Best and Cheapest Toyota Tacoma Insurance: Rates & Coverage

Methodology note: The company list is an editorial shortlist, not a uniform national rate ranking. Quotes vary by state, eligibility, cab, trim, year, modifications and use.

With a record 274,638 sold in 2025, the Tacoma is America’s best-selling midsize pickup, and the cost of Toyota Tacoma insurance varies substantially by insurer and driver profile. Study C’s October 2026 data puts full coverage on a 2025 Tacoma at $2,542 a year, or $212 a month, for a 40-year-old driver, while Travelers charges $1,761 and Farmers charges $3,562 for the same truck.

That spread is the reason to shop. A Tacoma costs about the same to insure as most midsize pickups, but the company you choose, your trim, your state, and whether you work, tow, or go off-road with your truck can each move the price by hundreds or thousands of dollars.

The Tacoma has also changed a lot. The fourth generation arrived for 2024 with eight trims, a 2.4-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, and an optional i-FORCE MAX hybrid with 326 horsepower. Many owners still drive the third-generation truck sold from 2016 to 2023, and its trims are priced differently.

This guide covers it all. It ranks the 10 cheapest companies and the best ones for service, explains liability-only and full coverage, and covers the 2026 and 2027 trucks, safety, theft, and repair costs. It then gives every current and third-generation trim its own section, followed by model years, work and off-road use, tickets, 10 discounts, teens from 16 to 19, seniors, and military families.

Toyota Tacoma insurance at a glance

Measure Figure Source
Average full coverage, 2025 Tacoma $2,542 a year ($212 a month) Study C, Oct 2026
Average Tacoma Hybrid (i-FORCE MAX) $2,779 a year ($232 a month) Study D, Mar 2026
Average liability-only coverage $1,101 a year Study C, Oct 2026
Cheapest company open to everyone, 2025 Tacoma Travelers, $1,761 a year Study C, Oct 2026
Cheapest trim in the trim data TRD PreRunner, $2,474 a year Study I, Apr 2026
Most expensive trim in the trim data Trailhunter, $2,962 a year Study I, Apr 2026
Average for an 18-year-old male driver $8,260 a year Study D, Mar 2026

Each study uses its own driver, limits, and deductible, so compare figures within one study rather than across them. The full study names are listed in the Sources section.

The 10 cheapest insurance companies for a Toyota Tacoma

Our editorial shortlist considers how often each company appears near the low end of nine published rate studies; it is not a statistically normalized ranking, because the studies use different vehicles, drivers, insurers, limits and deductibles. Each price below is the one the named study published for its own sample driver.

Top 10 cheapest insurers for a Toyota Tacoma: 1 Travelers 1,761 dollars a year, 2 GEICO 136 dollars a month, 3 USAA 1,859 dollars for military families, 4 American Family 1,702 dollars, 5 State Farm 1,900 dollars, 6 Progressive 1,464 dollars, 7 Erie 1,584 dollars, 8 Nationwide 1,681 dollars, 9 AAA Auto Club Group 2,141 dollars, 10 The Hartford 177 dollars a month. The letter after each price names the study.

The 10 cheapest insurers for a Toyota Tacoma. The letter after each price names the study.

Published Tacoma prices for the top 10 companies

Insurer Study C, 2025 (year) Study I (year) Study A, 2025 (year) Study H (month)
1. Travelers $1,761 $1,771 — $154
2. GEICO $2,003 $2,032 $1,643 $136
3. USAA* $1,859 $1,868 $1,721 —
4. American Family — $1,702 $1,661 —
5. State Farm $2,144 $2,146 $2,067 $191
6. Progressive $2,095 $2,109 $1,464 $173
7. Erie — $2,081 $1,584 —
8. Nationwide $2,263 $2,344 $1,681 $190
9. AAA (Auto Club Group) — $2,141 — $228
10. The Hartford — — — $177

Full coverage. Study C: 40-year-old, 100/300/100, $500 deductible, October 2026. Study I: 40-year-old male, $500 deductible, 2025 models, April 2026. Study A: 30-year-old male, 2025 Tacoma. Study H: 40-year-old male, $1,000 deductible, all model years, August 2026; its AAA figure covers all AAA clubs. *USAA sells only to military families. A dash means the study did not price that company.

1. Travelers

Travelers had the lowest price for a 2025 Tacoma in Study C, at $1,761 a year, and it was the cheapest company in that study for every model year from 2018 to 2025 except two, when USAA beat it by $1 and $7. It also placed second among companies open to everyone in Study I and Study H.

2. GEICO

GEICO was the cheapest company in Study H, at $136 a month for full coverage and $63 a month for state minimum across all model years, and it also led that study for the 2023, 2024, and 2025 Tacoma. It costs $1,643 a year for a 2025 Tacoma in Study A.

3. USAA

USAA had the lowest price of any company in Study B’s real customer quotes, at $122 a month for a 2023 Tacoma, and in Study J. It costs $1,859 a year for a 2025 Tacoma in Study C, but only military members, veterans, and their families can buy it.

4. American Family

American Family was the cheapest company in Study I at $1,702 a year, and it came in at $1,661 for a 2025 Tacoma in Study A. It had one of the lower complaint indexes in the cited comparison, but it does not sell in every state.

5. State Farm

State Farm was the cheapest company open to everyone in Study J and Study B, and it costs $1,900 a year in Study D, just $4 more than the cheapest. It was also the cheapest company open to everyone after a ticket, an accident, or a DUI in Study J.

6. Progressive

Progressive had the lowest 2025 Tacoma price in Study A, at $1,464 a year for a 30-year-old man, and the lowest price in Study D at $1,896. It placed in the middle of the pack in Studies C and I.

7. Erie

Erie costs $1,584 a year for a 2025 Tacoma in Study A, second only to Progressive, and $2,081 in Study I. It sells in a limited number of states, but it leads three regions in J.D. Power’s satisfaction study.

8. Nationwide

Nationwide costs $1,681 a year for a 2025 Tacoma in Study A and $2,133 in Study D. It placed second in J.D. Power’s 2026 claims study and led its usage-based insurance rankings.

9. AAA (Auto Club Group)

The Auto Club Group, one of several regional AAA clubs, costs $2,141 a year in Study I. Other AAA clubs charged far more in that study, from $3,650 to $3,839, so prices depend heavily on which club serves your state.

10. The Hartford

The Hartford costs $177 a month for full coverage in Study H, fourth among the 14 companies it priced. Its auto insurance is best known through its AARP program, so it is worth a quote for drivers aged 50 and older.

PRO TIP #1

Start with Travelers, GEICO, State Farm, and Progressive, which sell nationwide. Then add American Family, Erie, or AAA if they sell in your state, and USAA if anyone in your household has served.

The best Tacoma insurance companies for service and claims

Many Tacomas tow, haul, and head down dirt roads, so the best and cheapest Toyota Tacoma insurance has to handle claims well, not just quote low. To rate service, we compared the cheapest companies on three outside measures.

Those measures are J.D. Power’s 2026 customer satisfaction scores, AM Best ratings for financial strength, and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) complaint index. On the complaint index, 1.00 is the expected number of complaints for a company of that size, so lower is better.

