travelers | $45 |
Study B also lists a pay-per-mile insurer tied with Auto-Owners for the lowest liability price. Study G uses marketplace quotes, so its prices run higher. Study D’s company rankings use 2023 rates, so we left them out of this table.
Minimum coverage versus full coverage auto insurance in AZ
Arizona’s 25/50/15 legal minimum averaged about $55 a month for Study C’s driver profile. Some published examples of car insurance under $50 a month refer to limited liability coverage and specific drivers; they are not universally available. Moreover, $15,000 of property damage coverage will not replace many newer vehicles, and you are personally responsible for amounts above your policy limits. In Study C, the difference between the quoted minimum and the higher 50/100/50 liability tier ranged from $83 to $695 per year across the companies shown; those differences apply only to its driver profile.
Arizona premiums by coverage level, Study C (yearly)
| Company | State minimum (25/50/15) | Liability 50/100/50 | Full coverage |
| Travelers | $517 | $693 | $1,707 |
| GEICO | $435 | $692 | $1,796 |
| Progressive | $641 | $935 | $2,114 |
| Auto-Owners | $548 | $767 | $2,258 |
| Nationwide | $1,090 | $1,173 | $2,636 |
| Allstate | $683 | $1,123 | $2,846 |
| Farmers | $840 | $1,535 | $2,865 |
| State Farm | $776 | $1,082 | $2,883 |
| USAA* | $480 | $672 | $1,880 |
| Arizona average | $662 | $964 | $2,333 |
*Military families only. 40-year-old driver, Honda Accord LX, good credit, clean record; full coverage is 100/300/100 with $500 deductibles. Source: Study C, November 2025.
The cheapest company for your specific situation
Three studies published Arizona results for nearly every common driver profile. Travelers comes up again and again, but State Farm, Progressive, and Auto-Owners each win specific situations.
Cheapest Arizona insurer by driver situation (monthly)
| Situation | Study E | Study F | Study H |
| Clean record, full coverage | Travelers $138 | Progressive $176 | Travelers $86 |
| Minimum or liability only | Travelers $45 | Travelers $70 | Travelers $45 |
| Young driver | Travelers $240 (age 20) | Travelers $515 (age 18) | Travelers $421 (age 16) |
| Senior | Travelers $129 (age 70) | Not published | Travelers $91 |
| Speeding ticket | Travelers $177 | State Farm $216 | Auto-Owners $108 |
| At-fault accident | Travelers $185 | State Farm $203 | Travelers $114 |
| DUI | Travelers $198 | Progressive $226 | State Farm $122 |
| Poor credit | Travelers $208 | Progressive $278 | Safeway $143 |
Full coverage unless noted; USAA excluded. Study E uses a 35-year-old with a 2023 Toyota Camry, Study F a 30-year-old man with a 2018 Honda Civic, and Study H a 40-year-old. Sources: Studies E, F, and H, October and November 2026.
PRO TIP #1
If you have a ticket or an at-fault accident on your record, quote State Farm and Travelers side by side. They traded the top spot across studies, and either could save you $50 a month or more over the average.
Phoenix pays more: rates across Arizona cities
Phoenix had the highest average full coverage rate of the cities in Study F, at $284 a month, and Glendale was close behind at $274. Northern Arizona is the bargain: Flagstaff averaged $194 and Prescott $193. Progressive had the lowest modeled price in the cities reported by Study F; that result applies to its sample profile and does not guarantee Progressive will be cheapest for each resident.

30-year-old man, 2018 Honda Civic, 50/100/50 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study F, October 2026.
If you only need minimum coverage, Study H found Travelers cheapest in 16 of the 20 Arizona cities it checked, from $57 a month in Phoenix to $48 in Tucson. In Study E, Travelers was also cheapest for a clean-record driver in Phoenix, at $2,032 a year, as well as in Mesa and Tucson. Study B found the same geography with lower numbers: Phoenix averaged $219 a month for full coverage, while Prescott was $119 and Lake Havasu City just $102.
Desert driving risks and the coverage that pays for them
Most Arizona claims don’t come from anything exotic, but a few local hazards make comprehensive coverage, and one optional add-on, worth more here than in most states.
Arizona hazards and the coverage that pays
| Hazard | What happens | Coverage that pays |
| Cracked windshields and windows | Rocks, heat, and hail damage glass | Comprehensive, with zero-deductible glass if you add it |
| Monsoon hail and flooding | Golf-ball hail hit metro Phoenix on October 21, 2026 | Comprehensive |
| Haboobs (dust storms) | Sudden near-zero visibility on highways | Collision for crashes; liability if you hit someone |
| Vehicle theft | 12,686 vehicles stolen statewide in 2025 | Comprehensive |
| Wildfire | Fire or falling debris damages a parked car | Comprehensive |
| Battery and tire failures in extreme heat | Wear and tear, not a covered loss | Roadside assistance, if you add it |
Arizona’s zero-deductible glass option
Arizona Revised Statutes § 20-264 requires insurers writing comprehensive coverage for private passenger vehicles to offer, at the insured’s option, safety-equipment repair or replacement without a deductible. The law defines safety equipment as the glass in the windshield, doors, and windows and the glass or plastic in the vehicle’s lights. It is not automatic; insurers may charge an additional premium, and the option is associated with comprehensive, not liability-only coverage. Arizona Revised Statutes § 20-264 sets out the requirement.
WHY IT MATTERS IN ARIZONA
The October 21, 2026, storm damaged windshields across North Phoenix, Glendale, Tempe, and Mesa, according to Insurance Journal. Hailstorms in Phoenix in October 2010 caused an estimated $2.7 billion in insured losses. Without zero-deductible glass coverage, a $500 or $1,000 comprehensive deductible could leave you paying for some or all of a windshield repair, subject to the policy terms.
Monsoon season and haboobs
Storm damage is not limited to one bad afternoon. Progressive reported hail and flooding affecting customers in Maricopa and Pinal counties on September 26, 2025, a year before the October 2026 storm.
Monsoon season officially begins June 15, and the Arizona Department of Transportation’s advice for a dust storm is “Pull Aside, Stay Alive”: pull off the road early, turn off all lights, including your flashers, set the parking brake, take your foot off the brake pedal, and stay buckled in. A study published in the Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society found 232 traffic deaths linked to dust storms nationally from 2007 to 2017, with the Phoenix-Tucson corridor among the deadliest stretches.
Wildfire is a rural risk, too: the Dragon Bravo Fire on the Grand Canyon’s North Rim burned 145,504 acres in 2025. Fire damage to a car falls under comprehensive coverage.
Heat is its own hazard. AAA advises testing your battery twice a year in hot climates and checking tire pressure monthly, because heat speeds battery fluid loss and underinflated tires can overheat. Those failures are maintenance, not insurance claims, which makes roadside assistance one of the more useful add-ons in Arizona.
Vehicle theft is falling, but pickups are still targets
The Arizona Automobile Theft Authority counted 12,686 stolen vehicles in 2025, down 25% from 17,010 in 2024 (AATA 2025 report), and thefts fell another 24% in the first half of 2026. Phoenix accounted for 4,700 thefts in 2025, followed by Tucson with 2,060. Even at the lower 2026 pace, a vehicle was stolen somewhere in Arizona about every 41 minutes, and thefts in the 85034 ZIP code near Sky Harbor Airport rose 65% in the first half of 2026.

Number of thefts statewide. Source: Arizona Automobile Theft Authority, via Insurance Journal (February 2026).
If you drive a high-theft model, compare the cost of comprehensive coverage against the vehicle’s value and ask about eligible anti-theft discounts. Theft is typically a comprehensive claim, subject to exclusions and the deductible. In Study B’s data, State Farm offered up to 40% off certain coverages for safety and anti-theft features.
Fewer crashes, fewer deaths
ADOT counted 118,052 crashes and 1,156 traffic deaths in 2025, both down from 2024 (2025 ADOT crash summary). Alcohol was involved in 334 deaths, about 29% of the total, and 194 motorcyclists were killed. These are useful road-safety indicators, but they do not by themselves establish that Arizona liability premiums will fall. Any injury figure attributed to speeding requires the definitions in the state crash report.