Service scores for the main Tacoma insurers

Insurer J.D. Power 2026 satisfaction (regional range) AM Best rating NAIC complaint index
Travelers 584 to 657 A++ 0.52
GEICO 631 to 668 A++ 0.69
USAA* 707 to 763 A++ 1.18
American Family 632 to 649 A 0.33
State Farm 632 to 669 A+ 0.79
Progressive 604 to 645 A+ 0.71
Erie 652 to 704 A+ 0.89
Nationwide 612 to 685 A 0.63
Allstate 612 to 660 A+ 1.10
Farmers 558 to 675 A 0.86

J.D. Power scores are out of 1,000 from its June 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, where the average was 644. AM Best ratings and NAIC indexes are as reported by Study D in December 2025 and August 2026. *USAA is not officially ranked by J.D. Power because only military families can buy it.

Best overall for Tacoma owners: Travelers

Travelers had the lowest 2025 Tacoma price among companies open to everyone in Study C and came second in Studies H and I. It holds an A++ rating and has a complaint index of 0.52, and it led J.D. Power’s New York region with 657.

Best for low rates nationwide: GEICO

GEICO led Study H for every recent model year and is sold in every state. It pairs those prices with an A++ rating and a complaint index of 0.69, well below average.

Best for fewest complaints: American Family

American Family had a complaint index of 0.33, the lowest in our table, and it was the cheapest company in Study I. If it sells where you live, it belongs on your quote list.

Best for customer satisfaction: Erie

Erie led three J.D. Power regions in 2026: the Mid-Atlantic with 704, the North Central with 688, and the Southeast with 691. State Farm, which led the Northwest with 667, is the strongest choice where Erie does not sell.

Best for claims: Amica and Nationwide

Amica led J.D. Power’s October 2026 claims study with 775 points, and Nationwide was second with 743, against an industry average of 700. Amica is not a low-price pick for a Tacoma at $2,345 a year in Study I, but Nationwide offers a good mix of price and claims service.

Best for service members: USAA

USAA had the lowest Tacoma price of any company in Studies B and J, and it scored highest in every J.D. Power region, from 707 to 763.

PRO TIP #2

If your Tacoma has a lift, aftermarket wheels, or other add-ons, ask each company how it would handle a claim for them before you buy. A cheap quote that leaves your upgrades uncovered is not a bargain.

The cheapest Tacoma insurance company overall

Within Study C, Travelers had the lowest full-coverage rate for a 2025 Tacoma among the eight companies it evaluated, at $1,801 a year less than Farmers, and it was the cheapest in that study for six of the last eight model years.

40-year-old driver, clean record, good credit, 100/300/100 with a 0 deductible. Source: Study C, Toyota Tacoma car insurance, October 26, 2026.

40-year-old driver, clean record, good credit, 100/300/100 with a $500 deductible. Source: Study C, Toyota Tacoma car insurance, October 26, 2026.

The cheapest Tacoma insurer in each study

Study Sample driver Cheapest open to everyone Price
Study C, 2025 Tacoma 40-year-old, $500 deductible Travelers $1,761 a year
Study I, 2025 models 40-year-old male, $500 deductible American Family $1,702 a year
Study H, all model years 40-year-old male, $1,000 deductible GEICO $136 a month
Study D 40-year-old male, $500 deductible Progressive $1,896 a year
Study A, 2025 Tacoma 30-year-old male Progressive $1,464 a year
Study B, 2023 Tacoma Real customer quotes, $1,000 deductible State Farm $135 a month
Study J Customer quotes and rate data State Farm $84 a month

USAA, which sells only to military families, was cheaper still in Studies B and J.

How to get your lowest Tacoma quote

  1. Note your exact truck: generation, trim, cab (XtraCab, Access Cab, or Double Cab), bed length, two- or four-wheel drive, and whether it has the i-FORCE MAX hybrid.
  2. List any lift kit, wheels, bumpers, racks, or other add-ons, because most need extra coverage.
  3. Tell each company honestly how you use the truck, including any work hauling.
  4. Get quotes from Travelers, GEICO, State Farm, and Progressive, then add American Family, Erie, AAA, or USAA where you can.
  5. Compare each quote at the same limits and at both a $500 and a $1,000 deductible, and ask which discounts were applied.

Cheapest liability-only insurance for a Tacoma

Liability-only insurance pays for injuries and property damage you cause to others, but it does not pay to fix or replace your own Tacoma. Study C puts 50/100/50 liability coverage at $1,101 a year for a gas Tacoma and $1,104 for the hybrid, and Study H’s state-minimum average is $96 a month, or $1,157 a year.

40-year-old male, clean record, good credit, state-minimum liability, all model years. Source: Study H, Toyota Tacoma insurance, August 24, 2026.

40-year-old male, clean record, good credit, state-minimum liability, all model years. Source: Study H, Toyota Tacoma insurance, August 24, 2026.

GEICO’s minimum policy costs $63 a month, or $755 a year, which is less than 40% of UAIC’s $162. In Study B’s customer quotes, liability coverage costs $43 a month with USAA, $49 with GEICO, $50 with State Farm, and $56 with Allstate, while Liberty Mutual charges $157.

Where you live changes liability prices as much as the company does. Study H’s state-minimum figures for a Tacoma range from $35 a month in Wyoming and $44 in Vermont to $190 in Louisiana, so the same bare-bones policy can cost more than five times as much from one state to the next.

Is liability-only right for your Tacoma?

Study E estimates that a 2025 Tacoma loses $11,445 in value over its first five years, so most Tacomas stay worth enough to justify full coverage for a long time. Liability-only is worth a look only when all of these are true:

  • The truck is paid off, so no lender or leasing company requires full coverage.
  • You could afford to repair or replace it yourself after a crash, a theft, or storm damage.
  • The yearly cost of comprehensive and collision coverage is a large share of what the truck is worth.

PRO TIP #3

If you drop collision coverage on an older Tacoma, think about keeping comprehensive. It covers theft, fire, hail, flooding, and animal strikes, and for a truck whose tailgate and catalytic converter attract thieves, it is often worth the small extra cost.

Cheapest full coverage for a Toyota Tacoma

Full coverage combines liability with collision and comprehensive coverage. With a new 2026 Tacoma costing about $34,000 to $66,000, nearly every owner with a loan or lease will need it, and most others will want it.

40-year-old male, clean record, good credit, 100/300/100 with a 0 deductible, 2025 models. Source: Study I, Toyota Tacoma insurance cost, April 7, 2026.

40-year-old male, clean record, good credit, 100/300/100 with a $500 deductible, 2025 models. Source: Study I, Toyota Tacoma insurance cost, April 7, 2026.

American Family charges $2,137 a year less than the most expensive AAA club in Study I. The middle of the pack, from GEICO to Amica, sits within about $310 of each other, so a single extra quote can move you from average to cheap.

Study H shows the same pattern for a 2025 Tacoma with a $1,000 deductible. GEICO charges $166 a month, Travelers $188, and Progressive $193, while AIG charges $444.

Full coverage for a 2025 Tacoma by company, Study H (per month)

Insurer Full coverage State minimum
GEICO $166 $76
Travelers $188 $102
Progressive $193 $104
National General $206 $100
Nationwide $225 $130
The Hartford $246 $144
UAIC $254 $201
State Farm $257 $123
Allstate $287 $149
AAA $293 $141
Kemper $297 $144
Amica $311 $152
Farmers $338 $191
Chubb $342 $172
AIG $444 $177

40-year-old male, clean record, 100/300/100 with a $1,000 deductible for full coverage. Source: Study H, August 24, 2026.

PRO TIP #4

Raising your deductible from $500 to $1,000 lowers the price of collision and comprehensive coverage. Before you do it, make sure you could pay $1,000 out of pocket the day your truck goes into the shop.