After any crash, exchange insurance information with the other driver and file a police report if anyone is hurt. ADOT will provide the other driver’s insurance information for a $3 fee if you submit a copy of the police report, which helps when a driver gives you incomplete details.
Arizona’s insurance rules in plain English
Arizona is an at-fault state, so the driver who causes a crash pays through their liability coverage. Since July 1, 2020, every policy must carry at least 25/50/15: $25,000 for injuries to one person, $50,000 for all injuries in one crash, and $15,000 for property damage. The previous 15/30/10 limits had not changed in more than 40 years.
What Arizona law requires and protects
| Rule | What it means for you |
| 25/50/15 liability (A.R.S. 28-4009) | The legal minimum for every policy issued or renewed since July 1, 2020 |
| Uninsured and underinsured motorist (A.R.S. 20-259.01) | Insurers must offer both in writing, up to your liability limits; you can decline |
| No surcharge for crashes you did not cause (A.R.S. 20-263) | An insurer cannot raise your premium for an accident you did not cause or significantly contribute to |
| Credit-based insurance scores | Allowed, but insurers cannot use your income, gender, address, or ZIP code to build the score |
| Gender | Allowed as a rating factor |
| 55+ driver course (A.R.S. 20-262) | Insurers may, but do not have to, give a discount after an approved course |
Sources: Arizona Revised Statutes and the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI).
With only 10.6% of drivers uninsured in 2023, Arizona ranked 37th, below the national rate of 15.4%. Still, one in ten is a real risk, and uninsured motorist coverage is inexpensive compared with the medical bills it covers.
PRO TIP #2
When your insurer sends the written uninsured and underinsured motorist offer Arizona law requires, do not sign the rejection by default. Ask for a quote at your liability limits first; the difference is often smaller than drivers expect.
Penalties for driving without insurance in Arizona
| Offense | Minimum fine | Suspension |
| First | $500 | 3 months |
| Second within 3 years | $750 | 6 months |
| Third within 3 years | $1,000 | 1 year |
Court surcharges can push the total much higher; one Arizona city court lists totals of $972 to $1,883. An SR-22 filing and a reinstatement fee may also be required; the requirement and its start date depend on the reason for suspension or revocation. Sources: Arizona Department of Transportation (ADOT), Goodyear City Court, and Study F.
Arizona’s three levels of DUI
Arizona separates drunk driving into tiers by blood alcohol content, and the insurance consequences follow. Study D found a first DUI raised the average annual premium by about 57%, from $2,420 to $3,799, and a second by 107%.
Arizona DUI tiers, first offense
| Tier | Blood alcohol content | Minimum fine | Ignition interlock |
| Standard DUI | 0.08% to 0.149% | $1,250 | 12 months |
| Extreme DUI | 0.15% to 0.199% | $3,000 | 12 months |
| Super extreme DUI | 0.20% or more | $3,250 | 18 months |
Fines are statutory minimums before surcharges. Ignition interlock periods are set by ADOT. Arizona MVD generally requires proof of future financial responsibility after qualifying DUI suspensions or revocations; the start and duration vary by case. Sources: ADOT and Nolo.
Arizona insurers report policy changes and cancellations to ADOT’s Motor Vehicle Division automatically, so a lapse can lead to a suspension notice even if you are never pulled over. If you are required to file an SR-22 certificate of financial responsibility (Spanish-language explanation), keep it continuously for the period specified by MVD. Arizona commonly requires three years, but the starting point differs for suspensions versus revocations, and a lapse can trigger further suspension.
How a ticket or crash changes your price
Arizona full coverage by driving record, Study C (yearly)
| Company | Clean record | At-fault accident | Speeding ticket |
| Travelers | $1,707 | $2,429 | $2,503 |
| GEICO | $1,796 | $2,778 | $3,286 |
| Progressive | $2,114 | $3,456 | $2,951 |
| Auto-Owners | $2,258 | $3,141 | $4,025 |
| Nationwide | $2,636 | $3,759 | $3,921 |
| State Farm | $2,883 | $3,312 | $3,066 |
| Farmers | $2,865 | $4,573 | $3,691 |
| Allstate | $2,846 | $4,038 | $4,286 |
40-year-old driver, Honda Accord LX, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study C, November 2025.