Insuring a new 2026 or 2027 Tacoma

The fourth-generation Tacoma arrived for 2024 and carried into 2026 with no major changes. The base SR uses a 2.4-liter turbocharged four-cylinder with 228 horsepower, most other gas trims get 278 horsepower with the automatic or 270 with the six-speed manual, and the i-FORCE MAX hybrid makes 326 horsepower. A properly equipped Tacoma can tow up to 6,500 pounds.

Demand has held up well. Toyota sold 214,875 Tacomas through September 2026, up 5.1% from a year earlier, keeping it first among midsize pickups.

No study had published company-level insurance rates for the 2026 Tacoma when we checked, so the 2025 model is the newest year with full data. Study E’s five-year cost-to-own estimates for the 2026 truck put insurance at $2,410 a year for the XtraCab, $2,489 for the Double Cab, and $2,761 for the i-FORCE MAX Double Cab.

2026 Toyota Tacoma trims and starting prices, including destination

Trim Starting price Cab Engine
SR $34,190 XtraCab or Double Cab i-FORCE, 228 hp
SR5 $38,280 XtraCab or Double Cab i-FORCE, 278 hp
TRD PreRunner $40,780 XtraCab, two-wheel drive i-FORCE, 278 hp
TRD Sport $42,060 Double Cab i-FORCE or i-FORCE MAX
TRD Off-Road $44,460 Double Cab, four-wheel drive i-FORCE or i-FORCE MAX
Limited $55,215 Double Cab, four-wheel drive i-FORCE or i-FORCE MAX
Trailhunter $65,395 Double Cab, four-wheel drive i-FORCE MAX, 326 hp
TRD Pro $66,395 Double Cab, four-wheel drive i-FORCE MAX, 326 hp

Starting prices include a $1,745 destination charge as reported in May 2026. Earlier 2026 reports used a $1,595 charge. The i-FORCE MAX adds about $3,700 to the TRD Sport, TRD Off-Road, and Limited compared with the same four-wheel-drive gas truck.

For 2026, Toyota added new colors, made a tow hitch standard on the SR XtraCab, and gave the TRD Off-Road Premium package 18-inch wheels with 32-inch all-terrain tires. For 2027, Toyota had not published US prices or a full list of changes as of early November 2026, though a new color for the TRD Pro has been reported.

How safe is the current Tacoma?

The Tacoma Double Cab earned a 2024 Top Safety Pick from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), but that award came before IIHS ran its updated moderate overlap test on the truck. When it did, the 2024 to 2026 Double Cab scored Marginal, because the rear-seat dummy’s lap belt slid onto its abdomen. The 2026 crew cab remains rated Marginal in the updated test, so the cited IIHS results do not establish a 2025 or 2026 Top Safety Pick award. See the IIHS 2026 Tacoma crew-cab ratings for the exact tested body style.

The rest of its IIHS results are strong. The Double Cab scores Good in the small overlap and updated side tests and for preventing front crashes with other vehicles and pedestrians, and its headlights rate Acceptable on every trim. In federal testing, secondary sources list a four-star overall rating, with three stars for the driver in the frontal crash test on the 2025 crew cab.

Every 2026 Tacoma comes with Toyota Safety Sense 3.0, which includes a pre-collision system with pedestrian detection, lane departure alert with steering assist, full-speed adaptive cruise control, lane tracing assist, road sign assist, automatic high beams, and Proactive Driving Assist.

Recalls to check before you insure

In August 2026, Toyota announced a recall affecting certain 2024–2025 Tacoma TRD Off-Road vehicles and some 2024 Tacoma Hybrids equipped with specified shock absorbers. Dealers inspect and replace affected assemblies free of charge. Confirm applicability by VIN; the recall does not apply to every Tacoma. An earlier 2024 recall covered 381,199 third-generation Tacomas from 2022 and 2023 for rear axle parts that could loosen.

PRO TIP #5

Run your Tacoma’s VIN through the federal recall lookup at nhtsa.gov before you buy a used truck. A recall does not by itself establish a premium increase; promptly completing a covered safety repair can reduce vehicle-related safety risks.

How much Tacoma insurance costs on average

Nine studies publish a Tacoma average, and most fall between about $2,000 and $2,600 a year for full coverage. The differences come mostly from the sample driver’s age, the deductible, and whether the study priced a new or an older truck.

Average full coverage for a Toyota Tacoma by study

Study Full coverage Liability only Sample driver and coverage
Study I (Apr 2026) $2,584 a year — 40-year-old male, $500 deductible, 2025 models
Study C (Oct 2026) $2,542 a year $1,101 a year 40-year-old, $500 deductible, 2025 model
Study E (Oct 2026) $2,489 a year — Cost-to-own estimate, 2026 Double Cab
Study D (Tacoma page) $2,345 a year — 40-year-old male, $500 deductible
Study H (Aug 2026) $2,241 a year $1,157 a year 40-year-old male, $1,000 deductible, all years
Study J (Nov 2026) $185 a month $106 a month Customer quotes and rate data
Study B (Nov 2026) $183 a month $92 a month Customer quotes, ages 20 to 70, $1,000 deductible
Study F (Jun 2026) $200 a month — 30-year-old in Texas, $500 deductible, 2023 model
Study A $2,036 a year — 30-year-old male, 2025 model

The Tacoma sits in the middle of Toyota’s lineup for insurance cost. In Study C, its $2,542 average is higher than the RAV4 at $2,414, but lower than the 4Runner at $2,636, the Tundra at $2,777, and the Camry at $2,889.

Gas vs. i-FORCE MAX hybrid

The hybrid costs more to insure, but the gap depends on the study. Study D reports $2,779 a year for the hybrid; its gas comparison varies by model/section, so do not treat a $237 difference as a verified matched-trim premium. In Study I, the gap on the same trim is much smaller, at $14 for the TRD Off-Road, $23 for the Limited, and $58 for the TRD Sport. Liability-only coverage costs almost the same for both, at $1,101 and $1,104 in Study C.

Tacoma insurance vs. other pickups

The Tacoma costs about the same to insure as most midsize pickups. Study D priced nine of them for the same 40-year-old driver, and only $153 a year separates the cheapest from the most expensive.

40-year-old male, 100/300/100 full coverage. Source: Study D, brand pages for Jeep, Ford, Nissan, Toyota, Chevrolet, Honda, GMC, and Hyundai, March 23, 2026.

40-year-old male, 100/300/100 full coverage. Source: Study D, brand pages for Jeep, Ford, Nissan, Toyota, Chevrolet, Honda, GMC, and Hyundai, March 23, 2026.

The Tacoma ranks fourth of nine, and for an 18-year-old it does even better, coming in third at $8,260 a year behind the Gladiator and the Maverick. Full-size trucks cost more: Study D puts the Ford F-150 at $2,696, the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 at $2,724, and the Toyota Tundra at $2,777. Study I found the same pattern, with the Tacoma at $2,584 against $2,778 for the Silverado and $2,974 for a Ram truck.

Tacoma vs. rival pickups for an 18-year-old, Study D (per year)

Truck Age 18 Age 40
Jeep Gladiator $8,114 $2,460
Ford Maverick $8,206 $2,488
Toyota Tacoma $8,260 $2,542
GMC Canyon $8,305 $2,558
Honda Ridgeline $8,310 $2,547
Chevrolet Colorado $8,343 $2,546
Nissan Frontier $8,361 $2,539
Hyundai Santa Cruz $8,365 $2,613
Ford Ranger $8,485 $2,564
Toyota Tacoma Hybrid $8,960 $2,779
Toyota Tundra $8,996 $2,777

Tacoma insurance by state and city

Your state can matter more than your trim. In Study I, full coverage on a Tacoma ranges from $1,525 a year in Hawaii to $4,322 in Louisiana, a gap of $2,797 for the same driver and truck.