State Farm stands out for forgiving drivers: its accident and ticket prices rose far less than most competitors’ in Study C, which matches its top finish after a violation in Study F.
Credit also matters in Arizona. Drivers looking at no-credit-check car insurance options should know that Arizona generally allows insurers to use credit-based insurance scores, but it bars them from penalizing you for having no credit history, for medical collection accounts, or for bankruptcies more than seven years old, and Study B found liability coverage rose from $91 a month with good credit to $116 with poor credit.
Teens, retirees, and service members
Insuring a teen driver
Travelers dominated Study H’s teen data, ranking cheapest for every age from 16 to 18 for both girls and boys. Costs fall quickly as teens gain experience: a 16-year-old cost about twice as much as a 19-year-old.
Cheapest Arizona insurer for teens, Study H (monthly, full coverage)
| Age | Teen girls | Teen boys |
| 16 | Travelers $421 | Travelers $423 |
| 17 | Travelers $312 | Travelers $313 |
| 18 | Travelers $250 | Travelers $251 |
| 19 | Travelers $199 | GEICO $189 |
For many households, adding an eligible teen to an existing family policy is less expensive than a separate policy, although eligibility and underwriting vary. Study B found a teen on a family policy cost about $257 a month, compared with $343 on their own policy, a difference of more than $1,000 a year. Study B also found Auto-Owners cheapest for teens, at $177 a month for full coverage, compared with an average teen rate of $344.

*Military families only. 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study C, November 2025.
The spread is huge: CSAA charged more than three times as much as GEICO for the same 16-year-old in Study C, so shopping matters even more for teen drivers than for adults.
Retirees and winter visitors
Older Arizona drivers can earn a course discount, though insurers don’t have to offer one.
Arizona Revised Statutes 20-262 lets insurers give drivers 55 and older a discount after an approved driver improvement course taken within the past three years. The discount is voluntary for insurers, and Study B found it worth up to 10% with GEICO.
For price, Travelers was cheapest for seniors in both Study E, at $129 a month at age 70, and Study H, at $91. In Study G’s marketplace quotes, Progressive was cheapest for drivers 65 and older, at $1,590 a year, and Study B found Auto-Owners cheapest for liability-only coverage in drivers’ 60s and 70s, at $38 a month.
Drivers with limited annual mileage can compare pay-per-mile insurance against traditional policies, although product availability and total premiums depend on the state and individual use. If you split the year between Arizona and another state, check with your insurer about where the car should be registered and insured. ADOT says an Arizona registration is not valid until an insurer confirms an active Arizona policy, so moving your registration here means moving your insurance too.
Military families
Arizona is home to Luke Air Force Base, Davis-Monthan Air Force Base, Fort Huachuca, and Yuma-area military installations. USAA, which serves military members, veterans, and their families, held 8.1% of the Arizona auto market in 2021. USAA scored 707 with J.D. Power, higher than any company ranked in the Southwest, and charged $114 a month for full coverage in Study B. Davis-Monthan alone counted 9,856 military personnel and civilians in a 2024 report, and Fort Huachuca 8,784.
What it costs to insure what Arizonans drive
The Toyota Camry led Arizona new-car sales in recent dealer data, followed by the Toyota Tacoma, Toyota RAV4, and Toyota Tundra. Pickups made up 21.8% of registered vehicles at the end of 2024, and Arizona’s average vehicle was 13 years old, older than the national average of 12.2 years. For most models, Study D found Arizona rates slightly below the national average.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Model pages cite 2025 rates. Source: Study D.
Two exceptions stand out: the Hyundai Elantra and Honda Civic cost slightly more to insure in Arizona than nationally, and the Elantra was also the second most stolen vehicle in the state in 2025. For a Honda Accord driver, Study C found Travelers, GEICO, and Progressive cheapest among companies open to everyone, at $1,707, $1,796, and $2,114 a year.
Top 10 cheapest vehicles to insure in Arizona
Small SUVs fill Arizona’s cheapest list, and every model on it costs less than $1,000 for six months of full coverage, or about $166 a month.