Cheapest and most expensive states for Tacoma insurance, Study I

Cheapest states Per year Most expensive states Per year
Hawaii $1,525 Louisiana $4,322
Maine $1,595 Nevada $3,499
Vermont $1,638 Michigan $3,485
New Hampshire $1,656 California $3,378
Idaho $1,734 Florida $3,085
Ohio $1,784 Colorado $3,082
Indiana $1,830 Washington, D.C. $3,050
Wyoming $1,920 South Carolina $3,005

40-year-old male, full coverage with a $500 deductible, 2025 models. Source: Study I, April 7, 2026.

Study J, which blends customer quotes with rate data, ranks the states a little differently. Its cheapest states for a Tacoma are New Hampshire at $67 a month and North Carolina at $68, and its most expensive is Washington, D.C., at $240, followed by Maryland at $232.

Texas comes in at $2,976 a year in Study I, and Florida at $3,085. Louisiana was the most expensive state in Studies C, D, H, and I, and Hawaii, Maine, Vermont, New Hampshire, and Idaho were among the cheapest in most of them.

40-year-old male, full coverage with a 0 deductible, 2025 models. Source: Study I, April 7, 2026.

40-year-old male, full coverage with a $500 deductible, 2025 models. Source: Study I, April 7, 2026.

Company choice matters even more inside a single state. Study C’s Florida figures for a 2025 Tacoma show how wide the range can be.

Full coverage for a 2025 Tacoma in Florida by company, Study C (per year)

Insurer Per year
State Farm $1,770
Nationwide $2,008
Travelers $2,221
UAIC $2,645
Mercury $3,151
GEICO $3,163
Progressive $3,574
Farmers $3,791
Allstate $3,946
AIG $5,753

In Florida, State Farm charges $1,770 a year while AIG is listed at $5,753, more than three times that source’s State Farm sample; this is not a promise of either quote. GEICO, one of the cheapest companies nationally, ranks sixth of 10 there, which is why the best and cheapest Toyota Tacoma insurance in your state may come from a different company than the national rankings suggest.

Big cities push prices higher. New York costs $6,467 a year in Study I, two and a half times the national Tacoma average, while Chicago was the cheapest of the 10 cities at $2,889.

PRO TIP #6

Garaging address matters. If you keep your Tacoma at a ranch, cabin, or second home in another state for most of the year, tell your insurer, because rating it at the wrong address can cause problems with a claim.

Tacoma theft and repair costs

Whole-truck theft is less of a problem for the Tacoma than for full-size pickups. The Tacoma was not among the National Insurance Crime Bureau’s 10 models with the highest reported theft counts in 2025, while the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 ranked fourth and the Ford F-150 seventh. It also missed the Highway Loss Data Institute’s (HLDI) list of the 20 most-stolen 2022 to 2024 models, which included nine pickups.

In HLDI’s earlier report on 2021 to 2023 models, theft losses for third-generation Tacomas ranged from 16 to 54 on a scale where 100 is the average for all vehicles. Large pickups as a group scored 220 on the same measure.

The real theft risk: parts

For some Tacoma owners, theft of parts is a practical concern, although the cited local reports do not establish that parts theft is more common nationwide than whole-vehicle theft. In 2024, police in Costa Mesa, California, counted at least 20 stolen pickup tailgates in a few months, and 19 came from Tacomas. A repair shop owner put the cost of a replacement tailgate, with paint and camera recalibration, at $2,500 to $4,500. In a 2023 ranking based on Carfax data, the Tacoma was fourth among vehicles targeted for catalytic converter theft.

Both kinds of loss fall under comprehensive coverage, not liability, which is one more reason to keep it even on an older truck.

Repair and claim costs

RepairPal puts the Tacoma’s average yearly repair bill at $478, below the $548 average for midsize trucks, although it ranks the Tacoma last of seven midsize trucks for reliability with a 3.5 out of 5 rating. On the insurance side, HLDI rates collision losses for small pickups, the class that includes the Tacoma, at 81, well below the all-vehicle average of 100. Comprehensive losses for the class average $179.59 per insured vehicle each year, against $233 for all passenger vehicles.

For hybrid owners, Toyota covers the i-FORCE MAX battery for 10 years or 150,000 miles, and the coverage transfers to later owners.

PRO TIP #7

A tailgate lock costs far less than a comprehensive deductible. Adding one, along with a catalytic converter shield, can help you avoid both the claim and the deductible you would pay on it.

Tacoma insurance costs by trim

Trim choice moves a Tacoma premium more than it does for most cars, but less than the company you pick. In Study I, the 11 gas and hybrid trims of the 2025 Tacoma range from $2,474 a year for the TRD PreRunner to $2,962 for the Trailhunter, a spread of $488. The sections below cover every fourth-generation trim first, then every third-generation trim.

40-year-old male, clean record, 100/300/100 with a 0 deductible, 2025 models. Source: Study I, Toyota Tacoma insurance cost, April 7, 2026.

40-year-old male, clean record, 100/300/100 with a $500 deductible, 2025 models. Source: Study I, Toyota Tacoma insurance cost, April 7, 2026.

Fourth-generation gas trims (2024 to present)

Six fourth-generation trims come with the gas i-FORCE engine. In Study I they cost $2,474 to $2,716 a year to insure, and the order does not always follow the sticker price.

Tacoma SR

The SR is the entry-level Tacoma, starting at $34,190 for 2026 with the 228-horsepower engine, and it comes as an XtraCab or a Double Cab. It costs $2,493 a year to insure in Study I, the second-lowest of any trim, and Study E’s estimate for the 2026 XtraCab, which covers the SR, SR5, and TRD PreRunner, is $2,410 a year.

Tacoma SR5

The SR5 adds the 278-horsepower version of the engine and starts at $38,280. Insurance in Study I runs $2,551 a year, $58 more than the SR. Like the SR, it can be ordered as an XtraCab or a Double Cab, with two- or four-wheel drive.

Tacoma TRD PreRunner

The TRD PreRunner is an XtraCab with a long bed and two-wheel drive, priced from $40,780. It is the cheapest Tacoma to insure in Study I at $2,474 a year, $19 less than the SR, even though it costs about $6,600 more to buy.

Tacoma TRD Sport

The TRD Sport is a Double Cab that starts at $42,060 with the gas engine, and it can be ordered with a six-speed manual or the i-FORCE MAX hybrid. The gas version costs $2,616 a year to insure in Study I.

Tacoma TRD Off-Road

The TRD Off-Road is the four-wheel-drive Double Cab built for trails, starting at $44,460. It costs $2,639 a year to insure in Study I, just $23 more than the TRD Sport. Owner reports say the August 2026 shock absorber recall mainly affects 2024 and 2025 trucks of this trim, so check your VIN if you own one.

Tacoma Limited

The Limited is the luxury trim, a four-wheel-drive Double Cab with a short bed that starts at $55,215. It is the most expensive gas trim to insure in Study I at $2,716 a year, $242 more than the TRD PreRunner.

XtraCab vs. Double Cab

The smaller XtraCab costs a little less to insure than the four-door Double Cab. Study E’s 2026 estimates put the XtraCab at $2,410 a year and the Double Cab at $2,489, a difference of $79. In the fourth generation, the XtraCab comes only on the SR, SR5, and TRD PreRunner.

PRO TIP #8

Buying a new Tacoma for value? In Study I, the TRD PreRunner costs less to insure than the SR, and the SR5 costs only $58 more, so you can step up in equipment without much change in your premium. The biggest jump comes with the Trailhunter.

Fourth-generation i-FORCE MAX hybrid trims

The i-FORCE MAX pairs the turbocharged engine with an electric motor for 326 horsepower. It is optional on the TRD Sport, TRD Off-Road, and Limited and standard on the TRD Pro and Trailhunter. Every hybrid trim costs more to insure than its gas twin, though the gap varies widely by study.

i-FORCE MAX hybrid trims: insurance cost and 2026 price

Hybrid trim Study I (year) Study H (month) 2026 MSRP before destination
TRD Sport i-FORCE MAX $2,674 $234 to $239 $46,935
TRD Off-Road i-FORCE MAX $2,653 $238 to $240 $47,235
Limited i-FORCE MAX $2,739 $284 to $286 $56,495
Trailhunter $2,962 $320 to $323 $63,350
TRD Pro $2,682 $328 to $330 $64,350

Full coverage. Study I: 40-year-old male, $500 deductible, 2025 models. Study H: 40-year-old male, $1,000 deductible; it lists each hybrid trim twice, so both figures are shown. MSRP excludes the destination charge.

Tacoma TRD Sport i-FORCE MAX

The hybrid TRD Sport costs $2,674 a year to insure in Study I, $58 more than the gas TRD Sport, the largest same-trim gap in that study. Study H puts it at $234 to $239 a month, about $32 to $37 more than its gas TRD Sport listing.

Tacoma TRD Off-Road i-FORCE MAX

The hybrid TRD Off-Road is the cheapest hybrid Tacoma to insure in Study I at $2,653 a year, only $14 more than the gas version. At $47,235 before destination, it is also one of the least expensive ways to get the 326-horsepower powertrain.

Tacoma Limited i-FORCE MAX

The hybrid Limited costs $2,739 a year in Study I, $23 more than the gas Limited, and $284 to $286 a month in Study H. With an MSRP of $56,495, it is the top luxury hybrid Tacoma.

Tacoma Trailhunter

The Trailhunter is a four-wheel-drive off-road trim that comes only as a hybrid. It is the most expensive Tacoma to insure in Study I at $2,962 a year, $488 more than the TRD PreRunner, and Study H lists it at $320 to $323 a month. Its 2026 price starts at $65,395 with destination.

Tacoma TRD Pro

The TRD Pro is the most expensive Tacoma to buy, at $66,395 with destination for 2026. The studies disagree on its insurance cost: Study I puts it at $2,682 a year, below the Limited hybrid and the Trailhunter, while Study H lists it as the most expensive trim at $328 to $330 a month.

Is the hybrid worth the higher premium?

For most buyers, the insurance cost is a minor part of the decision. Study I’s same-trim gaps of $14 to $58 a year are small, while Study D’s overall gap is $237 a year, and Study E’s estimate for the 2026 i-FORCE MAX Double Cab is $272 a year more than the gas Double Cab. Toyota’s 10-year, 150,000-mile hybrid battery warranty also limits one of the biggest worries for used hybrid buyers.

PRO TIP #9

Torn between a gas and a hybrid TRD Off-Road? Have the same company quote both on the same day. Across the studies, the hybrid gap ranged from $14 to $272 a year, so only a side-by-side quote shows what it will cost you.

Third-generation Tacoma trims (2016 to 2023)

Model identification correction: The 2016–2023 Tacoma lineup did not include a factory PreRunner trim. Some rate tables appear to mix older PreRunner configurations with later trucks; we exclude those mislabeled rows from the third-generation comparison.

The third-generation Tacoma costs less to insure than the new one. In Study I, a 2016 to 2023 Tacoma costs $2,000 to $2,443 a year, against $2,584 to $2,597 for the 2024 and 2025 trucks.

Two sources give third-generation trim figures. Study D’s trim table does not name a model year, but its model-year data runs only through 2023. Study H lists trucks by cab and bed length without model years, so its figures are shown for the third-generation naming it uses.

Third-generation Tacoma trims: insurance cost

Trim Study D (year) Study H, Double Cab (month) Study H, Access Cab (month)
SR $2,295 $164 $149
SR5 $2,401 $171 to $176 $156
TRD Sport $2,309 $176 to $183 $171
TRD Off-Road $2,313 $177 to $186 $178
Limited $2,452 $197 to $208 —
TRD Pro — $202 —
Trail Special Edition — $190 —
Nightshade — — —

Full coverage. Study D: 40-year-old male, 100/300/100, $500 deductible. Study H: 40-year-old male, 100/300/100, $1,000 deductible; ranges cover the 5-foot and 6-foot beds. A dash means no figure was published.

2016 to 2023 Tacoma SR

The SR was the third generation’s base trim. Study D puts it at $2,295 a year, and Study H lists an SR Access Cab at $149 a month, one of the lowest figures for any Tacoma.

2016 to 2023 Tacoma SR5

At $2,401 a year, the SR5 is the second-most expensive trim in Study D. Study H puts the SR5 Double Cab at $171 to $176 a month and the Access Cab at $156.

2016 to 2023 Tacoma TRD Sport

The TRD Sport costs $2,309 a year in Study D and $176 to $183 a month as a Double Cab in Study H. It sits close to the SR on price despite its sportier equipment.

2016 to 2023 Tacoma TRD Off-Road

The TRD Off-Road costs $2,313 a year in Study D, only $4 more than the TRD Sport. Study H puts the Double Cab at $177 to $186 a month, depending on bed length.

2016 to 2023 Tacoma Limited

The Limited is the most expensive third-generation trim to insure in Study D at $2,452 a year, $165 more than the PreRunner. Study H lists the Limited Double Cab at $197 to $208 a month.

2017 to 2023 Tacoma TRD Pro

The TRD Pro joined the third-generation lineup for 2017. Study H lists the third-generation TRD Pro Double Cab at $202 a month, well below the $328 to $330 it lists for the fourth-generation TRD Pro hybrid.

Tacoma Trail Special Edition

Toyota introduced the Trail Special Edition for 2021 as an SR5-based truck, and the 2023 version added a lift and a locking rear differential. Study H lists the Trail Special Edition Double Cab at $190 a month, between the SR5 and the Limited.

Tacoma Nightshade Edition

The Nightshade Edition, also new for 2021, was based on the Limited. No study published a separate Nightshade figure, so the Limited, at $2,452 a year in Study D, is the closest published guide.

Access Cab vs. Double Cab

In Study H, third-generation Access Cabs cost $5 to $15 a month less than the same trim as a Double Cab for the SR, SR5, and TRD Sport, or $60 to $180 a year. The TRD Off-Road costs about the same in either cab.

PRO TIP #10

If you own a 2022 or 2023 Tacoma, confirm that the 2024 rear axle recall was completed. The repair is free, and a future buyer is likely to ask whether it was done.

Tacoma insurance by model year

The jump from the third to the fourth generation is the biggest step in the Tacoma’s insurance history. In Study I, a 2023 Tacoma costs $2,443 a year and a 2024 costs $2,597, a 6% increase, while Study H shows a 30% jump, from $189 to $245 a month.

40-year-old male, full coverage with a 0 deductible. Source: Study I, Toyota Tacoma insurance cost, April 7, 2026.