Chart note: These are study-specific six-month vehicle premiums, not current offers or a statewide guarantee that the same ten models are cheapest for every driver.
The 10 cheapest vehicles to insure in Arizona, six-month full coverage premiums.
Cheapest vehicles to insure in Arizona, Study D
| Rank | Vehicle | 6-month premium | About per month |
| 1 | Honda CR-V | $944 | $157 |
| 2 | Hyundai Venue | $962 | $160 |
| 3 | Subaru Outback | $965 | $161 |
| 4 | Subaru Forester | $970 | $162 |
| 5 | Chevrolet TrailBlazer | $980 | $163 |
| 6 | Mini Cooper Electric | $981 | $164 |
| 7 | Honda HR-V | $985 | $164 |
| 8 | Mazda CX-5 | $986 | $164 |
| 9 | Honda Pilot | $989 | $165 |
| 10 | Subaru Crosstrek | $994 | $166 |
100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. For an 18-year-old, the Subaru Outback cost $3,815 and the Honda CR-V $3,818 for six months. Source: Study D.
Among sedans, the Subaru Legacy was cheapest, at $1,035 for six months, and among sports cars, the Mazda MX-5 Miata was $1,091. Teslas cost a bit less in Arizona than nationally: Study C put the Model 3 at $3,761 a year and the Model Y at $3,736, compared with national averages of $3,871 and $3,836. Heat is hard on batteries of every kind, but that is maintenance, not an insurance claim.

40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles. Source: Study D.
Even a Porsche 911 Turbo cost less than $2,230 for six months in Arizona, though that is more than twice the price of a Honda CR-V.
Pickups and EVs
Pickups made up more than a fifth of Arizona’s registered vehicles, and they cost more to insure than small SUVs. Study G priced full coverage at $174 a month for a Ford F-150, $182 for a Chevrolet Silverado 1500, $190 for a Ram 1500, and $219 for a Toyota Tacoma. Because the Silverado was also Arizona’s most stolen vehicle in 2025, comprehensive coverage is especially important for Silverado owners.
Electric vehicles are still a small slice of Arizona’s fleet, 118,553 registrations or 1.7% at the end of 2024, but they made up 8.0% of new sales that year. The cheapest EVs to insure in Study D were the Mini Cooper Electric, at $981 for six months, the Kia Niro EV, at $1,010, and the Volkswagen ID.4, at $1,086, while the Ford F-150 Lightning cost $1,201.
How Arizona insurers rate on service and stability
Arizona belongs to J.D. Power’s Southwest region along with Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, and Utah. Only two companies, AAA’s CSAA and State Farm, beat the regional average of 638 in 2026, and several of the cheapest insurers in Arizona scored below it.

USAA scored 707 but is not eligible for official rankings. Source: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, released June 9, 2026; full table as reported by Study C.
Satisfaction is slipping nationally. J.D. Power found 30% of customers had an insurer-initiated premium increase in the past year, and only 58% said they fully understood their policy, down four points. Nearly a third of shoppers used AI tools in their search.
Complaints
Arizona’s insurance department closed 4,077 consumer complaint cases and health care appeals in fiscal 2025, and about 60% of the consumer complaints involved personal auto or homeowners insurance. Claims handling was the top issue, followed by premiums and cancellations, and the department recovered more than $24 million for consumers.
DIFI has published an annual auto premium comparison with complaint ratios in past years, but we could not find a current edition, so the chart below uses the NAIC’s national index, where 1.00 is the expected number of complaints for a company’s size.

Lower is better. National data. Source: NAIC data as published by Study D, August 2026.
AM Best financial strength ratings, Arizona insurers
| Insurer | Rating | Latest action we found |
| GEICO | A++ | Affirmed April 16, 2026 |
| Travelers | A++ | Affirmed August 21, 2026 |
| USAA | A++ | Affirmed June 25, 2026 |
| State Farm | A+ | Lowered from A++, November 14, 2025 |
| Progressive | A+ | Affirmed May 1, 2026 |
| Allstate | A+ | Affirmed September 2, 2026 |
| Auto-Owners | A+ | Lowered from A++, October 31, 2024 |
| The General | A+ | Raised from A after its sale to Sentry, February 20, 2025 |
| American Family | A | Affirmed October 22, 2026 |
| Mercury | A | Affirmed February 24, 2026 |
| CSAA (AAA) | A | Affirmed July 23, 2025 |
| Nationwide | A | Affirmed November 7, 2025 |
| Farmers | A | Affirmed August 1, 2025 |
| Liberty Mutual | A | Affirmed September 10, 2025 |
Many Arizona guides still list State Farm or Auto-Owners as A++. Sources: AM Best releases and company announcements.
Who insures Arizona
GEICO, State Farm, and Progressive wrote 46.4% of Arizona’s private passenger auto premium in 2021 between them, and the top 10 groups wrote more than 80%.

Share of $6.0 billion in 2021 direct written premium, the newest group-level Arizona data we found. Source: NAIC data, published February 2024.
Crossing into Mexico, and riding in a robotaxi
Two situations come up in Arizona more than almost anywhere else. If you drive into Mexico, your U.S. policy will not satisfy Mexican law. Mexico recognizes only insurance from Mexican insurers, so buy a Mexican auto tourist policy before you cross, and check whether your U.S. insurer extends any physical damage coverage near the border. Northern Arizona University’s risk management office gives its own travelers the same warning: Mexican police do not recognize policies written by American companies.
Metro Phoenix also has a large driverless taxi service area, about 350 square miles after Waymo’s August 2026 expansion into Gilbert and Chandler. Under A.R.S. 28-9702, the automated driving system counts as the driver when it is engaged, so the operating company, not the rider, is responsible for traffic citations. A Swiss Re study of 25.3 million Waymo miles found 88% fewer property damage claims and 92% fewer injury claims than the overall driving population.
What the 2026 rate filings suggest—and do not prove—about 2027
Arizona premiums have cooled since their 2024 peak: Study B’s tracker put the average at $2,121 a year in August 2024 and $1,951 in October 2026. The picture is mixed by company. In Study F’s filing data, Progressive and the cited AAA rate-filing analysis reported a 4.7% reduction for its tracked program in 2026, while Farmers raised them 5.2%.

Bars show the size of each change: Progressive -4.7%, AAA -4.7%, American Family -4.5%, USAA and Travelers 0.0%, Allstate +1.2%, State Farm +2.4%, GEICO +2.5%, Liberty Mutual +3.8%, Farmers +5.2%. Source: Study F, from rate filings as of October 2026.
Lower theft counts and fewer reported traffic deaths are encouraging, but the effect on future premiums is uncertain and depends on repair costs, claims severity, reinsurance, and insurer filings. ADOT reported 1,156 traffic deaths in 2025, down 5.2% and the third straight annual decline. Hail is the wild card: a single storm, like October’s, can damage cars across the Valley in an afternoon. WTW published a national 2027 personal-auto pricing outlook of −2% to +4%. That is an industry forecast, not an Arizona-specific approved rate change or a promise about an individual renewal.
Discounts Arizona drivers can ask for
Largest discounts available to Arizona drivers
| Discount | Up to | Example insurer |
| Safety features and anti-theft devices | 40% | State Farm, on eligible coverages |
| Good driver | 33% | Progressive |
| Multi-policy bundle | 30% | Progressive |
| Telematics | 30% | State Farm Drive Safe & Save; Liberty Mutual RightTrack |
| Multi-vehicle | 25% | Amica |
| Good student | 25% | State Farm |
| Membership or affinity group | 15% | Various |
| 55+ defensive driving course | 10% | GEICO |
Maximum advertised savings; most drivers get less. Source: Study B, November 2026. If you pay premiums by bank transfer, compare online car insurance payment options using a checking account and check whether an EFT discount offsets any installment fees.