40-year-old male, full coverage with a $500 deductible. Source: Study I, Toyota Tacoma insurance cost, April 7, 2026.

Interestingly, the 2025 Tacoma costs $13 a year less than the 2024 in Study I, and Study H shows the same dip, from $245 to $233 a month. Study A goes further, with a 2025 Tacoma at $2,036 a year against $2,134 for a 2024.

Average Tacoma premium by generation

Generation Model years Study I average Study A average Study H average
Fourth 2024 to present $2,591 a year $2,085 a year $239 a month
Third 2016 to 2023 $2,209 a year $1,774 a year $176 a month
Second 2005 to 2015 $1,869 a year (2015 only) $1,394 a year (2011 to 2015) —

Our averages of each study’s published model-year figures. Study I: 40-year-old male. Study A: 30-year-old male. Study H: 40-year-old male, $1,000 deductible, 2016 to 2025 only.

Fourth generation (2024 to present)

The current Tacoma costs the most to insure, at about $2,590 a year in Study I. Its higher prices and newer technology help explain the jump.

Third generation (2016 to 2023)

The third generation averages about $380 a year less than the fourth in Study I. Prices climb steadily with each model year, from $2,000 for a 2016 to $2,443 for a 2023.

Second generation (2005 to 2015)

The oldest Tacomas in the data cost the least, at $1,869 a year for a 2015 in Study I and as little as $1,339 for a 2011 in Study A. The sporty X-Runner was part of this generation and ended after 2014.

What real customers paid by model year

Study B’s customer quotes, which use a $1,000 deductible, show the same steady climb. Full coverage from the three cheapest companies rises by about half from a 2014 to a 2023 Tacoma.

Full coverage by model year from real customer quotes, Study B (per month)

Model year USAA* State Farm GEICO
2023 $122 $135 $140
2021 $103 $114 $118
2019 $99 $109 $113
2017 $89 $98 $102
2015 $84 $92 $96
2014 $83 $92 $95

Drivers aged 20 to 70 with a clean record. *USAA sells only to military families. Source: Study B, November 2, 2026.

Which companies are cheapest for older Tacomas?

Travelers led Study C for most years from 2018 to 2025, with USAA slightly cheaper for military families in 2019 and 2020. For the oldest trucks in Study A, American Family and USAA beat Progressive, with American Family charging $1,076 a year for a 2011 and USAA $986.

PRO TIP #11

Shopping for a used Tacoma to keep insurance low? A 2022 or 2023 third-generation truck costs about $150 to $235 a year less to insure in Study I than a 2024, and you still get a relatively new truck.

Work trucks, lifts, and off-road trips: what your policy covers

A Tacoma is often more than a commuter, and how you use it can change both your price and whether a claim gets paid. These are the three areas where truck owners most often run into coverage gaps.

Using your Tacoma for work

Driving to and from a job is normal personal use, but carrying tools, materials, or customers’ goods can cross into business use. GEICO says commercial coverage is needed when a vehicle is used for hauling work-related equipment, transporting goods, or making deliveries, and that a personal policy can be insufficient when a vehicle is used for work. It lists electricians, plumbers, HVAC workers, contractors, landscapers, and snowplow services among the drivers who may need a commercial policy.

Allstate’s business auto checklist names similar triggers:

  • Carrying goods or passengers for pay.
  • Driving to or between job sites.
  • Making deliveries.
  • Hauling tools or equipment.
  • Visiting clients or transporting employees.

GEICO says delivery and rideshare driving need a rideshare add-on or endorsement, and it lists a business title as one factor that points to a commercial policy. Tell your insurer exactly how you use the truck before a claim, not after.

Lifts, wheels, bumpers, and other upgrades

Many pickup owners add lift kits, larger tires and wheels, bumpers, light bars, racks, and bed covers. A standard policy may not pay full value for those parts after a theft or crash. Progressive’s custom parts and equipment coverage helps pay to repair or replace items you add to modify a vehicle, such as custom wheels, paint, or a stereo, and it says the coverage typically has a $5,000 limit.

Keep receipts and photos of every upgrade, and add up what they cost before you choose a limit. A heavily built Tacoma can carry well over $5,000 in parts, so ask each company how much it will cover and whether a larger limit is available.

Off-road and trail driving

Trims like the TRD Off-Road, TRD Pro, and Trailhunter are built for dirt roads and trails, but your insurance may not see it that way. Coverage for damage that happens off the pavement depends on your policy wording, and damage from racing or organized competition is commonly excluded. Some insurers also sell separate off-road vehicle policies, but those are written for ATVs and similar vehicles, not pickups.

Before a trail trip, read the exclusions section of your policy or ask your agent directly whether trail damage to your truck would be covered. It is a short call that can prevent a very expensive surprise.

Optional coverages worth a look

A few add-ons matter more for a truck owner than for the typical driver:

  • Rental reimbursement. J.D. Power found the average repair took 15.3 days in early 2026, which is a long time to go without a truck you rely on for work or towing.
  • Roadside assistance. New Tacomas come with two years of ToyotaCare roadside help, so you may not need to pay for it right away, but older trucks used far from town can benefit from it.
  • Gap coverage. With prices up to about $66,000, a financed Tacoma can be worth less than the loan in the first years, and J.D. Power found that about one in four total-loss customers with a loan were paid less than they owed.
  • Accident forgiveness and new car replacement. The Hartford’s AARP program, for example, includes accident forgiveness after five clean years and new car replacement, both useful on a newer truck.

Toyota’s own insurance program

Toyota Auto Insurance offers a 5% upfront discount, uses genuine Toyota parts when available, and works with Toyota certified collision centers. It also links with ToyotaCare roadside assistance, offers rideshare and pet coverage options, and can cover other vehicles in your household. It was sold in about a dozen states as of its last announced expansion, so check whether it is available where you live.

PRO TIP #12

Planning a lift or bigger tires? Call your insurer before the install, not after. Some modifications change how a truck is rated, and it is better to know the cost, and add custom parts coverage, before you spend the money.

Tacoma insurance with a ticket, accident, or DUI

A single violation can cost a Tacoma owner more than any trim upgrade. Study J, which blends customer quotes with rate data, puts the average Tacoma premium at $146 a month with a clean record. A speeding ticket raises that to $196, an at-fault accident to $209, and a DUI to $245, an increase of 68%.

Source: Study J, Toyota Tacoma car insurance, November 2, 2026. The study does not publish its full driver profile.

Source: Study J, Toyota Tacoma car insurance, November 2, 2026. The study does not publish its full driver profile.

Study J lists State Farm among the lowest sampled prices after a violation, including a $123 DUI figure. Because the published profile is incomplete, do not interpret it as a generally available DUI rate. GEICO was the next-cheapest national option after an accident at $143 a month and after a DUI at $161.

PRO TIP #13

After a ticket or accident, do not just accept your renewal. In Study J, State Farm charged $122 a month less than the average for a driver with a DUI, so a full round of quotes is worth the time.

10 discounts that cut Tacoma insurance costs

Several large discounts fit Tacoma owners, especially those who insure more than one vehicle or a home with the same company. Here are 10 to ask about, with the largest amounts insurers print on their own websites.

Maximum amounts printed by each insurer; most apply only to some coverages and vary by state. Sources: insurer discount pages, November 2026.

Maximum amounts printed by each insurer; most apply only to some coverages and vary by state. Sources: insurer discount pages, November 2026.