An Arizona checklist before you renew
Arizona renewal checklist
| Check this | Why |
| Zero-deductible glass | Hail and road debris make windshield claims common |
| Uninsured and underinsured motorist limits | Insurers must offer them up to your liability limits |
| Liability above 25/50/15 | A serious crash can easily exceed $25,000 per person |
| Anti-theft discounts | Especially for a Silverado, Elantra, Sonata, or Kia Soul |
| 55+ course discount | Ask whether your insurer offers one before you sign up for a class |
| Mexico plans | Buy a Mexican policy before any trip across the border |
PRO TIP #3
When a haboob or monsoon cell is in the forecast, park in a garage or under cover if you can. Comprehensive pays for hail, but a covered space can spare you the damage, the deductible, and the claim altogether.

Chart note: The original illustration reflects the article’s earlier categorical winner labels and selected rates. It should be replaced when updated artwork is available; the revised text provides the qualified assessment.
Arizona car insurance, summed up in six desert-themed panels.
Frequently asked questions about the best Arizona car insurance companies
Who has the best car insurance in Arizona?
Travelers ranks first in our review for low prices in most studies and an A++ rating. State Farm offers the best mix of price and service, and AAA’s CSAA leads J.D. Power’s Southwest region.
Who has the cheapest full coverage in Arizona?
Travelers was cheapest in five of eight studies, Progressive in Study F, and Auto-Owners in Study B.
Does Arizona require full glass coverage?
No, but insurers that sell comprehensive coverage must offer a zero-deductible glass option. You have to choose it.
What are the minimum car insurance requirements in Arizona?
Liability of 25/50/15 since July 1, 2020. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage must be offered, but you can decline it in writing.
Is uninsured motorist coverage required in Arizona?
No. Insurers must offer uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage in writing, but you can reject it. Most drivers should keep it.
Is Arizona a no-fault state?
No. Arizona is an at-fault state, so the driver who causes a crash pays for the damage through their liability insurance.
Can my rate go up after a crash that was not my fault?
Arizona law bars insurers from raising your premium for an accident you did not cause or significantly contribute to.
Is car insurance more expensive in Phoenix?
Yes. Study F put Phoenix at $284 a month for full coverage, compared with $229 in Tucson and $193 in Prescott.
Does my Arizona car insurance work in Mexico?
No. Mexico recognizes only policies from Mexican insurers, so buy Mexican auto tourist insurance before you cross the border.
How much does a DUI raise insurance in Arizona?
Study D found a first DUI raised the average premium about 57%. Travelers, Progressive, and State Farm were cheapest after a DUI in different studies.
Who has the cheapest car insurance for teens in Arizona?
Travelers was cheapest for 16- to 18-year-olds in Study H, GEICO for a 16-year-old in Study C, and Auto-Owners in Study B.
Do I need an SR-22 in Arizona after a DUI?
Yes. ADOT requires proof of future financial responsibility after a DUI conviction, usually for three years.
What is the cheapest car to insure in Arizona?
The Honda CR-V, at $944 for six months of full coverage in Study D, followed by the Hyundai Venue and Subaru Outback.
Who is responsible if a Waymo hits my car?
Arizona law treats the automated system as the driver, so the operating company is responsible for traffic violations. Tempe police have said that if a robotaxi violation causes a crash, the operator can be cited and found liable for damages.
The final word on the best Arizona car insurance companies
Arizona rewards drivers who shop on price and then customize for the desert. Request matching quotes from Travelers, State Farm, and Progressive, then consider Auto-Owners or an AAA-affiliated underwriter where available. Compare the specific policy, not just the brand. Add USAA if you meet its membership eligibility requirements; military service alone is not an automatic quote or eligibility guarantee.
Whichever company you choose, compare comprehensive coverage and the optional zero-deductible safety-glass offer, price uninsured and underinsured motorist protection, and choose deductibles you could afford after a claim.
Compare at least three written quotes with matching liability limits, deductibles, drivers, garaging address, and policy term. A Spanish-language explanation of comparing free car insurance quotes covers the inputs and terms to verify. No fixed completion time or amount of savings is guaranteed.
Sources
- Study A: The Zebra, Arizona car insurance.
- Study B: Insurify, Arizona car insurance (November 1, 2026); Insurify, Arizona teens; Insurify, Arizona discounts; and Insurify, rate report (August 11, 2026).
- Study C: Insurance.com, best and cheapest car insurance in Arizona (November 26, 2025); Insurance.com, Tesla Model 3; Insurance.com, Tesla Model Y; and Insurance.com, J.D. Power ratings (June 23, 2026).
- Study D: CarInsurance.com, Arizona high-risk drivers (March 26, 2026); CarInsurance.com, cheapest cars to insure in Arizona (accessed November 2, 2026); CarInsurance.com, NAIC complaint data (August 13, 2026); and model pages for the Ford F-150, Chevrolet Silverado 1500, Ram 1500, Toyota Tacoma, Toyota Camry, Honda Civic, Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, and Hyundai Elantra.
- Study E: NerdWallet, cheap car insurance in Arizona (October 2, 2026) and NerdWallet, best car insurance in Arizona (October 1, 2026).
- Study F: ValuePenguin, cheapest car insurance in Arizona (October 13, 2026) and ValuePenguin, Arizona penalties (June 30, 2026).
- Study G: Experian, cheapest car insurance in Arizona (October 13, 2026).
- Study H: MoneyGeek, best car insurance in Arizona (November 1, 2026) and MoneyGeek, cheapest car insurance in Arizona (October 31, 2026).
- Arizona government and law: DIFI, minimum coverage; DIFI, shopping for auto insurance; DIFI, how insurers use credit information (February 2025); A.R.S. 28-4009; A.R.S. 20-259.01; A.R.S. 20-264; A.R.S. 20-262; A.R.S. 28-9702; ADOT, vehicle insurance information; ADOT, SR-22; ADOT, DUI; ADOT, Pull Aside, Stay Alive; ADOT, 2025 crash facts (August 27, 2026); Goodyear City Court, insurance violations; and Insurance Journal, DIFI fiscal 2025 results (October 22, 2025).
- Ratings, companies, and news: J.D. Power, 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study (June 9, 2026); AM Best, State Farm (November 14, 2025); AM Best, GEICO (April 16, 2026); AM Best, Progressive (May 1, 2026); AM Best, Allstate (September 2026); AM Best, Farmers (August 1, 2025); AM Best, USAA (June 25, 2026); AM Best, Travelers (August 21, 2026); AM Best, Liberty Mutual (September 10, 2025); AM Best, American Family (October 22, 2026); AM Best, Nationwide (November 7, 2025); AM Best, CSAA (July 23, 2025); AM Best, Mercury (February 24, 2026); AM Best, The General (February 20, 2025); The Insurer, Auto-Owners (November 1, 2024); AAA Mountain West Group (September 2026); NAIC market share via Stacker (February 20, 2024); Insurance Journal, Phoenix hail (October 23, 2026); Insurance Journal, Arizona auto theft 2025 (February 3, 2026); Insurance Journal, first-half 2026 thefts (July 22, 2026); FOX Weather, dust storm study (April 8, 2023); GEICO, Mexico auto insurance; Northern Arizona University, Mexican auto insurance; KJZZ, Waymo expansion (August 13, 2026); KJZZ, Waymo citations (February 9, 2026); Waymo, Swiss Re study (December 19, 2024); Nolo, Arizona DUI; Arizona best-selling new cars; Alliance for Automotive Innovation, Arizona; WTW, 2027 personal lines outlook (October 2026); and Insurance Information Institute, uninsured motorists.
Disclaimer
We are an independent publisher, and this review compares Arizona auto insurers using public information. Travelers, State Farm, Progressive, GEICO, Auto-Owners, AAA, CSAA, USAA, American Family, Allstate, Mercury, Farmers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Dairyland, Bristol West, The General, Safeway, and every other company named here had no role in writing it and have no business relationship with us. We are likewise not connected to J.D. Power, AM Best, Waymo, ADOT, or DIFI. All trademarks are their owners’ property.
This article does not give insurance, legal, or financial advice and does not sell any policy. For questions about a DUI case, an SR-22, or a claim dispute, talk with an Arizona attorney, a licensed agent, or DIFI.
The prices shown are published sample estimates from different dates and methods, not 2027 filed rates, individually underwritten quotes, or guaranteed premiums. Ratings, laws, and theft and crash figures change over time, so verify anything important with the insurer or the state before you make a decision.