  1. Bundle your policies. Progressive says new customers who bundle save more than $1,000, Nationwide reports $1,032, The Hartford averages $963, and Farmers advertises 10% or more.
  2. Insure every vehicle with one company. GEICO offers up to 25% for more than one vehicle, and Progressive’s multi-car discount averages 12%.
  3. Try a driving app. State Farm’s Drive Safe and Save and Liberty Mutual’s RightTrack go up to 30%, USAA’s SafePilot gives up to 10% to start and 30% at renewal, Nationwide’s SmartRide gives 10% for signing up, and Progressive says Snapshot drivers save $328 on average.
  4. Keep a clean record. GEICO offers up to 22% for drivers with a clean record, and The Hartford offers up to 10% after five clean years.
  5. Ask about hybrid discounts. Travelers and The Hartford both list one for hybrids, which covers the i-FORCE MAX, though neither prints the amount.
  6. Ask about new-vehicle discounts. Travelers lists a discount for vehicles less than three years old, except in California, and USAA offers one too.
  7. Get credit for safety equipment. State Farm offers up to 40% off medical-related coverage for factory airbags, and GEICO lists 5% for anti-lock brakes.
  8. Claim good student savings for young drivers. State Farm offers up to 25%, GEICO up to 15%, and Progressive starts at 5%.
  9. Use military discounts. GEICO offers up to 15% off the total premium for active-duty, retired, Guard, and Reserve members and up to 25% for drivers deployed overseas.
  10. Buy online or through Toyota. Progressive’s online quote and online signing discounts average 7% and 10%, The Hartford gives 8% for starting a quote online, and Toyota Auto Insurance offers 5% upfront where it is sold.

PRO TIP #14

Discounts do not always stack the way you expect, so compare final prices rather than discount lists. A company that offers fewer discounts can still be cheaper for your Tacoma once everything is added up.

Best and cheapest Tacoma insurance for teen drivers

Insuring a teen in a Tacoma is expensive, and safety experts do not point teens toward pickups. The 2026 IIHS and Consumer Reports list of recommended vehicles for teens includes no pickups at all, and coverage of the list noted that it steers young drivers away from larger SUVs and pickups.

No study published Tacoma rates by company for each teen age, so this section combines Tacoma-specific figures for 18-year-olds with national teen data by age. Study D puts an 18-year-old male driver in a gas Tacoma at $8,260 a year, more than three times the $2,542 a 40-year-old pays.

Adding a teen to a parent’s full-coverage policy by company, Study C (per year)

Company Parents only With a teen girl With a teen boy
Travelers $2,164 $4,733 $5,390
USAA* $1,574 $4,805 $5,062
Nationwide $2,932 $5,864 $6,199
GEICO $2,748 $5,931 $6,535
State Farm $3,047 $6,457 $7,610
Progressive $2,566 $6,958 $7,448
Farmers $4,090 $8,419 $8,981
Allstate $4,271 $8,778 $9,352

National data with no specific test vehicle; the study does not state the teen’s age. *USAA sells only to military families. Source: Study C, teen car insurance costs, August 13, 2026.

Travelers had the lowest family total with a teen girl in Study C, and USAA had the lowest with a teen boy. On average, adding a teen raises a family’s premium by $4,515 a year in that study.

Cheapest Toyota Tacoma insurance for a 16-year-old

Sixteen is the most expensive age to add to a policy. Study D found that adding a 16-year-old raises a family’s premium by about $4,050 a year, and Study C found that GEICO was the cheapest national company for a 16-year-old on their own policy, at $8,436 a year. These are different sample populations and policy structures; obtain family-policy and separate-policy quotes before drawing a savings conclusion.

Cheapest Toyota Tacoma insurance for a 17-year-old

Prices drop at 17. Adding a 17-year-old costs about $3,740 a year in Study D, and GEICO was again the cheapest national company for a 17-year-old with their own policy in Study C, at $6,937 a year, about $1,500 less than at 16.

Cheapest Toyota Tacoma insurance for an 18-year-old

Eighteen is the age with the most Tacoma-specific data. Study D puts an 18-year-old male at $8,260 a year in a gas Tacoma and $8,960 in a Tacoma Hybrid, and Study I puts the same age at $8,383.

In Texas, Study F found an 18-year-old pays $702 a month for a 2023 Tacoma, but only $541 for a 2015, so an older truck saves a teen real money. Travelers was the cheapest national company for an 18-year-old on their own policy in Study C, at $5,566 a year, and adding an 18-year-old to a family policy costs about $3,478 a year in Study D.

Cheapest Toyota Tacoma insurance for a 19-year-old

By 19, Travelers was the cheapest national company for a teen on their own policy in Study C, at about $4,465 a year, and adding a 19-year-old to a family policy costs about $3,105 a year in Study D. For drivers under 25, Study J found USAA cheapest at $122 a month, followed by State Farm at $134, Allstate at $173, and GEICO at $189.

Ways to cut a teen’s Tacoma premium

  • Keep the teen on a parent’s policy rather than buying a separate one.
  • Choose an older Tacoma or a lower trim like the SR or TRD PreRunner, since those cost the least in the trim data.
  • Ask for good student discounts of up to 25% at State Farm and up to 15% at GEICO.
  • Have the teen use a driving app, since State Farm, Liberty Mutual, and USAA all offer up to 30%.
  • Requote every year, because prices fall noticeably from 16 to 19.

PRO TIP #15

For a family adding a teen, get Travelers and USAA quotes first. They had the two lowest family totals with a teen driver in Study C, and both rank well for financial strength.

Tacoma insurance for drivers 65 and older

Senior Tacoma owners get some of the best rates. Study J puts seniors at $126 a month, $20 less than adults overall, and its cheapest companies for older Tacoma drivers were USAA at $65 a month, State Farm at $71, Allstate at $92, GEICO at $100, and CSAA at $110.

Rates do creep up again with age. Study D’s national data, which does not use a specific vehicle, shows full coverage rising from $2,353 a year at 65 to $2,498 at 70 and $2,742 at 75.

Full coverage at 100/300/100 with a 0 deductible; no test vehicle named. Source: Study D, car insurance for seniors, April 16, 2026.

Full coverage at 100/300/100 with a $500 deductible; no test vehicle named. Source: Study D, car insurance for seniors, April 16, 2026.

Travelers, the cheapest company for a 2025 Tacoma in Study C, was also the cheapest company open to everyone in Study D’s senior data at $1,987 a year. The two senior studies disagree on Allstate and State Farm, which were among the cheapest in Study J but among the most expensive in Study D, so seniors should quote both.

Ways older Tacoma owners can save

  • Take a defensive driving course. AARP lists 33 states plus Washington, D.C., that require insurers to give a discount for an approved classroom course, and Kiplinger says AARP’s online course can earn a multiyear discount of up to 10%.
  • Look at The Hartford’s AARP program, which offers up to 10% for members, 5% for a defensive driving course, and up to 15% for joining its TrueLane driving program.
  • If you no longer commute or tow often, report your lower mileage and ask about pay-per-mile coverage.

PRO TIP #16

If your Tacoma now mostly sits at home between trips to the hardware store or the lake, ask your insurer to update its usage from commuting to pleasure. GEICO lists pleasure as a separate usage class from commuting, and the change can lower your rate.

Tacoma insurance for military families

USAA is a relevant option for eligible service members, veterans, and family members, alongside competing quotes. It had the lowest Tacoma price of any company in Study B’s customer quotes, at $122 a month for a 2023 truck, and in Study J at $76 a month. It costs $1,859 a year for a 2025 Tacoma in Study C and $1,721 in Study A.

Full coverage; no test vehicle named. Source: Study D, best car insurance for military members, August 13, 2026.

Full coverage; no test vehicle named. Source: Study D, best car insurance for military members, August 13, 2026.

All nine companies in Study D charged military members less than civilians, with gaps from $107 a year at USAA to $507 at Allstate. GEICO’s military rate of $1,951 a year was $197 below its civilian rate.

Military discounts for Tacoma owners

  • USAA advertises up to 60% off for a stored vehicle, except in North Carolina and Virginia, and up to 15% off comprehensive coverage when the vehicle is garaged on a military base.
  • GEICO offers up to 15% off the total premium for active-duty, retired, Guard, and Reserve members, and up to 25% for drivers deployed overseas.
  • Armed Forces Insurance arranges auto coverage for military families through partner companies.

PRO TIP #17

Do not stop at a USAA quote. In Study D, Travelers charged military members $1,818 a year, only $353 more than USAA, and GEICO charged $1,951, so a second quote can confirm you are getting the best deal.

Tacoma insurance in five cartoon panels

Cartoon guide with numbered panels on the best and cheapest Toyota Tacoma insurance: 1, shop around, Travelers 1,761 dollars versus Farmers 3,562 dollars a year for a 2025 Tacoma in Study C; 2, pick your trim, TRD PreRunner 2,474 dollars versus Trailhunter 2,962 dollars a year in Study I; 3, gas or hybrid, 2,542 dollars versus 2,779 dollars a year in Study D; 4, your state, Hawaii 1,525 dollars versus Louisiana 4,322 dollars a year in Study I; 5, your record, 146 dollars a month with a clean record, 196 dollars after a speeding ticket, and 245 dollars after a DUI in Study J; tip, insure your lift and wheels with custom parts coverage.

An original cartoon summary of five ways to find the best and cheapest Tacoma insurance.

FAQs about the best and cheapest Toyota Tacoma insurance

Who has the cheapest Tacoma insurance?

Travelers had the lowest price for a 2025 Tacoma among companies open to everyone in Study C, at $1,761 a year. American Family led Study I, GEICO led Study H, Progressive led Studies A and D, and State Farm led the customer-quote Studies B and J. USAA was cheaper still for military families.

How much does Tacoma insurance cost per month?

For a 40-year-old with full coverage, most studies put it between about $187 and $215 a month. Liability-only coverage runs about $92 to $106 a month.

Which Tacoma trim is cheapest to insure?

The TRD PreRunner, at $2,474 a year in Study I, followed by the SR at $2,493. The Trailhunter is the most expensive at $2,962.

Does the i-FORCE MAX hybrid cost more to insure?

Yes, but usually not by much. Study D puts the hybrid at $237 a year more than the gas Tacoma, while Study I’s same-trim gaps are just $14 to $58 a year.

Is the TRD Pro expensive to insure?

It depends on the study. Study I puts the TRD Pro at $2,682 a year, less than the Limited hybrid and the Trailhunter, while Study H lists it as the most expensive Tacoma at $328 to $330 a month. Its $66,395 price means collision and comprehensive coverage will cost more than on a base truck.

Which states have the cheapest Tacoma insurance?

Hawaii was the cheapest state in Study I at $1,525 a year, followed by Maine, Vermont, New Hampshire, and Idaho. Louisiana was the most expensive at $4,322.

Is the Tacoma cheaper to insure than the Tundra?

Yes. Study D puts the Tacoma at $2,542 a year and the Tundra at $2,777, a difference of $235.

Is the Tacoma cheaper to insure than other midsize trucks?

It is about average. In Study D, it ranks fourth of nine midsize and compact pickups, behind the Jeep Gladiator, Ford Maverick, and Nissan Frontier, and only $153 separates the cheapest truck from the most expensive.

Why did insurance go up on the 2024 Tacoma?

The redesigned 2024 Tacoma costs more to buy and has newer technology, and most studies with both years price it higher than the 2023. The increase was 6% in Study I and about 30% in Study H.

Is the Tacoma an IIHS Top Safety Pick?

Not for 2025 or 2026. The Double Cab earned a 2024 Top Safety Pick, but it has since scored Marginal in the updated moderate overlap test because of rear-seat belt performance.

Is the Tacoma a common target for thieves?

The whole truck is not, since the Tacoma was not on the 2025 list of the 10 most-stolen vehicles. Its tailgate and catalytic converter are popular with thieves, so comprehensive coverage is worth keeping.

Does my policy cover a lifted Tacoma?

Standard coverage may not pay full value for aftermarket parts. Add custom parts and equipment coverage, which typically has a $5,000 limit at Progressive, and ask about higher limits if your build costs more.

Do I need commercial insurance for a work Tacoma?

You might. GEICO says commercial coverage is needed for hauling work equipment, transporting goods, or making deliveries, and it lists contractors and other tradespeople among the drivers who may need it.

What will a teen pay to drive a Tacoma?

A lot. Study D puts an 18-year-old male at $8,260 a year in a gas Tacoma, and Study I puts the same age at $8,383. Adding a teen to a parent’s policy is usually far cheaper.

Are 2027 Tacoma insurance rates available?

Not yet. No study had published company-level rates for the 2026 Tacoma, and Toyota had not released 2027 prices in early November 2026, so quote your exact truck before you buy.

The essential Toyota Tacoma insurance numbers in a single graphic.

The essential Toyota Tacoma insurance numbers in a single graphic.

The final word on the best and cheapest Toyota Tacoma insurance

The Tacoma is an average-cost pickup to insure, close to the Frontier, Colorado, and Ridgeline and well below the Tundra and full-size trucks. Within the lineup, the TRD PreRunner and SR cost the least to insure, the Trailhunter costs the most, and the i-FORCE MAX hybrid adds anywhere from a few dollars to a few hundred a year.

The biggest savings come from choices you control. Travelers, GEICO, American Family, State Farm, and Progressive each led at least one study on price, USAA is the pick for military families, and Amica, Nationwide, and Erie stand out for service. Quote at least four companies, tell each one how you really use your truck, insure your upgrades, and shop again whenever you change trucks, add a driver, or move.

Sources

Disclaimer

This article compares published rate studies, customer satisfaction research, crash-test results, and financial ratings for the Toyota Tacoma and Tacoma i-FORCE MAX. It is meant as general information only and is not insurance, legal, tax, or financial advice, and it is not a substitute for reading your own policy. All prices are averages, estimates, or sample quotes for the driver profile each source chose.

Your actual premium will depend on your state and ZIP code, age, driving and claims history, credit where allowed, the drivers in your household, how you use your truck, any modifications, your Tacoma’s trim, cab, and model year, and the coverage limits and deductible you select. Coverage for business use, aftermarket parts, and off-road driving depends on your policy wording, so confirm it with your insurer.

This site reviews insurers independently and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Toyota Motor North America, Inc., Toyota Insurance Management Solutions, J.D. Power, AM Best, or any insurer named here, including Travelers, GEICO, USAA, American Family, State Farm, Progressive, Erie, Nationwide, AAA, The Hartford, Amica, Auto-Owners, Kemper, National General, Allstate, Farmers, Liberty Mutual, Chubb, AIG, UAIC, and Armed Forces Insurance.

No company paid to be included or saw this article before publication, and our rankings reflect editorial judgment, not endorsements. Toyota, Tacoma, i-FORCE MAX, TRD, Trailhunter, and other trim names are trademarks of their owners.

Related Articles